Cheap ice in the South was not an accident of weather. Somebody set the price, and somebody else was supposed to lose.

Charleston had a taste for it before Frederic Tudor showed up. The historian Richard O. Cummings, in The American Ice Harvests (University of California Press, 1949), writes on page 6 that the city's market was large enough by 1799 to justify an ice depot, one "set up by a hotelkeeper" who supplied subscribers.

The Receipt: Eight and a Third Cents, and a Request

Nic Butler of the Charleston County Public Library dates the opening of the Tudor ice house on Fitzsimons's Wharf to early 1817.

Its advertisement priced ice at "eight and a third cents a pound," with a four percent allowance for people who bought in quantity or by ticket, as Gavin Weightman prints it on page 127 of The Frozen-water Trade (Thorndike Press, 2003).

Then came the ask. The ad invited Charleston to buy enough ice to keep that price, and said the price could not hold unless ice was used "rather as a necessary of life than as a luxury."

Mary Caroline Crawford printed the same advertisement in Old Boston Days & Ways in 1909, from a clipping in a Tudor journal she says was then in the possession of his grandson.

She calls the paper a "Charleston, North Carolina" paper, which is her error; Fitzsimons's Wharf was on the Cooper River in Charleston, South Carolina.

Why It Costs You: A Necessity Is a Standing Order

Here is this show's read, and it is a read. A luxury is something you buy now and then. A necessity is a bill that comes every day, and the ad said out loud that the low price depended on people buying like it was one.

Weightman's page 125 quotes a writer who expected the pleasure to stay with the few who could pay for it. The lines we could see there read "Charleston and its Invirons [sic] alone can enjoy the pleasant Effect and are able to pay for their exclusive Benefits."

The lines we could see do not show who wrote it, so this piece does not name the writer.

How the Machine Works: A Penny a Pound, Then the Rest

Cummings, on page 14, credits Tudor's solidly built storage depots with an advantage, "for he could sell at a penny a pound until an 'interferer's' ice supply," and there the visible fragment stops.

A second fragment on the same page reads: "melted at the dock and then raise prices to a more profitable level."

The next sentence is Cummings's verdict: "In this he took savage glee."

We could not see what sits between those two fragments, and the second never prints Tudor's name in its visible lines, so read its "he" as the subject of a page about Tudor, not as a name we saw.

The same fragment turns to a man who arrived at Savannah with a supply, and Cummings writes that "he confided to his diary." The snippet ends before the diary's words, and this show has not read that diary.

Butler, writing for the library, tells the Charleston end in his own terms. Low prices and a steady supply, he writes, built a market that "soon generated perpetual demand."

And the rivals? "A few other local proprietors tried to pry their way into the ice market as well, but none survived more than a year or two of competition with the Tudor empire of ice."

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Cheap ice was good for the people buying it, and Tudor may have believed in it. Crawford, in 1909, wrote that he was driven by faith in what everyday ice would do for people in hot places, no less than by the chance of getting rich.

The ad made its own case, too, arguing that with nearly $10,000 invested and the waste in even a well-built ice house, "the profit cannot be more than reasonable" however much people bought.

Butler adds that the Charleston business "was not exactly profitable in the early years, according to contemporary newspaper reports," and that it survived because it was essentially a franchise of a larger enterprise under the Tudor Ice Company.

Our read, marked as a read: both things can be true in the same season. A price can cool a kitchen and sink a competitor at once, and the historian's page 14 tells you which one the penny was for.

What You Can Actually Do

Open the pages yourself. Search Cummings's book for "penny a pound" and "interferer," and Weightman's for "eight and a third," using the Google Books links above, and read Crawford's page 396, where the advertisement begins, free on the Internet Archive.

Our read, not page 14's words: when a company sells below what anyone else in your town can match, ask what happens to the price after the rivals are gone.

The So-What

Somebody always pays for the cheap part. In Charleston, the ad told buyers they were paying for a habit, and the historians tell you who else paid: whoever tried to sell ice against Tudor.

Come Back for the Rest

We open the page so you never have to take anybody's word for it, ours included. Subscribe to The Long Pour, and the next receipt lands in your inbox.

The Receipts

Book pages were read in Google Books snippet view unless the line says otherwise.

  • The American Ice Harvests: A Historical Study in Technology, 1800-1918 (Richard O. Cummings, University of California Press, 1949, pp. 6 and 14; accessed September 14, 2026): a market big enough by 1799 for an ice depot, the penny-a-pound advantage, "savage glee."
  • The Frozen-water Trade: A True Story (Gavin Weightman, Thorndike Press edition, 2003, pp. 125 and 127; accessed September 14, 2026): the ad's price and "necessary of life" line, and the page 125 quotation.
  • Old Boston Days & Ways (Mary Caroline Crawford, Little, Brown, 1909, p. 396, continuing to p. 397, full text on the Internet Archive; accessed September 14, 2026): the advertisement's price and wording, from a clipping in a Tudor journal.
  • Charleston's First Ice Age: Importing Frozen Water (Nic Butler, Charleston County Public Library, January 19, 2018; accessed September 14, 2026): the 1817 opening, perpetual demand, rivals gone in a year or two.