Last year the Jacksonville Housing Authority handed the paperwork for the city's biggest rental-assistance program to an outside firm, without taking bids, on a promise of $1.6 million in savings. On Monday its board found more than a million dollars going the other way, for rent, copiers and phones. The CEO who signed the deal was fired three weeks ago. The firm is still there. And on Friday the State Attorney's subpoena comes due.

So this show asks the two questions it always asks. Who decided it should go. And who got paid.

The Receipt

The account is Jacksonville Today's, published Tuesday from Monday's Finance Committee meeting: "The Jacksonville Housing Authority is questioning payments to a consultant who was hired under a no-bid contract by its recently fired CEO." The outlet puts the disputed total in one sentence: "The consulting costs in question, which were paid to a company called Nan McKay, total more than $1 million."

The questions surfaced "three weeks after the board fired CEO Cheron Corbett, with the opaqueness of the agency’s finances cited as one reason." This show covered that firing, and the words that mattered then were without cause.

Every figure that follows is Jacksonville Today's reading of what staff presented to the committee. This desk has not read the committee packet.

Why It Costs You

The program is the Housing Choice Voucher pool, which the outlet calls "the largest rental assistance program in the city, primarily serving low-income families and the elderly or disabled." Federal rent money, paid through a local authority to landlords, for Jacksonville tenants who cannot otherwise make the rent.

Here is how the outsourcing was sold. Jacksonville Today, crediting Action News Jax, writes that "50 positions were outsourced to Nan McKay, with a promised savings of $1.6 million." Here is what the board heard Monday. Interim CEO Roslyn Mixon-Phillips, in the outlet's quotation: "There were a number of operational costs that were still being absorbed by the agency." The outlet describes those costs, "which amount to a shade more than $1 million for 2025 and 2026," as "categorized as “rent, copier, phone, things like that.”" It adds that "They appear to be related to having people working onsite who weren’t actually employed by the housing authority." The outlet's summary: the costs "ate up most of that promised savings."

The ledger, per Jacksonville Today: "Nan McKay’s total expenses were almost $7.3 million, so the flagged costs are 15% of what the company charged JHA." And the program itself: "records presented at the meeting show a 2026 loss to the voucher program of about $467,000, though some federal reimbursements are still outstanding, according to staff. Before the consultant’s hiring, the housing authority reported a net profit for the program in 2024 and 2025."

How the Machine Works

First, the contract was never competed. The outlet's lede says no-bid, and so does the prosecutor. This show read the stations' accounts of State Attorney Melissa Nelson's subpoena last week; Jacksonville Today now writes that it covers "a wide range of JHA’s records, including some related to Nan McKay, due this Friday." News4JAX's report of that instrument gives the date: it "requires the agency to produce documents by Nov. 20, 2026." This desk has not read the subpoena.

Second, the savings were overhead, and overhead does not leave when the employees do. A copier lease, a phone line and office space are agency costs until somebody cancels them. By the outlet's reading, nobody did, across 2025 and 2026.

Third, the auditors had already flagged the program. The authority's own audited financial statements for the year ended September 30, 2025, signed June 26, 2026, carry a "Qualified Opinion on Housing Voucher Cluster," because, in the auditor's words, the authority did not comply with "requirements regarding Eligibility for the Housing Voucher Cluster as described in findings 2025-001." The audit does not name the firm and this piece does not connect the finding to it. It says only that the board had a document before Monday telling it the voucher program needed watching.

The board's answer Monday was that it could not yet tell what it was looking at. Board member Robin Smith, in the outlet's quotation: "We’re just getting our heads around what is this costing? What is the benefit? That’s a question I personally cannot answer". The outlet reports Smith requested "another day" to digest the figures.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

The firm's case was made in the room, and it is not nothing. Jacksonville Today reports that Nan McKay's representative "told the board the company was able to help get the housing authority’s voucher waitlist moving again, leading to homes for 450 people who likely were waiting on affordable housing for years." If that holds, 450 households got off a list that had not moved, which is the entire point of the program. The representative also said, per the outlet, that the reimbursement amount "is under negotiation." The firm is not refusing to talk about the million. And an authority that cannot read its own voucher ledger, by its own board member's account, is a shaky witness to what a vendor cost it.

The counter is the one the board raised. A no-bid contract sold on $1.6 million in savings has, on staff's figures, produced a seven-million-dollar vendor bill, a million in overhead the agency kept paying, and a program that went from profit to loss. The 450 placements are real only if the waitlist records say so, and the waitlist, per News4JAX's reading of the subpoena, is one of the things the State Attorney asked about.

What You Can Actually Do

Two dates.

Friday, Nov. 20. The subpoena's return date, per News4JAX. What the authority produces is a public record in its own hands under Chapter 119, the chapter this show read when the authority put a $90,000 price on a reporter's request. Ask for the production index, the Nan McKay contract and the procurement file that let it skip bidding.

Monday, Nov. 23. The full board votes on the fired CEO's severance. The committee, per Jacksonville Today, "approved a contractually obligated severance package for Corbett but reduced the number of weeks to 20 from 22, citing state law," and "A final payment amount will be presented to the the full board for a vote Nov. 23." The account does not say which law. Florida's s. 215.425(4)(a) says a government severance clause "may not exceed an amount greater than 20 weeks of compensation," and s. 421.05(2) says housing authorities set their own officers' compensation and, in its own words, "Accordingly, authorities are exempt from s. 215.425." If the committee leaned on the 20-week cap, it leaned on a statute its own enabling act exempts it from. That is a question for Nov. 23, not a conclusion.

The authority's meetings page is where the notice should post. When this desk last captured it, on Nov. 18, the newest entries were the three Nov. 16 committee meetings (Finance and Audit, Human Resources, Tenant Relations) above the Oct. 27 special meeting at which the CEO was fired, and no Nov. 23 notice yet; check it for that notice, the time and place, and for Monday's committee packet, the document every figure in this piece is a report of. The board roster lists the five commissioners who will vote.

The So-What

A public agency outsourced the people who run rent assistance for the city's poorest tenants, without bids, to save $1.6 million. Since then the vendor has billed almost $7.3 million, the agency kept paying the rent on the vendor's desks, the program went from profit to loss, the CEO is gone with a severance the board is still pricing, and the prosecutor's deadline is Friday.

That is not a savings plan with a side effect. That is what a no-bid contract looks like once somebody reads the invoices.

Come back for the rest

We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.

Y'all come back, now.

The Receipts

Every document below was opened and read by this desk from its saved capture; access dates are the day this desk read the capture.