Governor Ron DeSantis and the Cabinet on Tuesday, September 29, approved designating the Council on American-Islamic Relations and its Florida chapter as "domestic terrorist organizations," according to a September 29 release from the ACLU, which represents both groups. The ACLU says its lawyer stood and asked to speak for them, that the governor "did not acknowledge and spoke over" the request, and that "The entire vote consideration took thirty seconds."

What the state published is a seven-page notice of intent in the Florida Department of Law Enforcement's cabinet package for the September 29 meeting, marked "UNCLASSIFIED." We read it. We also read the law that made the vote possible, and the objection CAIR's lawyers filed, which sits in the same package.

So we're going to ask the two questions this show always asks. What did the state put in the file to carry a label this heavy? And who pays when it lands?

The Receipt

The power comes from CS/CS/HB 1471, which is now Chapter 2026-28 and took effect July 1. Section 8 of the enrolled text creates s. 943.03102, Florida Statutes, and it hands the first call to one state official.

Under it, Florida's Chief of Domestic Security can designate a group that is based or operates in Florida or the United States on finding that it is engaging in terrorist activity and that the activity is an ongoing threat to the state or the country. The chief must give the Governor and Cabinet written notice with a summary of the basis.

The group gets notice too, if it has a location or office the state can find and the notice can be delivered safely. The statute lets that notice arrive without the reasons: "The written findings regarding the basis for such designation need not be included with the notice."

The law also gives the state a way to hold part of a case back. CS/CS/HB 1473, Chapter 2026-29, exempts from the public records law any part of the chief's notice to the Cabinet "which would reveal information critical to state or national security." And HB 1471 says a court hearing a challenge "may not compel the public disclosure" of documents that are confidential or exempt.

In CAIR's case, the state published its summary. The notice in FDLE's package runs from "Page 1 of 7" to "Page 7 of 7," under an "UNCLASSIFIED" banner. Whether the chief gave the Cabinet anything beyond it, this show can't tell from the package.

One more thing about this act, because it's in the same PDF. Section 1 creates s. 2.05, which bars courts, agencies and arbitration panels from applying foreign law or "religious law" in a way that would violate a person's constitutional rights. It defines religious law as a legal code tied to a religion's sacred texts or traditions, and then it names exactly one: "The term includes Sharia law." The section doesn't reach a religious group's own internal matters, like choosing clergy or interpreting doctrine. It's the only religion's law the act names.

How the Machine Works

Here's how it runs, in the order the statute and the Department of Law Enforcement's emergency rule put it.

The chief writes to the Governor and Cabinet. Under emergency rule 11RER26-8, as this show captured it on September 12, the chief then does nothing more "Unless and until the Governor and Cabinet advise that they will hold a meeting to consider the notice of intent." If they call the meeting, the group gets notice and seven days from receipt to object in writing. Whether the group gets to stand up and argue at the meeting is another matter. The rule says the Governor and Cabinet "may permit, at their sole discretion," the organization to appear and present argument.

That's how CAIR's went. Its lawyers' written objection, in the package, says CAIR and CAIR-Florida received the notice on September 18, and it's dated September 25. The vote, by the ACLU's account, came September 29. And the permission to speak is what the ACLU says its lawyer asked for that Tuesday. By the ACLU's account, the governor spoke over the request and approved the designation.

Seven days at the earliest after the chief's notice reaches them, the Governor and Cabinet may approve or reject a designation by majority vote. Within seven days after an approval, the statute says the chief "must publish notice of the designation in the Florida Administrative Register." The rule adds that the notice "will provide that the designation is effective 30 days after publication." The chief also has to keep a current list of designated groups on the department's website, and review each designation at least once every five years.

This show walked through that whole procedure in a piece published September 15, when the record we read, as of September 12, showed nobody on the list. That piece called it a machine with nothing in it. According to the ACLU, on Tuesday it was used.

Here's the detail that matters for the calendar. The vote alone doesn't switch on the law's penalties. Every place this act defines a "domestic terrorist organization," it means one "whose designation as such has been published in the Florida Administrative Register." The ACLU says that if the courts don't intervene, the designation takes effect November 5.

Why It Costs You

Once the notice is published, here's what the act attaches.

A felony for support. A person who "knowingly provides material support or resources" to a designated domestic terrorist organization commits a first-degree felony. The statute puts a knowledge test on it: the person must know the group is designated, or know it has engaged in terrorism.

A felony for membership. A person who willfully becomes a member and serves under the group's direction or control, with the intent to further its illegal acts, commits a second-degree felony.

A wall around public money. State agencies, local governments and school districts that spend state money or levy property taxes can't spend it to support a designated group or its members, can't sign contracts with one, and can't take its money, outside fines, taxes and payment for goods or services.

The corporation itself. The Department of State may start proceedings to administratively dissolve a corporation that's been designated, once the designation is published and any timely court challenge has gone against it.

Students. Students at state colleges and universities found to have promoted one are to be "immediately expelled and assessed" out-of-state fees. The act also cuts them off from fee waivers, and from state and institutional grants, financial aid, scholarships and tuition assistance.

Private schools on scholarship money. A private school in Florida's scholarship programs has to refuse to hire, contract with, be owned by or take money from anyone affiliated with or controlled by a designated domestic terrorist organization.

Read that list and then read the ACLU's account of what it means for its clients. The ACLU says that if the designation takes effect, CAIR and CAIR-Florida "will be forced to shut down their operations in the state," under threat of severe criminal penalties for the groups and for the staff, board members, volunteers and other stakeholders they have in Florida.

You don't have to be a member of anything for this law to reach you. A school district, a city, a college and a private school all get new duties once a notice runs in the Register.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Here is what the state published, in its own words, from the notice. Keep in mind the statute lets the chief leave findings out of the group's notice, so this may not be everything the Cabinet saw.

Its headline finding is one sentence: "There is substantial evidence that CAIR is engaging in terrorist activity." Its basis summary opens with the 2008 Holy Land Foundation trial. The notice says that trial exposed the Muslim Brotherhood's U.S. Palestine Committee as a committee whose "sole purpose was supporting Hamas" inside the United States, and that the Holy Land Foundation, two other groups and CAIR were identified as its organizational structures.

From there it builds a timeline. It says the people who founded CAIR are connected to Hamas leaders. It says former members of one of those other groups founded CAIR in 1994, and that wiretapped transcripts from the Holy Land case indicate a "front" organization would be needed to "camouflage" their actions. It points to a co-founder of CAIR's Texas chapter who was convicted in the Holy Land case of conspiring to provide material support to Hamas. Of the 2008 verdict, it says, "CAIR was an unindicted co-conspirator."

It quotes CAIR's current national executive director, at a 1994 forum it says was videotaped at Barry University: "I am in support of the Hamas movement." The notice's own timeline puts Hamas on the federal list of foreign terrorist organizations in 1997.

Then it turns to what others have done about CAIR. It cites the United Arab Emirates' 2014 designation of CAIR and Texas's 2025 designation, along with Texas criminal investigations and lawsuits, a congressional bill to designate CAIR, requests for IRS investigations, and 2026 testimony to a U.S. Senate committee. And it says the executive director of a California CAIR chapter is "listed as a Board Member" of a foundation, citing that foundation's "last publicly published 990EZ Tax Form." It identifies a man as "the foundation's Treasurer" and says that, according to the Justice Department, he "was an alleged Palestinian Islamic Jihad (PIJ) member" who pleaded guilty to charges that included an intent to make or receive contributions benefiting a Specially Designated Terrorist.

The statute's side runs alongside. A designation requires findings of ongoing terrorist activity, the Cabinet votes at a public meeting, and the group gets a court. The definition of terrorist activity isn't loose. Under s. 775.30, it has to involve a violent act or "an act dangerous to human life" that breaks state or federal criminal law, or else a breach of s. 815.06, and it has to be meant to intimidate, injure or coerce civilians, sway government by intimidation or coercion, or affect government through acts like assassination or kidnapping.

There's more. A designated group may petition the department for removal at any time, and the Governor and Cabinet can lift one by majority vote whenever they choose. HB 1473 exempts only the portion that "would reveal information critical to state or national security," and the Legislature gave its reason in the text: the chief has to consult law enforcement, counter-terrorism and national security organizations and receives information that is "highly sensitive in nature." That exemption sunsets on October 2, 2031, unless lawmakers review it and save it.

The emergency rule goes further than the statute requires. FDLE says it "will not consider there to be cause for prosecution" based solely on membership, or solely on giving the group legal counsel in litigation over a designation. And the student penalties turn on a defined verb. To "promote" a designated group means a statement or action that "supports, approves, or encourages a terrorist organization's extralegal violence" and that, in context, "Is reasonably interpreted as a true threat of unlawful violence," "Materially disrupts the orderly learning environment," "Involves substantial disorder or the invasion of the rights of others," or constitutes material support for the group or recruitment of its members.

That's what the state put on paper. Here's the answer.

The statute asks whether a group "is engaging" in terrorist activity. Present tense. In the state's own timeline, the dated entries about CAIR's own conduct run from its 1994 founding to the 2008 trial. What comes after is other governments' and officials' actions against CAIR, testimony about it, and a board listing at another foundation.

And the definition the state has to meet starts with an act: violent, or dangerous to human life, and criminal. CAIR's objection says the notice identifies no such act by CAIR or CAIR-Florida, and no criminal law one would violate. It says neither group "has ever been charged with, much less convicted of, any crime." And it quotes the groups' expert, a former State Department official who, it says, led efforts to designate Hamas officials. On the absence of evidence tying CAIR to Hamas across decades of that work, he writes that it "is not a gap in the record. It is the record."

Then there's the Florida chapter. The notice proposes to designate CAIR-Florida too. In the notice's text, CAIR-Florida is named in the title, the address block and the sentence issuing the notice. None of the basis findings names it.

So the state's published case is a history, most of it decades old and much of it about other people and other groups, plus what other governments and officials have done about CAIR since. Whether that is "substantial evidence" that CAIR "is engaging in terrorist activity" now is the question a court will be asked. Under this law, the Cabinet votes first.

That's the ACLU's case too, in its own words. Hina Shamsi, director of the ACLU's National Security Project, calls the governor's use of the new designation regime against CAIR "baseless and unconstitutional," and the ACLU says its federal suits claim violations of the groups' First Amendment rights and of due process under the Fourteenth Amendment. The groups sued in federal court in early July.

Who Wrote It

The bill page lists the bill as filed by the House Judiciary Committee, the Education & Employment Committee and Rep. Cassel. The House passed it 81-26 on March 3. The Senate passed it as amended, 25-11, on March 5. The House agreed to the Senate's change, 80-25, on March 12. The governor approved it April 6.

What You Can Actually Do

Read what the state published. The CAIR notice is pages 10 through 16 of FDLE's cabinet package, and CAIR's objection is pages 255 through 260. It's a big file, so go straight to those pages.

Watch the Florida Administrative Register. The statute gives the chief seven days after an approval to publish the designation there. If the vote was Tuesday, September 29, the day of the ACLU's release, that's October 6. The notice is what every definition of the term in this act keys to.

Mark the thirty days. Within 30 days after that notice is published, the group or any member may challenge the designation in the circuit court in Leon County. The emergency rule says the designation takes effect 30 days after publication. Those two clocks start on the same day.

Check FDLE's list. Section 943.03102(1)(b) requires the chief to "maintain and publish on the department's website a current list" of designated groups. If a notice runs in the Register and the list doesn't show it, ask why.

Follow the federal case. The ACLU lists it as "CAIR-Foundation, Inc and CAIR Florida, Inc. v. DeSantis et al." and says the groups' lawyers plan to file an amended complaint, plus an emergency motion to block the designation.

If you're a student, read the definition. The act defines "promote" in s. 1009.01(4). It's the line between speech and expulsion, and it's one sentence with four short clauses.

The So-What

Florida didn't just call a group a name. It built a process where the name comes with felonies, a wall around public money, expulsions and a path to dissolving the corporation, and the summary it published runs seven pages, with a dated case about CAIR's own conduct that stops in 2008.

Whatever you think of CAIR, read the notice, because the process doesn't care who's next. The next name goes through the same door, on the same seven days, with a chance to speak that depends on the officials' discretion.

The court comes after the vote, after the notice, after the clock starts. Read the file before the clock runs out.

Come back for the rest

We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts

Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.