For years, barges have carried Puerto Rico's coal ash up the St. Johns River to a terminal in Talleyrand, which has stored it and trucked it to a landfill in Georgia. On Tuesday the city said stop. Mayor Donna Deegan announced an order telling Keystone Terminals to quit taking coal ash at its Wigmore Street terminal and to clear out what is already there. The company says it never needed the permit the city is talking about.
So we are going to ask the two questions this show always asks. Who decided it should go. And who got paid.
The Receipt
The honest frame first. The city's order, the notice before it and Keystone's letter back have not been published. Everything below is three outlets' reading of them, and this piece says whose. This desk has drafted a public records request to the city for all three; it has not yet been sent, the owner of this show sends it, and this piece will be corrected against the paper when it arrives.
The Jacksonville Daily Record read the city's release after the news conference and lists what the order requires: "Stop receiving any additional solid waste, including coal ash, at the terminal." "Remove all stored ash within 45 days and deliver it only to a facility lawfully permitted to accept it." "Control dust and runoff during removal." "Report weekly to the city on the amount of ash removed and where it was taken." If Keystone does not comply, the paper reports, "The company could face civil penalties of up to $2,000 per day if the city takes that step, according to the release."
Jacksonville Today has the same deadline: 45 days to get whatever ash is on site to a "lawful facility." Action News Jax adds the clock: "The company was served the order Monday. Keystone has five business days to stop receiving, accepting or storing any additional solid waste."
The legal hook is not the ash. It is a certificate. The Daily Record: "The city claims Keystone has never applied for or received a Certification of Public Convenience and Necessity, a requirement under city code for any business that stores, processes or transfers solid waste in Duval County." The paper names the entities: "City officials claim Keystone Properties LLC and Keystone Investments II LLC have been operating a solid waste facility without meeting local ordinance code requirements," and adds that state Division of Corporations records put both at 1915 Wigmore St., which is Keystone Terminals' address.
Why It Costs You
The mayor's case, as Jacksonville Today quotes her: "This operation has never been reviewed by the city as required by local ordinance code. Coal ash is not a benign material. According to the EPA, it contains contaminants such as mercury, cadmium and arsenic."
The scale is a claim in a federal complaint, not a city number. Jacksonville Today reports that the Public Trust for Conservation and the St. Johns Riverkeeper "filed a Clean Water Act and Resource Conservation and Recovery Act lawsuit on Aug. 19 against the Keystone Terminal," and that "Since 2022, the Riverkeeper claims, Keystone has handled more than 2 billion pounds of potentially toxic coal ash at its Jacksonville facility". The plaintiffs' figure; this desk has not read the complaint. What the city says it knows is narrower and, for the people near Wigmore Street, enough: an operation handling that material ran for years with no city review at all.
That is the cost. Not a line on your tax bill. A review the city says its code required and that did not happen, in a neighborhood that did not get asked.
How the Machine Works
Here is how it runs. Jacksonville Today reports that the shipments began after Puerto Rico outlawed permanent coal ash storage in 2017, that the barges travel almost 18 miles up the St. Johns to Talleyrand, and that the ash then goes to a landfill in Folkston, Georgia. The Daily Record's account of the city's position is the same chain: a Puerto Rican power plant's ash comes in, sits at the terminal, and leaves for a landfill in another state.
One jurisdiction decided it would not keep the ash. Another took it. A third buries it. The middle link, as Action News Jax puts it, calls itself a bulk material handling facility; the city's position, per the station, is that a facility storing coal ash is a solid waste management facility, and this one has no certificate.
The sequence: Jacksonville Today says the city's formal notice of violation went out Oct. 13 and gave Keystone 30 days to prove it was authorized to operate, and that the company's response, in the mayor's words, "was not satisfactory." Action News Jax describes the response: "In a letter to the city, Keystone pushed back on the claims. It said it is not a solid waste facility and that temporarily storing coal ash doesn’t mean it needs a city certificate. The company also said the Florida Department of Environmental Protection is aware of its operations and hasn’t required a state solid waste permit for that operation." Then the order, served Monday.
The certificate is not a state environmental permit. It is a city question. The mayor, as Jacksonville Today quotes her: "The rules for handling solid waste in Jacksonville apply to everyone, and they exist to protect the people who live and work nearby. Every other facility that stores or transfers solid waste in our city must go through the certification process. Keystone does too."
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
Keystone's position deserves its full weight. The company's statement, carried by all three outlets: "We do not believe the work being done at our Talleyrand facility requires this level of permitting, but we are working with the city to do what is necessary to resolve this issue." Its letter, as Action News Jax describes it, makes two real arguments. Definitional: a transfer point that holds material temporarily is not a solid waste facility. Institutional: the state agency that regulates solid waste knows what Keystone does and has not asked it for a permit. If the state has looked and passed, a company can fairly ask why a city certificate is suddenly the thing that stops it.
The counter is the city's. The state permit and the city certificate are different questions. The Daily Record's reading of the code is that the certificate applies to "any business that stores, processes or transfers solid waste in Duval County," and the company's description of what it does, as Action News Jax relays its letter, temporarily storing coal ash, lands inside that sentence. Whether the city is right is for a court or a council. That the question was never put to the city before Tuesday is not disputed by anyone quoted in the three accounts.
What You Can Actually Do
First, the hearing. Jacksonville Today reports: "When Keystone files for a permit to receive solid waste that approval process will include a City Council review and public hearing, with nearby property owners invited to comment before any vote." No application has been reported and no date exists. When one is filed, it lands on a council committee agenda, and a reader who has watched this show read a council land-use file knows the drill.
Second, the clocks. Action News Jax reports the order was served Monday, which was November 16, with five business days to stop accepting solid waste and 45 calendar days to remove what is there. Counting from the day after service, this desk puts those at Monday, November 23, and December 31. Those are the show's counts against the station's account; no outlet has published the order's text. The Daily Record reports the order requires weekly reports on the amount removed and where it went. Those are public records the moment they are filed. So is the order, and the records request this desk has drafted, not yet sent, asks for it.
The So-What
The ash is the headline. The certificate is the story. For years a terminal in Talleyrand took in a material the mayor now calls not benign, from an island that had banned keeping it, and the city says its own code required a review and a hearing first. It got neither. Not because anyone voted no. Because nobody asked.
That is not a paperwork lapse with a health side effect. That is what the paperwork was for.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced to the account it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Every account below was captured and read by this desk on November 18; the city's order, the Oct. 13 notice and Keystone's letter were not published and are not cited.
- City to Keystone Terminals: No more coal ash (Jacksonville Daily Record, November 17, 2026; accessed November 18, 2026): the order's four requirements; $2,000 per day; the certificate; the two LLCs and the Wigmore St. address.
- Storage of coal ash must stop at Jacksonville's Keystone Terminal: city order (Jacksonville Today, Dan Scanlan, November 17, 2026; accessed November 18, 2026): "lawful facility"; Oct. 13 notice; the mayor's quotations; the Aug. 19 suit; 2 billion pounds; the council hearing; Puerto Rico's 2017 ban.
- City orders Keystone Terminal to stop accepting solid waste at Talleyrand coal ash operation (Action News Jax, Deja Mayfield, November 17, 2026, 5:04 p.m.; accessed November 18, 2026): Keystone's letter as described; served Monday; five business days; 45 calendar days; "bulk material handling facility".