There's a church on Ashton Road in Sarasota County that has served people who have nowhere to live since 2015 and today hands out showers, laundry, clothes and meals. In late August, after a neighbor complained, county code enforcement sent it a notice of violation saying the property isn't zoned for a social service facility, Suncoast Searchlight reported in a story WUSF carried October 18. The church scaled back for a few weeks, then turned everything back on. The county gave it until December. The church says it won't.

I did twelve years of Catholic school, so let me save the county some trouble. Feeding the hungry and clothing the naked isn't a side business a church runs out of the fellowship hall. It's the final exam. Somebody at the county looked at a congregation doing the one thing the text is clearest about and filed it under a code category.

Who decided a shower is zoning. And who wrote the category.

The Receipt

Everything here about the church and its neighbors comes from Searchlight; this desk hasn't read the notice, the complaint or the emails. Pastor Frank Burns and his wife Tammy Burns, who runs the church's homeless ministry, started Remnant Church and Remnant Cafe in 2015; the cafe has served people without housing from the start, and both moved to Ashton Road in 2017. Across the street sit the six homes of the Ashton Enclave Condominiums. In August the president of that condo association, Christine Nordstrom, filed a complaint with the county, and code enforcement followed in late August with a notice saying the property isn't zoned for a social service facility.

A zoning lawyer told the church to comply. For about three and a half weeks in September it stopped the showers and laundry and kept the twice-weekly meals, Bible study and services. Then the leaders turned everything back on, the week before Searchlight's October 18 story, and told the county they won't meet the December deadline the county had extended. The county declined to comment beyond the basics of the code enforcement process, and county officials told Searchlight no special magistrate hearing has been scheduled.

Tammy Burns, to Searchlight: "To hear people say we’re a soup kitchen or a social service is kind of offensive to us because what we’re doing is living out our faith." And: "To not do what God called us to do would be sinful."

Why It Costs You

Look at the category. The county's position, as Searchlight describes the notice, is that the property is zoned for a church and not for a social service facility. So somewhere in the county's code a church is one thing and a shower is another, and the county drew the line.

The ones who paid for that line first went without a shower or clean clothes for three and a half weeks in September. Next is every congregation in the county that reads Matthew 25 and acts on it. The passage doesn't hedge: "For I was hungry and you gave me food, I was thirsty and you gave me drink, a stranger and you welcomed me," and "naked and you clothed me." No zoning district appears in those verses. A county that can call the first half worship and the second half a land use can shut down the second half anywhere it gets a complaint, with a notice, not a vote.

How the Machine Works

Here is how it runs. A neighbor complains, code enforcement sends a notice, and the owner complies or a special magistrate hears the case. Searchlight reports the church plans to argue religious freedom before that magistrate, then in circuit court, possibly in a lawsuit. It hasn't hired that lawyer yet.

The federal law it intends to stand on is the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act, signed September 22, 2000. Section 2000cc has two provisions that matter here.

The substantial burden rule, subsection (a)(1): "No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that imposes a substantial burden on the religious exercise of a person, including a religious assembly or institution, unless the government demonstrates that imposition of the burden on that person, assembly, or institution" is "in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest" and "is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest."

The equal terms rule, subsection (b)(1): "No government shall impose or implement a land use regulation in a manner that treats a religious assembly or institution on less than equal terms with a nonreligious assembly or institution."

Read the first one again. Once a church shows the rule substantially burdens its religious exercise, the proof moves to the government, which has to show a compelling interest and that stopping the showers was the gentlest tool it had. Not a reasonable tool. The least restrictive one.

Searchlight found a case on point: a 2016 federal appeals ruling for Harbor Missionary Church in Ventura, California, whose homeless ministry had been denied a permit. The judges, as Searchlight quotes them, found a compelling public safety interest but held the denial was not "the least restrictive means to achieve this goal." Remnant's code allows no exception for social services at all, which Searchlight flags as the difference. Denise Harle, who directs Florida State University's First Amendment Clinic, told Searchlight the act should still apply: the property is zoned for a church, and courts don't dictate what a church's ministry includes.

Then the timing. On October 1 the U.S. Supreme Court granted review in No. 25-1131, Missionaries of Saint John the Baptist, Inc. v. Frederic, out of the Supreme Court of Kentucky, limited to the first question in the petition. It's the Court's first land use case under this statute, Searchlight notes, and whatever the justices say about a substantial burden lands on Ashton Road.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Zoning is neutral; the code would say the same to a secular nonprofit. Searchlight reports an email another community member sent to county commissioners on October 2 that puts the case as well as it can be put: "Residents should not have to accept substantial neighborhood impacts simply because the organization responsible for them has a charitable or religious mission," and "Helping people in need is admirable, but the location and manner in which those services are delivered still matter." Nordstrom told Searchlight she "expected more integrity out of Tammy and Remnant" and said religion "is literally an afterthought of their mission."

Here's the answer. The statute was written for the neutral rule. Subsection (a)(1) doesn't require a hostile county; it requires a county that burdens religious exercise to prove it had no gentler option. Whether religion is an afterthought of Remnant's mission isn't the county's to grade, and Harle's point to Searchlight is the whole ballgame: judges don't rule on whether a religious practice is valid, and neither does code enforcement. If the street has real problems, the county has tools short of "stop feeding people," and the law says it reaches for those first.

What You Can Actually Do

Watch two dockets. No special magistrate hearing has been set, per Searchlight; when one is, it's a public proceeding on the Ashton Road notice. The Supreme Court's docket page for 25-1131 lists every filing.

Ask for the paper. This desk hasn't obtained the notice, the August complaint or the October 2 email. This show is drafting a public records request to Sarasota County for all three, and we'll publish what comes back.

The So-What

A county with a category for worship and no category for a shower built that gap itself; a complaint from across the street only found it. The church on Ashton Road says the shower is the worship. The federal law says that once the church says so, the county has to prove it had no gentler way. That's not a social service. That's the point.

Come back for the rest

We do this every week: the official category on top, the receipts underneath, every quotation traced to the document it came from so you can open it and check my work. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's receipts land in your inbox. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and we'll send you the receipts.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts