Look at your Florida ballot, any partisan race, top to bottom. The Republican is on the top line and the Democrat is under them. That isn't the alphabet, and it isn't a coin flip. It's one sentence of state law, passed in 1951, when Democrats ran the state.

A federal judge struck that law down in 2019. An appeals court threw his ruling out in 2020. Hold on to the next part: no court in that fight ever said the law was fair. The appeals court said this lawsuit could not be in federal court at all.

So we are going to ask the two questions this show always asks. Who decided it. And who gets the benefit.

The Receipt

Here's the sentence, from section 101.151(3)(a), Florida Statutes: "The names of the candidates of the party that received the highest number of votes for Governor in the last election in which a Governor was elected shall be placed first for each office on the general election ballot." The party that came in second goes second. Minor parties and candidates with no party follow behind them, in the order they qualified.

WUSF has the history: "In 1951, lawmakers passed a bill saying the top spot goes to the party that won the last governor's race." The station reports that Democrats ran the state then and that the Legislature held only a few Republicans. The party running the state when this rule passed was the party it put on top.

It didn't stay that way forever. The Eleventh Circuit's own count, as of 2020, was 20 general elections with Democrats on top and 14 with Republicans on top, the latest 10 in a row. Ron DeSantis won reelection in 2022, so WUSF reports the GOP sits on top again in 2026.

Who decided? A Democratic state, 75 years ago. Who gets the benefit? Whoever is holding the governor's office. That's the part that should bother you, whichever party you're in.

Why It Costs You

The benefit has a name. Researchers call it the primacy effect: a small number of voters pick the first name on the list because it's first.

The expert at the center of this fight is Jon Krosnick, a Stanford professor, and you should know up front that he testified for the plaintiffs in the Florida case. Read his numbers knowing that. He told WUSF: "If in the end it turns out that the actual margins of victory are narrow, if the Republicans win, then there is every reason to believe that they got two to three percentage points extra due to the primacy effect." Notice the conditional in that sentence. It's his estimate, it's about a hypothetical, and it isn't a measurement of any race.

At trial, the appeals court's opinion recounts, Krosnick testified that first-listed candidates on Florida ballots had historically gained an average of about five percentage points. The other side's expert, Michael Barber, a Brigham Young University professor, testified that estimate was not valid. And Krosnick himself agreed that his analysis did not "mean that every Republican candidate receive[s] a [five] percent advantage by being listed first." It's an average. The court's point was that an average says nothing about any one election, and on that much the court is right. Nobody can hand you the value of the top line in a given race, and this show won't pretend to.

Here's what can be said. Darren Grant, who teaches economics at Sam Houston State and has studied the effect too, told WUSF: "Candidates would spend millions of dollars in advertising to try to get a bump of one or two percentage points in the vote." WUSF puts Rick Scott's 2010 win at around 1.2 percentage points and Ron DeSantis's 2018 win over Andrew Gillum at 0.4, and the state's official results for 2010 and 2018 bear that out. Grant's view, as WUSF reports it, is that the top line played a role in those wins. That's his read, and it's a read. No document proves what any close race would have done with the names flipped.

If these experts are even partly right, the candidate on the second line has to buy with money what the first line gets for free, and you get an office decided a little less by anybody's actual choice.

The cost lands lowest on the ballot. WUSF reports Grant found the effect particularly pronounced in down-ballot races. Jonathan Rodden, who testified for the plaintiffs alongside Krosnick, told the court the same thing. Krosnick told the station a lack of information and voter ambivalence help drive it. Now read the statute's list of offices: sheriff, property appraiser, tax collector, county commission. The rule sits hardest, if these experts are right, on the races you know least about, and those are often the ones closest to home.

How the Machine Works

Here's how the fight went, from the court papers.

Three voters and six groups backing the Democratic Party sued the Florida Secretary of State in 2018. The case was Jacobson v. Lee, in the Northern District of Florida. The Republican Governors Association and the party's Senate campaign committee came in to defend the law. After a bench trial, Judge Mark Walker ruled for the plaintiffs on Nov. 15, 2019.

The Secretary and the Republican committees appealed, and the case became Jacobson v. Florida Secretary of State, No. 19-14552. The panel issued an opinion in April 2020, then vacated it and put a new one in its place on Sept. 3, 2020. The September opinion is the one that stands, and it gave several separate reasons the case had to go.

One: none of the voters or groups proved an injury. Two: they sued the wrong official, because Florida law has the 67 county supervisors of elections put names on the ballot, not the Secretary of State. Three: the whole complaint is what courts call a "political question," outside what a federal court may decide. In the majority's words: "No judicially discernable and manageable standards exist to determine what constitutes a 'fair' allocation of the top ballot position." The panel vacated the judgment and told the trial court to dismiss the case because federal courts had no jurisdiction over it.

Read that carefully, because it's the whole story. The court did not hold that the law is fair. On this point it held that federal judges have no standard for deciding what fair would be. Those are very different sentences.

Judge Jill Pryor dissented, and she didn't whisper. She'd have found that the Democratic national committees had standing and that the case could be heard, and she wrote that the majority opinion "introduces error upon error upon error into our precedent." The appeals court denied rehearing on Oct. 28, 2020. On Nov. 9, 2020, Walker vacated his own order and dismissed the case, as the mandate required. His ruling that the law was unconstitutional has no legal force today.

Now the catch. The majority said the plaintiffs should have sued the supervisors. It also said a complaint like this one is a political question. Pryor saw where those two pieces meet: "Even if a plaintiff sues only local elections officials and not the secretary of state, a federal court may refuse to address the merits of her claim on the basis that she has raised a nonjusticiable political question." That's a door with two locks.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

The law's defenders have a real case, and here it is at full strength.

A ballot has to put somebody first. Florida's rule names who, by a method nobody has to interpret, and it flips by itself when the governor's party flips. It has flipped before: the court's tally shows each party has held that line. Election officials testified that the statute helps prevent voter confusion, lets voters find their candidate faster, keeps things uniform across 67 counties and more than 6,000 precincts, and limits ballot layout errors. They also described the logistics of rotating names, and a voting machine vendor's representative said he didn't know whether the machines could rotate the top two spots and that the steps could take up to a year.

WUSF reports the Republican committees wrote, in a motion asking the court to toss the case, that the statute "imposes only minimal burdens on Plaintiffs' constitutional rights," even assuming a top-line advantage exists. The majority went further: the law doesn't make it harder to vote or to pick your candidate, and "All the statute does is determine the order in which candidates appear in each office block on the ballot." Nobody is kept off anything. Every vote gets counted. Krosnick testified for one side, and his estimate was challenged under oath.

That's serious, and it's why this piece won't tell you the law stole any race.

Here's the answer. A ballot needs an order, but it doesn't need this one. WUSF reports other states use "alphabetical order, random drawings or rotating names across ballots in the same election." So handing the top line to the party in power is a choice. Walker, before his order was vacated, found the state's justifications "weak" and "not particularly persuasive," though that finding carries no force now. And there's one small thing in his order worth reading twice. Footnote 1 records that the Republican groups first sought to intervene because their candidates and organizations would "stand to be most directly harmed by a change" in the ballot order, before arguing the order gives nobody a significant advantage. If the top line is worth nothing, it's an odd thing to go to federal court to keep.

What You Can Actually Do

If you're voting by mail, get it in. Under section 101.67(2), a mail ballot must be received by your supervisor of elections by 7 p.m. on election day, Tuesday, Nov. 3. Received, not postmarked. The statute's one cross-referenced exception, section 101.6952(5), gives overseas voters up to 10 days after the election, if the ballot is postmarked or dated by election day.

Do your reading before you get to the bottom of the ballot. Krosnick says a lack of information is part of what drives this. The cure is cheap. Look up the sheriff, the tax collector and the county commission before you vote. WUSF's voter guide covers local and statewide races. Then pick a name because you chose it, not because it was on top.

Ask the people who can change it. The Eleventh Circuit left this with the political branches, so take the court at its word. Ask your state representative and your state senator one question: would you vote to replace section 101.151(3)(a) with rotation, a random draw, or the alphabet? Ask it of both parties. This rule has served both.

The So-What

There's a race on your ballot this year that does double duty. The governor's race picks a governor, and under the statute, the party that draws the most votes also takes the top line on every general election ballot until Florida elects another one, unless the Legislature changes the rule first.

Nobody will ever print that on the ballot. It's still on it.

No court in this case found the law fair. The one that buried the challenge found it out of reach. That is not a verdict. That is a locked door, and the Legislature has held the key since 1951.

Come back for the rest

We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.

If you like reading what a court did not decide, the Supreme Court's mail-ballot order is the same kind of story.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts