Florida put out its list on the last day of August, and it is the least dramatic document you will read all year. Twenty-eight pages. Two columns. Title, author, title, author, county after county, most of them printing the same four words: None Removed or Discontinued. No cover letter. No summary. No count.
That is the first thing worth knowing about it, and it is the thing that shaped every headline you saw this week. The state of Florida publishes the rows and lets everyone else do the arithmetic.
So here is ours, labelled as ours, and then here is the part nobody did: we went and pulled the county's own paperwork.
The Receipt
The document is the Department of Education's "2025-2026 School District Reporting Pursuant to Section 1006.28(2), Florida Statutes," posted as a twenty-eight-page PDF. Its only paragraph of prose says what it is: "The report lists materials that were removed or discontinued by one of Florida's school boards in response to an objection raised by a parent of a public school student in the school district or a resident of the county where the school district is located."
Then it stops explaining itself. There is no methodology note, no caveat, and no claim anywhere that the state checked any of it. The Department's own framing is that this is information submitted by the districts. Nowhere in twenty-eight pages does the document define how a book that was removed differs from one that was discontinued. The two words only ever appear bolted together.
And there is no total. None. We searched all twenty-eight pages for `Total`, `total`, `TOTAL`, `titles`, `Number of`, `count` and `Count`. The only hit is the word "county," sitting inside that one paragraph. The same search across all twenty pages of last year's report returns the same nothing.
Which means that every figure you have seen attached to this document, ours included, is arithmetic somebody did over the state's rows. Ours works like this: we pulled the words out of the PDF, grouped them into rows by where they sit on the page, and counted a row as a title whenever it had text in the author column, throwing out the header line, the grade-band lines, the "None Removed or Discontinued" lines, and any line long enough to be the header paragraph bleeding across the column boundary. Where the author column starts is the whole ballgame, and the document answers that itself: the Author heading sits at x = 422 and the column under it begins around x = 390. That gives 620 title rows. Ten entities account for all of them. The report itemises seventy-five, and sixty-five of those print None Removed or Discontinued. Ten plus sixty-five is seventy-five, and a derived number whose parts add up to its own total has passed the cheapest check there is.
Print the method and you have to print what the method cost. An earlier run of this count drew the column line at x = 350 instead and came back with 623. The three extra rows were not books. They were the names of three state-run schools, printed centred on the page and wide enough that the last word of each fell past the line and got read as an author: the page carries Florida Atlantic University Lab School, Florida School for the Deaf and the Blind and Florida State University Lab School, Bay, and the words School, Blind and Bay landed in the author column. Underneath each of those three names the report prints None Removed or Discontinued. Schools that reported nothing were being counted as books taken away. And the tell was printed on the face of that count, where nobody read it: seventy-two entities listed, sixty-five reporting none, thirteen carrying titles, and sixty-five plus thirteen is seventy-eight, which is more entities than the report contains. A count whose parts will not add up to its own total has already refuted itself.
So 620 is the number, it does not move at x = 390, 400 or 410, and its parts reconcile. The per-district figures never moved at all this year: every county below reads the same at the bad boundary and the good one, which is why they carry most of what follows.
Per district, this desk's count: Clay 261. Escambia 150. Nassau 102. Then Polk 33, Santa Rosa 32, Sumter 22, St. Johns 11, St. Lucie 6, Collier 2, Orange 1. Every other entity in the report prints None Removed or Discontinued, and that includes all eight of them that are not county school districts: the university lab schools, the school for the deaf and the blind, the state scholars academy and the Florida Virtual School. Three counties are 513 of the 620.
Counted the same way, last year's report gives 443 rows across sixteen entities, with Clay alone at 280. Sixteen entities last year and ten this year. Four hundred forty-three rows last year and 620 this year. Fewer districts are removing books, more books are coming off the shelves, and for the second year in a row the county doing the most of it is Clay.
What "Removed" Turns Out to Mean
Here is where most coverage stops, because the state's table gives you nothing else. It gives you a title and an author and a county, and it invites you to assume the worst.
Do not assume. Go get the county's file.
Clay County District Schools publishes its school board agendas, with the backup documents attached, at agenda.oneclay.net. Across the whole 2025-2026 school year, four of its regular board meetings carry an item titled "Request for Review or Reconsideration of Library Materials Appeals": October 2, 2025 as item C9, January 8, 2026 as C4, April 2, 2026 as C12, and June 25, 2026 as C14.
The C is the important letter. All four sit under the heading Consent Agenda, and all four are disposed of by a single line near the bottom of the meeting: Adoption of Consent Agenda. One motion, one vote, the personnel list and the fire-alarm contracts and the books all together.
Now open the attachment. Clay's January 2026 appeals sheet runs six pages and has a column for what the district's own review committee found and a second column for what happened on appeal. The phrase that fills those columns, over and over, page after page, is this one:
"No violation of Florida Statute, Remain in Collection Keep:JH & HS Only"
Read it twice. The district looked at the book. The district wrote down that the book violates nothing. The district wrote down that the book stays in the collection. And then the district moved it to the junior-high and high-school shelves, which means it came off the elementary shelves, which means it goes on the state's list as removed or discontinued.
Three titles will do to show the seam. A Possibility of Whales by Karen Rivers, Alanna: The First Adventure by Tamora Pierce, and Becoming Brianna by Terri Libenson all appear in Clay County's block of the state's removal list. All three also appear on Clay's January 2026 appeals sheet, where the recorded result for each is that there was no violation of Florida statute and the book remains in the collection at a higher grade band.
That is what is inside 261.
One of the four sheets dates itself to a different year, and saying so is part of reading them honestly. The October 2025 sheet carries a footnote at the bottom of its single page, which the January, April and June sheets do not: 06/26/2025 School Board Meeting. The appeals on it were disposed of four days before the June 30 deadline for last year's report, and it reaches the October board as a record of what already happened. It lists seven titles and not one of them appears anywhere in the 2025-2026 list. One of the seven, Eon: Dragoneye Reborn by Alison Goodman, sits in Clay's block of the 2024-2025 list instead, which is exactly where that timing says it should be.
Read it anyway, because it shows the other way a book leaves a shelf. Against A Swift Pure Cry by Siobhan Dowd, the appeal result reads: "No longer in collection. Weeded due to circulation." Nobody banned that book. It stopped getting checked out, so it went the way every under-circulated library book has always gone, and the objection file caught it on the way out. That title is on neither year's state list, and its absence is the useful part: an objection file can close over a book that was already leaving for reasons that have nothing to do with the objection.
The Machine, and Where the Record Runs Out
Section 1006.28(2), Florida Statutes is the whole apparatus, and it is worth reading because almost nothing about it works the way the fight over it sounds.
A parent, or any resident of the county, files an objection on a form the district has to keep on the front page of its website. For two categories of objection, the pornography clause and the sexual-conduct clause, the statute is automatic: the material "must be removed within 5 school days after receipt of the objection and remain unavailable to students of that school until the objection is resolved." Removal first, review after. A resident who is not a parent of a student with access to the material is capped at one objection per month, which is the Legislature quietly conceding that volume was the problem.
The statute also says, about instructional materials, that a board must handle them "as a separate line item on the agenda" and that they "may not be selected, approved, or adopted as part of a consent agenda." That sentence is written about selecting, approving, adopting and purchasing. It is not written about the appeals sheet Clay puts on its consent agenda four times a year, and we are not going to tell you a rule was broken when the text does not say so. What the text does tell you is that the Legislature already decided this subject was too important to bury in a block vote, and then drew the line one clause short of where the books actually come off.
And the same statute uses the same two undefined words for something else entirely. District library procedures must "Provide for the regular removal or discontinuance of books based on, at a minimum, physical condition, rate of recent circulation, alignment to state academic standards and relevancy to curriculum, out-of-date content." Removal or discontinuance is also the statute's phrase for a book falling apart, or nobody reading it. That is why "Weeded due to circulation" can land on an objection form, and it is why a row on the state's list is not a ban.
Then there is the half of the report you cannot see. The statute requires every district, every June 30, to send the Commissioner three things: each material that drew an objection, each material that was removed or discontinued, and "Each material that was not removed or discontinued and the rationale for not removing or discontinuing the material." The Department's publication duty, in the flush text of the very same subparagraph, covers only "a list of materials that were removed or discontinued."
So the denominator exists. Every district wrote it down and mailed it in. The state publishes the numerator and keeps the rest. Without it, there is no way to know whether Clay's 261 came out of three hundred objections or three thousand, and no way to tell a district that reviews carefully from one that does not.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
It is this: the report is not lying, and the reform side keeps proving it.
The statute's own text makes clear the Legislature was trying to build a real process, not a bonfire. There is a committee. It has to meet on notice and in the open, under Florida's own sunshine law, and parents of students who can get at the material have to be on it. A parent who loses can ask the Commissioner to appoint a special magistrate, a Florida Bar member with at least five years in administrative law, who recommends a resolution to the State Board of Education, and the school district pays for it. The one-objection-per-month cap on non-parent residents is a direct answer to the serial-objector complaint. None of that is the behavior of a system designed to launder censorship.
And a district that moves a book from the elementary shelf to the high school shelf is doing something defensible on its face. Grade-banding is what school librarians have always done. If the answer to every objection is nothing changes, the process is theatre.
The trouble is that none of that survives the reporting. The statute makes the district record its reasoning in detail and then requires the state to publish only the outcome, stripped of it. Clay's own paperwork says no violation, remains in collection. The state's list says removed or discontinued. Both are true, and only one of them is public in a form anyone will read.
Where the Record Contradicts the Record
One more thing, and we flag it as a question rather than a finding, because a document that disagrees with another document is a lead, not a verdict.
On Clay's January 2026 appeals sheet the words "Remove from ALL Libraries" occur exactly twice in six pages, both times in the appeal-result column, against Brave New World by Aldous Huxley and Delirium by Lauren Oliver. Every other result in that column keeps the book in the collection at one grade band or another, except three that read "Not in Collection," which reports where a book already is rather than ordering it anywhere. So those two are the only entries on the sheet that mean what an ordinary person means by the word "removed."
Neither title appears anywhere on the state's 2025-2026 list. We searched both the 2025-2026 and the 2024-2025 reports for the exact strings "Brave New World" and "Delirium." No hits in either report, in any county.
We do not know why, and we are not going to guess. It could be the timing of the district's June 30 submission, or a category the district assigned differently, or something ordinary. But the state's list is built entirely on what districts choose to write down, the state claims no verification, and here is one district's own published record of two books pulled from every library in the county, absent from the state's record of books pulled.
What You Can Actually Do
Pull your own county's page out of the state's PDF and see whether it prints titles or prints None Removed or Discontinued. It is twenty-eight pages, alphabetical by district.
Then go around the state and get the file that matters. Your district's school board agendas are public and almost certainly online. Search them for "reconsideration," "library materials," and "challenged." The backup document attached to that agenda item is where the actual reasoning lives, and it is the only place you will find out whether "removed" in your county meant a ban, a grade change, or a book nobody checked out.
And if you want the missing half, it is a public records request with a very short sentence in it: the district's most recent June 30 report to the Commissioner of Education under s. 1006.28(2)(e)3., including subparagraph c. That is the list of everything that was objected to and stayed.
The So-What
The state of Florida built a machine that produces a number every August, hands it to the press with no denominator and no definitions, and then stands back while everyone fights about it. The people who want to say look how many books Florida banned get a number. The people who want to say those aren't bans get to be technically right about a lot of the rows. Nobody gets the document that would settle it, because the state has it and does not publish it.
Meanwhile, in the county that removed more books than any other in Florida two years running, the decision arrives at the school board attached to item C9, gets adopted along with the fire alarms, and is recorded in the district's own hand as no violation of Florida statute.
That is not a scandal. That is a design.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week: pull the document, count what the state would not count, and tell you which half is missing. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse.
The Receipts
- 2025-2026 School District Reporting Pursuant to Section 1006.28(2), Florida Statutes (Florida Department of Education, Bureau of Standards and Instructional Support, posted Aug. 31, 2026; 28-page PDF; accessed September 11, 2026): the removal list itself, its scope paragraph, and every row this desk counted.
- 2024-2025 School District Reporting Pursuant to Section 1006.28(2), Florida Statutes (Florida Department of Education, 20-page PDF; accessed September 11, 2026): the prior-year comparison, counted by the identical method, and the report that carries Eon: Dragoneye Reborn in Clay's block.
- Section 1006.28, Florida Statutes (Florida Legislature, Online Sunshine, 2026 Florida Statutes; accessed September 11, 2026): the objection process, the five-school-day rule, the consent-agenda bar, the weeding language, and both halves of the June 30 report.
- October 2, 2025 Regular School Board Meeting agenda (School Board of Clay County, Agenda Plus; accessed September 11, 2026): item C9 under Consent Agenda, disposed of by Adoption of Consent Agenda.
- October 2025 Request for Review or Reconsideration of Library Materials Appeals (School Board of Clay County, board backup to item C9, 1 page; accessed September 11, 2026): seven appealed titles, "No longer in collection. Weeded due to circulation," and the footnote "*06/26/2025 School Board Meeting."
- January 8, 2026 Regular School Board Meeting agenda (School Board of Clay County, Agenda Plus; accessed September 11, 2026): item C4 under Consent Agenda.
- January 2026 Request for Review or Reconsideration of Library Materials Appeals (School Board of Clay County, board backup to item C4, 6 pages; accessed September 11, 2026): the review and appeal columns, the three named titles, and the two "Remove from ALL Libraries" results.
- April 2, 2026 Regular School Board Meeting agenda (School Board of Clay County, Agenda Plus; accessed September 11, 2026): item C12 under Consent Agenda.
- April 2026 Challenged Library Books, Appeals to School Board (School Board of Clay County, board backup to item C12, 2 pages; accessed September 11, 2026): the third appeals sheet of the school year.
- June 25, 2026 Regular School Board Meeting agenda (School Board of Clay County, Agenda Plus; accessed September 11, 2026): item C14 under Consent Agenda.
- July (June 25) 2026 Challenged Library Books, Appeals to School Board (School Board of Clay County, board backup to item C14; accessed September 11, 2026): the fourth appeals sheet of the school year.
- Clay County School Board Agendas index (School Board of Clay County, Agenda Plus; accessed September 11, 2026): the 561-row meeting index this desk searched for the school year's board items.