On Thursday, October 1, the Council on American-Islamic Relations and its Florida chapter filed a new federal lawsuit against Governor Ron DeSantis, naming 24 other state officials as defendants, including Attorney General James Uthmeier, Chief of Domestic Security Larry Keefe, and all twenty elected state attorneys. The 98-page complaint was filed in the Northern District of Florida's Tallahassee division, and the CourtListener docket logs it as case 4:26-cv-00521.
The timing was not incidental. The complaint states that on the same day, October 1, the same court dismissed CAIR's first challenge to the law, filed July 1 and docketed as No. 4:26-cv-315, for lack of standing, because the designation had not yet happened when that case was filed.
On the complaint's account, then, the first case was filed before there was a designation to challenge, and CAIR walked back in the door the same day. This show read the state's notice and the law behind the September 29 vote in an earlier piece. This one reads the lawsuit, and asks the two questions this show always asks. Who decided this should go? And who pays if nobody stops it?
The Receipt
The new complaint asks the court to block the September 29 Cabinet vote that named CAIR a "domestic terrorist organization" from ever taking legal effect. Its request for relief asks the court to enjoin publication and enforcement of the designation and to declare the law unconstitutional.
Read the list of what it wants and you can see the whole fight. The first item asks the court to stop Keefe from publishing the designations "in the Florida Administrative Register and on the FDLE website." Another reaches past CAIR entirely. It asks the court to bar enforcement of the law "against others in connection with the designations of Plaintiffs." Hold onto that word, others. It comes back.
CAIR's eight counts argue that Florida's designation regime, built on HB 1471, violates the First and Fourteenth Amendments because, as the complaint describes it, the Chief of Domestic Security can designate a group without any judicial hearing, ruling or jury verdict, and that the regime is preempted by the federal government's exclusive authority to designate terrorist organizations under the Supremacy Clause. Read the count headings one by one in the complaint and they run free speech, association, retaliation, the right to petition, due process, two right-to-counsel claims (one Fourteenth Amendment, one First), and the Supremacy Clause.
The signature page lists the lawyers: the Southern Poverty Law Center, the Atlanta firm Bondurant, Mixson & Elmore, the ACLU Foundation of Florida and the national ACLU Foundation. The docket shows the case assigned to Mark Eaton Walker.
Here is what isn't there yet. As of the docket this show captured Friday morning, no docket entry shows a hearing date or an emergency motion; as filed, the case proceeds as an ordinary complaint.
How the Machine Works
Here's how CAIR got from one lawsuit to two, in the order the new complaint tells it.
CAIR filed the first case on July 1. The next day it asked for a temporary restraining order. On July 6 and 7, the complaint says, the court denied those motions, noting that CAIR's claimed harms assumed a Cabinet vote that was, in the court's words, "an occurrence which is no certainty." The state then told CAIR it would write an emergency rule first and hold off on designating until the rule took effect. It put the rule out on September 11.
Then the machine ran. By the parties' agreement, the complaint says, the earliest FDLE could mail its notice of intent was September 15, and it mailed it that day. CAIR got it September 18 and filed written objections September 25. On September 29 the Governor and Cabinet met. According to the complaint, CAIR's lawyer asked a Cabinet aide before the meeting for a chance to speak, then stood up during it and asked again. The complaint's sentence for what happened next is four words long: "Governor DeSantis ignored counsel."
The complaint says Commissioner Mark Glass spoke briefly to say CAIR met the statute's criteria, the governor moved to approve, the motion was seconded, and the entire approval process "took about 30 seconds." One more detail from the same filing: Larry Keefe, the Chief of Domestic Security the suit names, was appointed to that job on September 29, the day of the vote. Glass held it before him.
Two days later, on October 1, came the dismissal. Here's the part that stings. The complaint says the state itself told the court CAIR had standing once the designations were approved, and the court still concluded it had to measure standing as of July 1, the day the first case was filed, when CAIR had none. On CAIR's telling: too early in July, and still too early in October, because October looked back to July. New case.
Now the clock. The complaint says state law gives Florida's Chief of Domestic Security seven days after approval to publish a designation in the Florida Administrative Register, and that the parties agreed he will not do so before October 6. And the complaint says that absent a court order, CAIR's designation becomes legally effective November 5.
The complaint also argues that a challenge in state court is no brake on that date. It says that in any such challenge, the law "does not require the court to hold a hearing, order discovery, take testimony, issue a ruling, or otherwise act" before the designation takes effect.
Why It Costs You
After November 5, the complaint says, the state's twenty elected prosecutors could pursue the first-degree felony, carrying up to 30 years in prison, that the law creates for anyone who knowingly provides material support or resources to a designated group. The complaint's words for who that reaches: "for any person." Not any member. Any person.
All twenty state attorneys are in the caption, from Ginger Bowden Madden in the 1st Judicial Circuit to Amira Fox in the 20th. The complaint says there is a substantial risk that, once the designations take effect, those prosecutors, along with the Office of Statewide Prosecution, will try to enforce the law's penalties against CAIR and CAIR-Florida. And as the complaint describes the felony, the law would let a prosecutor charge anyone, not just a CAIR member, who knowingly gives the designated group material support. The complaint quotes Florida's statewide prosecutor, Brad McVay, speaking at DeSantis's July 1 press conference: "We stand here committed to . . . prosecute any individual or group associated with terrorist activity."
And the cost isn't waiting for November. The complaint says that in anticipation of the vote, CAIR-Florida has already turned away people who came to it for legal help and called off the fundraising galas it holds every year, which were set for this fall. It says both groups now have to spend time winding down operations.
You may never have heard of CAIR-Florida. You may never give it a dime. The felony, as the complaint describes it, doesn't care. It reaches any person, and the twenty prosecutors who could bring that charge are on the caption.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
The bill's own sponsors framed it as process. The complaint quotes the House sponsor, Rep. Hillary Cassel, saying HB 1471 would "create a due process" for organizations to be designated. It quotes the Senate sponsor, Sen. Erin Grall, describing the bill as seeking to "bring a process" to the governor's executive order designations.
And by the complaint's own timeline, there was a process. CAIR got written notice, got a deadline, and filed objections before the vote. That is the sponsors' point.
The dismissal has a fair reading too. As the complaint describes the orders, the court in July declined to act on a vote that hadn't happened, and in October held CAIR to the day it filed. Courts don't decide hypotheticals, and the complaint says the state conceded CAIR has standing now. If that holds, the state isn't ducking the merits. It's going to argue them.
Here's the answer, from the same filing.
CAIR's complaint counters that Florida has already lost this argument once, noting a federal judge preliminarily enjoined DeSantis's original executive order targeting CAIR in March. It says the governor publicly revealed that one purpose of that order was to get at CAIR's financial records through discovery in the lawsuit he expected, and it quotes his post on X about CAIR's finances: "Should be illuminating!"
On the process, the complaint quotes the sponsor too. It says Cassel later acknowledged the bill would not be "a judicial process." The complaint's case is that this is exactly the problem: the law requires no "judicial hearing, judicial ruling, or jury verdict" before a group is designated. The complaint says the state "has never indicted, much less convicted," either group of any crime.
So the sponsors call it due process, and one of them, by the complaint's account, said it isn't a judicial one. A notice, a written objection, a lawyer standing in the room, and a vote the complaint clocks at about thirty seconds. Whether that's enough process for a label that, as the complaint reads the law, can carry a 30-year felony for anyone who knowingly helps is now the question in front of a federal court, again.
What You Can Actually Do
Read the complaint, not the coverage. It's 98 pages, so start at paragraphs 166 through 179 of the complaint, which tell the July-to-October story in the plaintiffs' words, then the request for relief at the end. Remember whose words they are: this is CAIR's pleading, and the state hasn't answered it yet.
Watch the docket. The CourtListener docket for case 4:26-cv-00521 is public. The thing to look for is an emergency motion or a hearing date. As of Friday morning there was neither.
Mark two dates. October 6 is the earliest the complaint says the Register notice can run, by the parties' agreement. November 5 is the date the complaint says the designation takes effect without a court order.
Know your prosecutor. Every elected state attorney in Florida is a named defendant. Find yours in the caption on the first two pages. The complaint says there's a substantial risk those offices will seek to enforce the law's penalties against CAIR and CAIR-Florida once the designations take effect.
The So-What
By the complaint's account, a federal court told CAIR in July that the vote was no certainty. The vote came. Then, the complaint says, the court found CAIR had no standing on the day it first filed. On that account, none of it reached whether Florida can do this. It was about when CAIR was allowed to ask.
Now it's asking again, with the vote on the record, a clock that runs out November 5, and every prosecutor in the state named on the caption. The felony, as the complaint describes it, reaches any person. Read the complaint before the clock runs out, because the next name goes through the same door.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- “Complaint, CAIR-Foundation, Inc. and CAIR Florida, Inc. v. DeSantis et al.” (U.S. District Court, N.D. Fla., No. 4:26-cv-00521-MW-MAF, Doc. 1, filed October 1, 2026, 98 pages, plaintiffs' pleading; accessed October 2, 2026): the defendants, counts, relief, timeline and dismissal.
- “CAIR-Foundation Inc v. DeSantis, 4:26-cv-00521” (CourtListener RECAP docket, sourced from PACER; accessed October 2, 2026): the filing date, case number, assigned judge and the docket's four entries.