On Tuesday, Oct. 27, 2026, the Jacksonville City Council voted 12 to 7 to put Joseph DiSalvo back on the JEA board, and the record of how long that took is written one line at a time. Resolution 2026-0203-A was introduced March 10. By the council's own history file, it then sat in the Rules Committee under one word, "Defer," at twelve meetings in a row, from April 6 to Oct. 5. After that it moved in eight days. The committee approved it 6-1 on Oct. 19, the full council 12-7 on Oct. 27, and the matter now reads "Awaiting Mayor's Signature."
Here is what this desk opened and what it didn't, because the two halves of this piece stand on different legs. The Legistar record is the primary, and every date, tally and name in it is something you can pull up yourself at the two links above. Who DiSalvo is, and why one vote moved on Tuesday night, is Jacksonville Today's reporting, and it is credited to that outlet every time it appears. The same utility's own records show who asked it for 1,248 megawatts, and that is a sibling piece, who asked JEA for 1,248 megawatts; I am leaving it there.
The Receipt
The receipt is matter 8271 in the council's Legistar system. Its title, as the record carries it, calls the resolution one to confirm "the Mayor’s Reappt of Joseph “Joe” P. Disalvo, a Duval County Resident, to JEA," under "Sec 21.03" of "Article 21 (JEA), Jax Charter," for "a 2nd Full Term to Exp on 2/28/30," and the title ends "(Req of Mayor)." So the shape is the charter's: the mayor asks, the council confirms, and the term runs to Feb. 28, 2030.
Under the title, the record keeps its own action log. The lines read "3/10/26 CO Introduced: R," then "3/16/26 R Read 2nd & Rerefer," then "3/24/26 CO Read 2nd & Rerefer." Then nothing in the title line for seven months. Then "10/19/26 R Approve 6-1 (Salem)," and "10/27/26 CO Approve 12-7 (J. Carlucci, Carrico, Diamond, White, Arias, Gay, Salem)." The seven names in that parenthetical are the no votes, in the order the council's clerk typed them.
The nothing is in the history file. Between the March 24 rereferral and the Oct. 19 approval, the Rules Committee's rows are dated April 6, April 20, May 4, May 18, June 1, June 15, July 20, Aug. 3, Aug. 17, Aug. 31, Sept. 14 and Oct. 5. Every one of them carries the same action name, "Defer," and the same action text, "DEFER." That's twelve. I counted them from the file, and you can too. None of the twelve rows carries a tally or a sentence of reason; the API's history rows carry no tallies at all, which is why the 6-1 and the 12-7 live in the title line and not in the log. What eight of the twelve rows do carry is a name in the mover field. May 4, May 18, June 1 and June 15: "Chris Miller." July 20, Aug. 3, Aug. 17 and Oct. 5: "Mike Gay." The other four, April 6, April 20, Aug. 31 and Sept. 14, leave the field empty. So the record says who moved to defer on eight of the twelve days. It still doesn't say why on any of them. The Oct. 27 row is the only one with a story in it: "The Floor Leader moved the item be Approved. The motion CARRIED. Roll Call was ordered. The Chair declared the File Approved."
Do the math on the calendar. From introduction to final vote is 231 days. From the first deferral to the last is 182 days. From the last deferral to the council's approval is 22 days. The record tells you every one of those intervals to the day and tells you the reason for none of them.
Why It Costs You
If you pay a JEA bill, this is the only vote you get on who sits on JEA's board. You don't elect the board. The charter, by the resolution's own title, has the mayor pick and the council confirm, and the council is the part of that sentence you voted for. So the 12 and the 7 are the whole of your say, cast by proxy, on a seat that runs through February 2030.
And for seven months that say was parked. Twelve times a committee met and twelve times the record says "DEFER" and nothing else. That's not a scandal on its face. Committees defer things. But a deferral is a decision not to decide, and the public record of a decision not to decide is, by design, empty. You can look up, on eight of the twelve days, whose name sits in the mover field. You can't look up whether anyone objected, what the committee was waiting for, or what changed between Oct. 5 and Oct. 19 that turned twelve deferrals into a 6-1 approval. The record won't tell you. It's built not to.
Here's the cost, in plain currency. A board seat is where the decisions about your bill get made, and the confirmation of that seat is the one moment the people you elect have to say yes or no in public, on the record, by name. Tuesday they did. The seven months before Tuesday they didn't, and the file that is supposed to be the public's memory of that has twelve identical lines in it.
How the Machine Works
Now the part the record can't give you, and where the outlet's reporting comes in. Jacksonville Today describes the appointee this way: "Joseph DiSalvo, the former JEA board chair who defended former CEO Vickie Cavey amid allegations of creating a hostile work environment, earned reappointment to the board this week after months of deferrals." That characterization, the former chair, the defense of the former CEO, the allegations, is Jacksonville Today's, and the allegations are the outlet's description of a dispute, not a finding this desk is making or passing along as one.
The same outlet lists the seven no votes with their first names, "Raul Arias, Joe Carlucci, Kevin Carrico, Rory Diamond, Mike Gay, Ron Salem and Randy White," which matches the record's parenthetical name for name, and files the vote "under Resolution 2026-0203." The record's file number is 2026-0203-A; the letter is the council's, and the two are the same matter.
Then the one vote that moved, and this is the piece of the machine worth watching. Jacksonville Today reports: "Gay had previously voted in favor of DiSalvo's nomination during the committee process. During the Oct. 27 Council meeting, he cited concerns with DiSalvo's behavior at a February JEA board meeting as a reason for his change, noting DiSalvo did not allow Salem, the liaison to JEA, to speak at the meeting." Read that against the record. The committee's Oct. 19 tally is 6-1 with Salem the one. Eight days later Gay is in the seven. The outlet gives you the reason in Gay's own framing, a February board meeting and a liaison not allowed to speak. The record gives you the math of it, a 6-1 that became a 12-7, and not one word about why.
Now put the mover field next to that. The name on the record's last four Rules Committee deferrals, July 20, Aug. 3, Aug. 17 and Oct. 5, is "Mike Gay." The council member Jacksonville Today says switched his vote is Mike Gay. The record gives a name in a field and nothing more about him; the outlet names the same council member. Read the sequence the two documents make together. By the record, that name moves to defer four times through the summer and into October. By the outlet, that council member "had previously voted in favor of DiSalvo's nomination during the committee process," and the outlet gives no date for that yes. By the record, the committee's only approval is Oct. 19, 6-1, so the reading that the prior yes was the Oct. 19 vote is this desk's, from the two documents together. By both, he is in the seven on Oct. 27, and by the outlet, the reason he gave is a February meeting. If the February meeting was the reason, it was already in the past on July 20. The record doesn't say what he was waiting for on any of the four days he moved to wait.
That's the machine. The council's public file records what was done and when. It does not record why anything waited, and it does not record why a vote changed. For the why, you are relying on a reporter who was in the room. This show opened the record and read the reporter. It did not attend the meeting and it did not open the February JEA minutes the outlet refers to. So the February incident, in this piece, is exactly as strong as Jacksonville Today's sentence and no stronger.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
Twelve council members voted yes, and that's a majority with room to spare. The charter, by the resolution's own title, gives the mayor the pick, and a reappointment to a second full term is the least surprising kind of appointment there is: the council already confirmed this person once. A utility board with a seat in limbo from March to October is a board that can't fully do its work, and at some point the responsible thing is to vote. Twelve people decided that point was Oct. 27.
There's a fair reading of the deferrals too. "Defer" is a committee's ordinary tool, and the record doesn't say a single one of the twelve was hostile. Scheduling, an absent sponsor, a chair waiting on a question to be answered: any of those produces the same row. Treating twelve identical lines as twelve acts of resistance is reading intent into a blank.
And here's the counter, which is the record itself. If the twelve deferrals were routine, the committee could have said so in the row, and didn't. If the February meeting mattered enough to turn a yes into a no, by the outlet's account of Gay's reason, it mattered in February, and the record shows the committee deferring in April, May, June, July, August, September and October without saying what it was waiting for, with the name of the council member who later switched in the mover field on four of those days. Seven no votes on a reappointment is seven, and a council that lets a confirmation sit for seven months and then passes it 12-7 has told you something. It just didn't write it down.
What You Can Actually Do
Watch the status field. As of this writing the record says "Awaiting Mayor's Signature." The mayor requested the appointment, so the signature is the expected next line, and when it comes the status on matter 8271 changes. The term runs to Feb. 28, 2030. That's the date the next version of this vote comes around.
Name the seven. As the record lists them: "J. Carlucci, Carrico, Diamond, White, Arias, Gay, Salem." Jacksonville Today gives them as "Raul Arias, Joe Carlucci, Kevin Carrico, Rory Diamond, Mike Gay, Ron Salem and Randy White." Twelve others voted yes; the record names the no side only, by the council's convention. If your council member is on that list, or isn't, you now know how they voted on the one JEA decision that was theirs to make.
Go to the board. JEA's board meets in public. The February meeting that Gay cited, per Jacksonville Today, is the kind of thing that happens in those rooms, and the only way to know what happens in them is to be in them or to read the minutes afterward. This show has been in JEA's orbit before: the data-center tariff law, and the charter amendment that would put JEA's meetings on camera.
Ask the committee. The Rules Committee's twelve rows say "DEFER," and eight of them say who moved it. The committee's agendas and minutes for those twelve dates are public records, and they are where the reason lives if a reason was ever spoken aloud. This desk did not pull them for this piece. If you do, the dates are in the paragraph above.
The So-What
The council's record is honest in a very particular way. It will tell you, to the day, how long a thing waited, and it will tell you, by name, who said no at the end. It will not tell you why it waited, and it will not tell you what changed. Those are the two questions that matter, and the public file is silent on both by design.
So the two halves of this story come from two different places, and I want you to hold them apart. The twelve deferrals, the two names in the mover field, the 6-1, the 12-7, the seven names, the Feb. 28, 2030 end date and "Awaiting Mayor's Signature" are the record's, and you can open them right now. The former chair, the defense of the former CEO, the allegations, and a council member's reason for switching his vote are Jacksonville Today's, and they are as good as that outlet's reporting, which is to say credited and not independently confirmed here.
This show always asks who decided. On Tuesday the record finally answered: twelve yes, seven no, names attached. For the seven months before that, the file answers who moved to wait on eight days out of twelve, and why on none of them.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- Matter 8271, Resolution 2026-0203-A (Jacksonville City Council, Legistar API, as served Oct. 30, 2026; accessed October 30, 2026): the title, the charter section, the term to Feb. 28, 2030, the 6-1 and 12-7 lines, the seven names and the status.
- Matter 8271, histories (Jacksonville City Council, Legistar API, as served Oct. 30, 2026; accessed October 30, 2026): the twelve "Defer" rows April 6 to Oct. 5, the mover names on eight of them, the Oct. 27 floor text.
- "Joseph DiSalvo reappointed to JEA board after months of deferrals" (Jacksonville Today, Oct. 29, 2026; accessed October 30, 2026): who DiSalvo is, the Cavey characterization, the seven no votes by full name, and Gay's stated reason.