On Oct. 12 a nonprofit called Treehouse Sanctuary, Inc. sued the City of St. Petersburg in federal court, and the complaint it filed is thirty pages about chairs. The building is the 1926 Euclid Methodist Church at 919 10th Avenue North. The organization opened there in August 2025, pulled out the fixed pews so the sanctuary could seat people in a circle, at tables, or not at all, and by September, it says, the city's fire department had closed the building to worship until it applied for a "change of use." The case is 8:26-cv-03106 in the Middle District of Florida, and the mayor was served Friday, Oct. 16, the owner told the St. Pete Catalyst.

Yesterday this show read a Sarasota County notice that called a church's showers a social service facility. Today the City of St. Petersburg has looked at a church with no pews and decided it may not be a church anymore. Same move, different county. A local government that cannot say no to a church says the church is something else.

So we are going to ask what this show always asks. Who decided the pews were the religion. And what has it cost the people on the other end of that decision.

One thing first, because the show doesn't sell you a clean ending. Everything below about what the city did comes from the complaint, and a complaint is one side's pleading, written by the side suing. The city has not answered in court. The Catalyst, in the one press account this desk has read, notes the allegations have not been adjudicated and that the city's full response wasn't in the material it reviewed. Where this piece says the city said something, that's the complaint talking, and it's labeled that way every time.

The Receipt

The complaint's background section reads like a building permit with a grudge. The church was built in 1926 and, in the complaint's words, was "originally designed, permitted, and used as a place of religious assembly." It cites a 1926 newspaper report that about 1,250 people came to the opening service on Thanksgiving Day. Noam and Irene Krasniansky, named in the complaint as the principals of Treehouse Sanctuary, acquired it about three years before the organization opened, and the property is owned by a company called Treehouse Development Group, LLC, which leases it to the nonprofit.

Treehouse Sanctuary describes itself as interfaith, and says an interfaith sanctuary needs to change shape: forward-facing rows for one tradition, a circle for another, open floor for processions, tables for a meal. So in August 2025 it took out the fixed seating. The complaint says "no structural alterations were made" and that nothing changed about the building's exits, exit capacity, or the paths to them. The city's own certificate of occupancy, it says, "does not identify fixed seating as a condition of occupancy."

Then opening night. The complaint describes a celebration of about 120 young adults with music and dancing. A complaint brought police inside, who found no violation, including on noise. Ambulances came after a neighbor reported eight people had fainted; paramedics found no one had. The next morning a farmers market drew about 500 people over six hours. Within the week a city fire official insisted on an inspection, and after it, the complaint says, the city told the organization it "could no longer use the building for assembly purposes" and called what it was doing a "merchant expo." The fire department allowed a few August events to go forward with an assembly permit and a fire marshal in the room.

In September 2025, the complaint says, the fire department required the property to close. The city said "substantial modifications" had been made; the only modifications it pointed to, per the complaint, were furniture and the fixed seating, both removed. From there the city's position became that the nonprofit had to pursue a "change of use" and get zoning approval before worship could resume, and it demanded a full automatic sprinkler system and a voice alarm system. The complaint says the city never identified a change in the building's fundamental use from religious assembly and never named "a distinct life-safety hazard caused by the removal of fixed seating."

The nonprofit was told at one point that it could keep operating if it put the seats back. It did, with extra spacing, termite damage and all. A city inspector then found the building satisfactory subject to minor corrections, the complaint says, and promised a report so a Sunday service could go ahead. The report that came instead imposed the sprinkler and alarm requirements again. When the organization moved its events outdoors into its own parking lot in January 2026, the fire department saw the posts on social media and said not without a change of use. A later reinspection report, issued without anyone entering the building, directed it to reinstall chairs in a third-floor mezzanine that had been empty since years before the Krasnianskys bought the place.

The paper trail the complaint attaches is the part to watch. An architect's letter dated Feb. 2, 2026, proposed alternative life-safety measures for a historic building. A formal demand letter went to the fire marshal on March 7. On March 17 the city answered in writing, and here is what the complaint says that answer contained: the city acknowledged that the building counts as an existing assembly occupancy, with a certificate of occupancy to match, then said that removing the fixed seating, basement partitions and ceiling finishes were significant modifications, that the intended sanctuary layouts triggered a change-of-use process, and that the waiver was denied. That letter is Exhibit E on the docket. This desk hasn't read it; more on that below.

Six counts follow, not five: free exercise and equal protection under Section 1983, substantial burden, equal terms and nondiscrimination under the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, and a sixth under Florida's own Religious Freedom Restoration Act. The city is sued through Mayor Ken Welch in his official capacity, and the complaint asks only for declarations, injunctions and fees, not damages.

What a year without a sanctuary costs

Start with what the complaint says was lost. Since September 2025 the organization has been "totally unable to conduct regular religious worship" in its own building. A wedding scheduled for September 2025 was cancelled after the fire department refused to permit it. Weddings book six to sixteen months out, the complaint says, and none can be booked. Food collection for a children's hunger nonprofit, run at the events the city stopped, stopped with them. And the owner of the building, Treehouse Development Group, LLC, is in bankruptcy, case 8:25-bk-09027 in the Tampa bankruptcy court, which the complaint attributes to the financial consequences of the closure.

The money behind that is the Catalyst's reporting, not the complaint's. The Krasnianskys bought the vacant church for about $1.1 million. Before Treehouse Sanctuary existed, a previous proposal in 2019 to convert the building into about twenty residences had city approval and then died under neighborhood opposition. The couple's own plan for an event venue got a staff recommendation for approval, deadlocked 3-3 at the Community Planning and Preservation Commission in November 2024, and then split 4-4 at City Council in February 2025, which left it denied. "We've put all of our life savings into this," Krasniansky told the Catalyst.

Here is why it costs you even if you've never set foot on 10th Avenue North. If the removal of furniture from a room that already holds a certificate of occupancy for assembly can trigger a change of use, then every old sanctuary in Florida that has moved to flexible seating is one neighbor's phone call away from the same letter. The complaint names five St. Petersburg congregations, on information and belief: two it says removed their pews, two it says host secular events in their halls without a change of use, and one it says was never made to install comparable sprinklers or voice alarms. If the complaint is right about them, the rule isn't the rule. It's a rule the city applies when it wants to.

How the Machine Works

Here is how it runs, in the complaint's telling. A city that twice could not deliver a no through its land-use boards, once by a 3-3 tie and once by a 4-4 one, received a building that had quietly become the one thing the zoning already allowed: a church in a church. There was no board vote to lose. So the question moved from the planning commission to the fire marshal, where the decision is an inspector's, the standard is "substantial modifications," and the remedy is a sprinkler system the complaint says would mean "substantial structural work, engineering, significant capital expenditures," and the destruction of the historic interior. The complaint also says public records requests turned up city staff from four departments, building, planning, zoning and historical, coordinating about the property, and that city officials, in conversation and in correspondence, called the opening-night event a "rave."

Whether that's what happened is what a judge decides. What the federal statute does is set the terms of that decision, and the terms are the reason a chair dispute is in federal court at all. Section 2000cc of Title 42 says no government may apply a land use regulation "in a manner that imposes a substantial burden on the religious exercise of a person, including a religious assembly or institution," unless the government shows a compelling interest pursued by "the least restrictive means." That rule reaches any case where the government makes "individualized assessments of the proposed uses for the property involved," which is a description of a change-of-use determination. And the equal-terms clause, subsection (b)(1): "No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that treats a religious assembly or institution on less than equal terms with a nonreligious assembly or institution."

That last sentence is the one the complaint is built around. It names, on information and belief, Historic Bethel AME Church, which it says hasn't been made to install comparable sprinklers or voice alarms; First Baptist Church, which it says hosts candlelight concerts without a change of use; a commercial venue called Coastal Creative that hosts a congregation called Artisan Church without being reclassified; Allendale United Methodist and St. Pete First United Methodist, which it says removed their pews for flexible seating; and a Unitarian church on Mirror Lake Drive that rents its halls for weddings and birthdays. None of that has been tested. "Upon information and belief" is lawyer for "we think so and we'll find out in discovery," and the complaint says as much.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Put yourself in the fire marshal's chair, because the city's argument is not nothing. A sanctuary built in 1926, before the current building and fire codes existed, which the complaint itself concedes, where a 1926 newspaper, as the complaint cites it, counted about 1,250 people at the opening service. Pews bolted to the floor give an inspector a fixed count of bodies and fixed aisles to the doors. Take the pews out and the room can hold a standing crowd, or a dinner at tables, or a farmers market with 500 people through the door in six hours, and the inspector who signed off on that with no sprinklers owns the night something goes wrong. The city's March 17 letter, as the complaint describes it, didn't rest on the pews alone; it cited basement partitions and ceiling finishes removed as well. And the complaint's own timeline shows a department that let August events proceed with a permit and a marshal present, told the nonprofit it could operate with the seats reinstalled, and sent an inspector who said the building looked satisfactory. That's a city trying to find a yes, until it didn't.

Here's the answer, and it comes from the statute, not from the show. RLUIPA doesn't ask whether the city has a safety interest. The complaint grants that it does, and the Catalyst notes the lawsuit doesn't dispute that fire safety matters. The law asks whether closing a house of worship outright for more than a year was the least restrictive way to serve that interest, and whether a secular hall in the same shape would have gotten the same letter. The complaint says the city's own certificate says assembly, that the exits never changed, that the city never named a hazard the chairs created, and that an architect put a historic-building alternative on the table and the city said no. Every one of those is an allegation. The document that would test them is the city's March 17 letter, and it's sitting on the docket as Exhibit E.

What You Can Actually Do

Read the complaint, not the coverage. The complaint is free on CourtListener's RECAP archive, all thirty pages. Paragraphs 9 through 91 are the story; the counts begin on page 16.

Watch the docket. The CourtListener docket for 8:26-cv-03106 is public and free. The case is assigned to Judge Steven D. Merryday and Magistrate Judge Anthony E. Porcelli. The six exhibits, including Exhibit D, the demand letter, and Exhibit E, the city's response, are listed as attachments to docket entry 1 but hadn't been uploaded to the free archive when this desk checked on Oct. 20; the docket page lists Exhibit D and Exhibit E for purchase on PACER at 30 cents apiece. Anyone who buys one with the RECAP browser extension installed puts it in the free archive for everyone. If you do, we'll read it.

Ask the city for its file. The change-of-use and certificate-of-occupancy file for 919 10th Avenue North, the 2025 closure order, the March 17 response and the city's internal correspondence about the property are the city's records, and this desk drafted a public records request to the City of St. Petersburg for all of them today. We'll publish what comes back, and the city's words will replace the complaint's description of them wherever the two differ.

Put it next to Sarasota. Yesterday's piece on Remnant Church is the same statute, the same clause, and a county instead of a city. Read them together and the pattern is hard to unsee.

The So-What

The zoning boards tied. The council tied. The building became a church, which is what it was permitted to be in 1926 and, by the city's own certificate as the complaint reads it, what it's permitted to be now. And then, the complaint says, a fire inspector looked at an empty floor and called it a change of use. That's not a fire code with a side effect. That's the question a federal judge has now been asked to answer, and the city's answer is due on a public docket.

Come back for the rest

We do this every week: the official category on top, the receipts underneath, every quotation traced to the document it came from so you can open it and check my work. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's receipts land in your inbox. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and we'll send you the receipts.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts