The sweet in a glass of tea came from somewhere, and in this country the somewhere had a name. In 1860, nearly all the cane sugar grown in the United States came out of one state.

The federal census volume Agriculture of the United States in 1860, printed by the Government Printing Office in 1864, says it plainly on page c: "Louisiana produces over two hundred and twenty-one million of the two hundred and thirty million pounds raised in the whole United States."

The table on the page before it counts cane sugar in hogsheads of 1,000 pounds each: 221,726 for Louisiana, out of 230,982 for all the states. By our math, that is 96 percent.

So when this piece talks about what sugar cost, it is not talking about somewhere far away. It is talking about Louisiana, and it is going to let the documents do the talking.

The Receipt: Eighteen Hours in Twenty-Four

Start with a man who was there against his will. The title page of Twelve Years a Slave (Derby and Miller, 1853) calls Solomon Northup a citizen of New York "kidnapped in Washington City in 1841 and rescued in 1853, from a cotton plantation near the Red River in Louisiana."

On pages 193 and 194, Northup is hired out to a planter on Bayou Salle, sent into the field to cut cane, and then moved into the sugar house to act as a driver. He writes: "From the time of the commencement of sugar making to the close, the grinding and boiling does not cease day or night."

Then he tells you what the job was. "The whip was given me with directions to use it upon any one who was caught standing idle. If I failed to obey them to the letter, there was another one for my own back."

And what it did to him: "I had no regular periods of rest, and could never snatch but a few moments of sleep at a time."

On page 195 he adds that "On cane plantations in sugar time, there is no distinction as to the days of the week," and that "all hands must labor on the Sabbath."

Now a traveler's book. Frederick Law Olmsted's A Journey in the Seaboard Slave States (Dix and Edwards, 1856) records on page 650 what a commercial traveler told him about sugar plantations: in the grinding season, under the usual system, eighteen hours of work were required in every twenty-four, "leaving but six for rest."

Eighteen pages later, on page 668, a sugar planter Olmsted calls Mr. R. says it about his own place. During the last grinding season, "nearly every man, woman, and child on his plantation, including his overseer and himself, were at work fully eighteen hours a day." The fires under the boiler never went out, and people rested six hours in the twenty-four, in relays.

To be exact about who said what: the eighteen-hour figure comes from the traveler and the planter. Northup's sugar pages give no hour count. What he gives is a sugar house that never stopped and a man who never got regular rest.

Northup also tells you who else worked in that sugar house. Describing the mill on the plantation where he spent three seasons, he writes on page 211: "All along the endless carrier are ranged slave children, whose business it is to place the cane upon it."

That is what the page says, so that is what this piece says, and it stops there.

Why It Costs You: The Missing Children

If you want to know what that work did to people, you do not need an adjective. A historian counted.

In "The Demographic Cost of Sugar," published in the American Historical Review in December 2000, Michael Tadman describes Louisiana's sugar parishes as "a miserable island of natural decrease in the midst of the otherwise consistent pattern of natural increase that stretched across the cotton, tobacco, and rice plantations of the United States."

Here is his measurement. In the 1840s, enslaved people across the United States had a typical natural increase rate of 27.8 percent. Tadman calculates that the sugar area "experienced at best a 6 percent natural decrease," and says the real situation was probably substantially worse.

In the 1850s, he finds the sugar parishes had "a rate of natural decrease of over 13 percent," against an expected natural increase of 23.4 percent for typical enslaved people in the United States.

Natural decrease means deaths outran births. Tadman puts it without softening: "deaths greatly exceeded births among slaves in the main sugar parishes." Planters kept buying people all the same. He notes that local agricultural societies "routinely reported intensive slave importation combined with natural decrease among slaves."

Then he asks what the decrease was made of, and the answer is why worked to death is only part of the story. For the 1850s, he estimates that excess deaths among people aged ten and older accounted for about 44 percent of the gap. The shortage of children under ten accounted for the other 56 percent.

He breaks the child shortage down too. About 40 percent of it came from a scarcity of women who could bear children. The rest came from low fertility among the women who were there and high child mortality.

The 1860 numbers show the shape of it. In the thirteen leading sugar parishes, enslaved people aged 15 to 49 numbered 28,205 males and 19,946 females. For every 1,000 women in that age range there were 922 children under ten, where the figure for enslaved people in the United States generally was 1,320.

Tadman says why the men outnumbered the women. Louisiana's sugar planters "persistently imported far more males than females, and they did this because they wanted a male-dominated labor force."

Our read, and we mark it as a read: planters bought for the cane, and the families that purchase kept from forming are part of what sugar cost.

How the Machine Works: It Was Not the Swamp

There is an easy explanation people reach for, and Tadman closes the door on it. Nearly all of western Louisiana, he writes, including a large tract of cotton parishes, sat "in the same high-risk malaria belt as the sugar parishes." The cotton parishes had no child shortage.

His sentence: "Malaria brought many deaths and much debility, but it took the labor demands of sugar to produce natural decrease."

The scale matters, and it makes the point sharper. Tadman writes that sugar planting "was always of very minor significance in North America," that at its height it employed no more than about 6 percent of enslaved people, and that it was "almost entirely confined to a group of parishes in southern Louisiana." A small sector, and a uniquely lethal one by this country's standards.

That is also why the Caribbean belongs in this story without being blurred into it. "In the Americas as a whole, however, sugar was the great plantation crop," Tadman writes. And he says Louisiana's experience "would have been better than that of typical sugar plantations of the Caribbean and South America," where the people imported "nearly always came from Africa" and so suffered what he calls the "dreadfully high mortality levels" of the seasoning period.

This piece gives the Caribbean no percentage. Tadman's comparison says enough: the worst place in the United States was not the worst place sugar went.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

The planter had an answer, and Olmsted wrote it down on page 668. Mr. R. said the people he held were "as glad as he was himself to have the time for grinding arrive," and worked "with greater cheerfulness than at any other season."

Olmsted, who believed him on this point, gave his reasons: in that season "they are then better paid; they have better and more varied food and stimulants than usual, but especially they have a degree of freedom, and of social pleasure, and a variety of occupation which brings a recreation of the mind, and to a certain degree gives them strength for, and pleasure in, their labor." The traveler on page 650 said the same about food, that during grinding they were "liberally supplied with food and coffee."

Northup, on page 195, confirms one piece of it. Enslaved people hired out in sugar time, as he was, were understood to "receive remuneration" for Sunday work.

Olmsted's next sentence says what the rewards were for: "Men of sense have discovered" that to get "extraordinary exertions" from enslaved people, it is better to offer rewards than to whip them. The traveler on page 650 said that on all sugar plantations people were worked "excessively, in the grinding season; often cruelly." Northup, put in the sugar house as a driver, was handed the whip for anyone "caught standing idle."

Our read: whatever freedom the season allowed did not change Tadman's count. In the 1850s, most of the sugar parishes' gap was children who were never born or did not live.

What You Can Actually Do

Open the pages yourself, free. Northup's pages 194, 195 and 211 and Olmsted's pages 650 and 668 are on Documenting the American South at the links above, with the original page numbers marked. The census page is a scan you can read from the Census Bureau's own server.

Tadman's article is at the journal's DOI link above; the Receipts below also carry a free full-text copy, which has no page numbers, so cite the article, not a page.

Then read the two pieces that sit on either side of this one: who paid for the ice, and the 1791 pamphlet about sugar.

Come Back for the Rest

Subscribe to The Long Pour for the next receipt.

The So-What

In 1860, Louisiana grew 221,726 of the 230,982 hogsheads of cane sugar the census counted in the United States. In the thirteen leading sugar parishes that year, Tadman counts 922 children under ten for every 1,000 women aged 15 to 49, where the figure for enslaved people across the country was 1,320. For the 1850s, Tadman attributes some 44 percent of the parishes' shortfall to excess deaths among people ten and older, and the remaining 56 percent to childhood factors: a shortage of women, low fertility and high child mortality.

The Receipts

Book and article passages were read in full text; the census pages were read on the page scan.