Tonight, Tuesday, Oct. 27, 2026, at 5 p.m., the Jacksonville City Council opens a public hearing on $590,000 of state money for a machine that will scan every ballot cast in Duval County a second time, before the result is certified. That's Ordinance 2026-802, item 46 on the marked agenda, in the Council Chamber on the first floor of City Hall, 117 W. Duval Street.
I want to be careful with this one, because on its face it's good news. A second count of every ballot is the thing people on every side of the aisle say they want. So this show is going to do what it does with good news, which is the same thing it does with bad news. Read the paper. Ask who decided it should go, and who gets paid.
Nothing has been voted. Tonight is the hearing. Nothing in this piece tells you how it ends.
The Receipt
The Council Research Division's summary, dated Oct. 13, 2026, says the bill "appropriates $590,000 in grant funds awarded by the State of Florida, Department of State, Division of Elections, to reimburse the City of Jacksonville for the costs of purchasing a ClearAudit Post-Election Voting Audit System." The summary lists the Council President as introducer, at the mayor's request, and it says "The Supervisor of Elections will oversee the project and the grant."
What the money buys, per the same summary: equipment that "will allow the City to conduct 100 percent post-election voting system audits prior to certification of election results." The grant "covers the cost of the equipment, including eight scan stations, software and services, implementation, and extended warranty and licensing through December 31, 2028." Then the sentence that matters for your wallet: "After that date, the City will be required to continue with the software licensing and maintenance."
The summary's fiscal line says "No local match is required." The grant period runs "from July 1, 2026 through December 31, 2026."
The bill's Exhibit 1 is Budget Transfer BT 26-106, the Supervisor of Elections' request form. It splits the $590,000 two ways: $417,786 for computer equipment and $172,214 for hardware and software maintenance and licenses. The form was initiated Aug. 28, 2026, and the mayor's action on it is dated Sept. 21, 2026.
The agenda's history for item 46 shows the Neighborhoods committee and the Finance committee each read the bill a second time and re-referred it, on Oct. 19 and Oct. 20. No committee has voted it up or down.
Why It Costs You
Start with what it doesn't cost you. The $590,000 is grant money, and the summary says no local match. For the price of the scanners, this is the state's check.
Now the tail. The summary says the licensing and the warranty run through Dec. 31, 2028, and after that the city pays for "software licensing and maintenance." The bill doesn't say how much. The summary doesn't say how much. BT 26-106 puts $172,214 against maintenance and licenses inside the grant, which is the only number anyone has written down for what this software costs to keep alive, and it covers a period that ends two years from now. After that, the line is yours.
The second cost is the one you can't see from the paperwork, and it's the reason this piece exists. The city's bill never names the vendor. The summary never names the vendor. The budget transfer never names the vendor. "ClearAudit" appears in all three as the name of the product. The company that makes it appears in none of them. The only document in this stack that puts a company name next to ClearAudit is the state's own 2018 System Qualification Test Report, from the Division of Elections, whose cover reads "Clear Ballot Group, Inc." above "ClearAudit 1.4.4." That's how this show knows who's getting paid: not from the city's bill, but from a state report that's eight years old.
I'm not saying anybody hid it. I'm saying a $590,000 purchase of a named product went through two committees with the maker's name nowhere on the page, and you shouldn't have to go to a 2018 test report to learn it.
How the Machine Works
Here's what a ClearAudit system does, in the state's words. The 2018 report says the Clear Ballot Group system "captures ballot images, via digital scanning for tabulation, and then independently verifies the results by comparison to the county's election voting system results." Your ballot gets counted by the county's voting system. Then it gets scanned again by a different machine, from a different company, and the two totals get compared. That's the second set of eyes. The state's bureau said it focused its test on "the county's ability to setup, administer, and use the ClearAudit 1.4.4 system independent of vendor support," and in July 2018 it recommended approval for use with the two voting-system families it tested.
Now the law. Florida already requires an audit after every election, and it's smaller than this one. Section 101.591 says that "Immediately following the certification of each election, the county canvassing board or the local board responsible for certifying the election shall conduct a manual audit or an automated, independent audit of the voting systems used in randomly selected precincts." The manual version, under subsection (2)(a), is one race in "at least 1 percent but no more than 2 percent of the precincts." The automated version, under subsection (2)(b), covers every race but only "at least 20 percent of the precincts." Either way, the statute says the audit happens after certification, and it has to be done "no later than 11:59 p.m. on the 7th day following certification."
So read the two numbers side by side, and keep them with their owners. The 20 percent floor is the statute's. The 100 percent is the bill's. Section 101.591 sets a floor, after the fact. Ordinance 2026-802 buys the ceiling, before the fact. That's the whole design, and it's a real upgrade. The statute also says, in subsection (2)(c), that the state's rules for an approved audit system require it to be "Completely independent of the primary voting system." Which is the reason the second machine comes from a second company, and the reason the second company's name belongs on the bill.
Then there's the line I can't explain, so I'm going to show it to you instead. The bill says the grant was "awarded by the State of Florida, Department of State, Division of Elections." The summary says the same. But BT 26-106, the city's own budget transfer, labels the revenue it's moving as "US Election Assistance Commission (EAC)" on its line-item page, and its justification paragraph says the money comes from "the US Elections Assistance Conversion" account. The Election Assistance Commission is a federal agency. The Division of Elections is a state one. Whether the state is passing federal money through to Duval, or the city's budget office reused an old account name, or something else is going on, the documents filed with this bill don't say. I'm carrying that as an open question, not a finding. The one document that would settle it is the Memorandum of Agreement between the state's Division of Elections and Duval's Supervisor of Elections, and per the bill it "has been placed On File with the Legislative Services Division." It isn't attached. It isn't posted. This show has a public records request drafted to the Supervisor of Elections for that agreement, the vendor contract, and the vendor's communications since Jan. 1, 2026. It hasn't gone out yet. When it does, and when the answer comes back, you'll read it here.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
Here's the best case for the bill, and it's a good one. The state is paying. There's no match. The equipment does the thing the audit statute was written to make possible, and does it for every precinct instead of a random fifth of them, before the number becomes official instead of after. In a county the size of Duval, a 100 percent independent audit before certification is about as close to a receipt for your own vote as the law allows anyone to hand you. The Supervisor of Elections oversees it, which is where oversight of an election audit belongs. And the state qualified this specific system in 2018, so the county isn't buying something nobody has tested.
All of that is true, and I'd vote for it. Here's where it runs out. None of it requires the vendor's name to be missing from the bill. None of it explains why a city budget form calls the money federal while the ordinance calls it state. And none of it tells you what the license costs in 2029. A good purchase can survive those three questions. That's what makes it a good purchase.
What You Can Actually Do
Go tonight, or watch. Tuesday, Oct. 27, 2026, 5 p.m., Council Chamber, first floor of City Hall, 117 W. Duval Street. Item 46. The agenda marks it "Open PH" and "Close PH," a public hearing. If you can't be there, the public hearing is the point in the meeting where the clerk reads the bill and the floor opens.
Read the three documents. The bill, the summary, and BT 26-106. They're short. Every figure above is in them.
Ask three questions, out loud or in writing to your council member. Who's the vendor, and why isn't the company on the bill? Is this state money or federal money passed through the state, and why do the ordinance and the budget transfer disagree? What does the software license cost the city after Dec. 31, 2028?
Ask for the agreement. The Memorandum of Agreement is on file with Legislative Services, per the bill. Anyone can ask to see it. We did.
Three More This Show Pulled From Tonight's Agenda
The agenda marks "Open PH" on 45 bills tonight, by this show's count of the capture, and item 46 is one of them. These three are the ones this show picked to read, not the rest of the list, and each gets one line from its own Research Division summary.
Ordinance 2026-804, introduced by Council Member Howland, creates a School Crossing Guard Trust Fund for money the city gets from "school zone speed detection system fines," which the summary says the Sheriff's Office will administer; the summary's fiscal line reads "No fiscal impact." The money it holds is the piece section 316.1896(5)(e) sets aside from each school-zone camera ticket: "Five dollars must be retained by the county or municipality for the School Crossing Guard Recruitment and Retention Program."
Ordinance 2026-803, introduced by Council Member Salem, amends the city charter "to require JEA to televise and/or live-stream all meetings of the governing body of JEA," with recordings posted "within three business days." Because it's a charter change, the summary says it takes "a two-thirds vote," and the agenda sets a second public hearing for Nov. 24.
Ordinance 2026-800, introduced at the request of the Sheriff, sets the Inmate Welfare Trust Fund's budget at $2,280,097.81, of which $1,728,607.38 is for "admission packs, indigent packs, law library supplies, recreational equipment" and software across three facilities: the Pre-Trial Detention Facility, Montgomery Correctional Facility and the Community Transition Center.
And the WareWorks bill this show read last week is item 52 tonight, its own public hearing, with the agenda's history showing second readings and re-referrals and no committee vote yet.
The So-What
Somebody decided Duval should count every ballot twice, and the paper trail for that decision is mostly in order. The state awarded it. The mayor asked for it. The Supervisor of Elections will run it. Two committees have read it. That's what a public purchase is supposed to look like.
Here's the turn. The part of the paper trail that's missing is the part that names a company and a price for the years after the grant runs out. And the one document that would close both gaps is sitting in a drawer at Legislative Services, on file, unattached. I'm for the second set of eyes. I'd just like to know whose they are and what they cost in 2029 before the vote, not after. Tonight at 5 is when you say so.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet decision clears the chamber. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little decisions and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- Ordinance 2026-802 (Jacksonville City Council, introduced Oct. 13, 2026 at the request of the Mayor; accessed October 27, 2026): the $590,000, the 100 percent audit, the 2028 date, the agreement on file.
- Legislative Summary, Ordinance 2026-802 (City Council Research Division, Oct. 13, 2026; accessed October 27, 2026): the grant's purpose, the eight scan stations, no local match, SOE oversight, the grant period.
- Budget Transfer BT 26-106, Exhibit 1 (City of Jacksonville, Supervisor of Elections, initiated Aug. 28, 2026; accessed October 27, 2026): the $417,786 and $172,214 split and the "US Election Assistance Commission (EAC)" revenue line.
- City Council Agenda, Marked, Oct. 27, 2026 (Jacksonville City Council, event 3734; accessed October 27, 2026): 5 p.m., Council Chamber, item 46, the committee history, items 47 and 52.
- Section 101.591, Florida Statutes (Florida Legislature, 2026 Florida Statutes; accessed October 27, 2026): the post-certification audit, the 1 to 2 percent manual and 20 percent automated floors, the seven-day deadline.
- System Qualification Test Report, ClearAudit 1.4.4 (Florida Division of Elections, Department of State, July 2018; accessed October 27, 2026): Clear Ballot Group, Inc. as the maker, what the system does, the 2018 approval.
- Legislative Summary, Ordinance 2026-804 (City Council Research Division, Oct. 13, 2026; accessed October 27, 2026): Council Member Howland's crossing guard trust fund, Sheriff's Office administration, no fiscal impact.
- Section 316.1896, Florida Statutes (Florida Legislature, 2026 Florida Statutes; accessed October 27, 2026): the $5 per ticket retained for crossing guard recruitment and retention.
- Legislative Summary, Ordinance 2026-803 (City Council Research Division, Oct. 9, 2026; accessed October 27, 2026): Council Member Salem's JEA livestream charter amendment, three business days, the two-thirds vote.
- Legislative Summary, Ordinance 2026-800 (City Council Research Division, Oct. 13, 2026; accessed October 27, 2026): the Sheriff's $2,280,097.81 Inmate Welfare Trust Fund budget and the $1,728,607.38 line.