A state administrative law judge has recommended that Florida's Education Practices Commission dismiss every charge against an Advanced Placement Art History teacher at Douglas Anderson School of the Arts, a Jacksonville magnet school. She was charged over posts she made on or about September 11, 2025, after Charlie Kirk's killing.

The state got its hearing. It called its witnesses, it argued its case in writing, and it had to meet the standard Florida sets when it goes after a teacher's certificate: clear and convincing evidence. The judge went through the charges one at a time and found the state had not proved a single one.

We are not naming her. She is a private person, and this story is about what the state could prove. So we are going to ask the two questions this show asks of any prosecution. What did the state say she did. And what did it actually show.

The Receipt

The document is DOAH Case No. 25-5786PL, Amended Recommended Order (Sept. 21, 2026), signed by Administrative Law Judge Garnett W. Chisenhall. It recommends "a Final Order dismissing the charges."

It starts with the charges. The Commissioner of Education issued an administrative complaint against her on October 8, 2025. As the order quotes it, the complaint said she "posted unprofessional comments on her personal and open to the public social media account that were grossly immoral in the wake of the murder of public figure Charlie Kirk," and that she "posted or reposted an artist's rendition of an individual holding the screaming severed head of what clearly is intended to represent the President of the United States, Donald Trump."

The complaint cited three provisions of section 1012.795, Florida Statutes, subsections (1)(d), (1)(g) and (1)(j), and two professional-conduct rules, Rule 6A-10.081(2)(a)1 and Rule 6A-10.081(2)(b)1 of the Florida Administrative Code. The judge took them up as five counts: gross immorality; personal conduct that seriously reduces her effectiveness as a school district employee; breaking the Principles of Professional Conduct; and, under that heading, two specific duties, protecting students from conditions harmful to learning and keeping her personal views distinct from her school's.

Here is what she posted, as the judge found it. After Kirk was assassinated on September 10, 2025, she wrote on Facebook, "Karma's a bitch" and "she heard all your speeches when you proudly proclaimed that you didn't give a shit about other people's lives." She also shared a drawing of the writer E. Jean Carroll with President Trump's severed head in her hand. In a footnote, the judge called it "clearly a cartoon rather than an attempt to publish a realistic-looking depiction."

She testified to what she meant. Of the karma post: "There was nothing to celebrate that day." Of the drawing, that it is "a symbolic image that is about women who have been abused overcoming their abuser."

How the Machine Works

Discipline against a Florida teaching certificate runs on a track most people never see. Here is the track, as this order lays it out.

The prosecutor. The Commissioner of Education heads the Florida Department of Education and, in the order's first finding, is "statutorily authorized to investigate and prosecute disciplinary actions against those holding Florida educator certificates." The case now runs in the name of Commissioner Henry Mack, who took over from Anastasios Kamoutsas while it was pending. The order lists three lawyers appearing for the Commissioner, two of them at the Department of Education.

The complaint, then the referral. After the October 2025 complaint, she asked for a formal hearing, and the Education Practices Commission sent the case to the Division of Administrative Hearings on November 5, 2025.

The hearing. Judge Chisenhall heard it by Zoom on July 27, 2026. The state called three witnesses, and one of them was the teacher. She testified for herself and called her principal. Afterward both sides filed proposed recommended orders, which is where the state's best arguments, quoted below, come from.

The standard. Because discipline proceedings are "considered penal in nature," the order says, the Commissioner had to prove the allegations "by clear and convincing evidence." And the charges "must be strictly construed, with any ambiguity construed in the licensee's favor."

The recommendation. The judge entered his recommended order on September 18, 2026, and an amended recommended order on September 21, 2026. The amended version adds "Amended" to the title, changes the entry date, and changes the year the case was referred to DOAH from 2026 to 2025. Both recommend dismissing the charges. A recommendation is not the end. The order gives the parties 15 days to file exceptions, and the Education Practices Commission issues the final order. Exceptions go, in the order's words, to "the agency that will issue the Final Order in this case."

The limit on that final step. The Commission does not get a clean slate on the facts. The order states the rule: "An agency may not substitute its own facts for that of the ALJ so long as there is adequate evidence in the record to support the ALJ's factual findings."

Nobody Saw It in Class

Now the evidence, and this is the part the charges could not get past.

The district's professional-standards investigator received a complaint about the posts, investigated, and concluded there was a potential for them to disrupt district operations. The district then gave her a verbal warning, coaching and counseling, and a temporary reassignment to its Art Resource Center with no teaching duties. The order notes that nobody explained why the district moved her to a job without teaching.

What that same investigator did not find is the story. He found no evidence that the school's or the district's operations were disrupted. He found no teacher, administrator or student in the district who complained about her. He found no student who had seen the posts.

The state ran its own investigation. The chief of the Office of Professional Practices at the Department of Education opened it in September 2025 on complaints from the public. He spoke to about ten of her students, and not one said they had seen any of her posts. He found no evidence the posts disrupted operations at the school or anywhere else in the district, no student saying the posts had disrupted their education, and no evidence of any protests against her.

Then her principal testified. He got complaints when she was taken out of the classroom, and, the judge found, none about her character, her teaching, or how she dealt with students. Of her two classes, he said: "Not one of those students or parents ever said anything about the posts." The judge found that the principal would like to have her "back."

Why It Costs You

Start with the students. By the principal's count, she teaches about 50 students across two classes. The state's own proposed order says her removal from the classroom "began in September 2025, lasted the entirety of the 2025-2026 school year." On the reassignment, the judge wrote that "the Record lacks any persuasive explanation for why the School District took that action." He went further: the evidence, he wrote, "conclusively demonstrates" that she "is still capable of being an effective classroom teacher."

So by the state's own account, an Advanced Placement teacher her principal wants back spent a full school year out of the classroom, and the record does not say why.

She is not the only teacher in this position. The order cites a June 26, 2026 recommended order in a Sumter County School Board case that recommended dropping charges "arising from a teacher's social media activity following the Kirk assassination." The order lists that case's final order as pending.

And here is the cost that does not show up in any finding, and this is our read, not the judge's: every teacher in Florida can read this docket. The lesson a prosecution like this teaches does not wait for the verdict. It lands the day the complaint is filed.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

State it at full strength, in the state's own words from its proposed recommended order, as the judge quotes it.

On gross immorality, the state argued that circulating the drawing "conveys approval of lethal violence against a political figure."

On harm to students, it argued: "Content that trivializes a homicide and that generally depicts the decapitation of a national figure is a condition harmful to learning and to the mental health of the adolescent students who encounter it." It said the missing student witness did not matter: "No individual student was identified as having viewed the posts. That does not defeat the charge."

On keeping her views separate from her school's, it had a real fact, and the judge found it too: her Facebook and Instagram accounts note that she is employed as a Duval County teacher, and they carry no disclaimer. The state listed what she could have done instead: "She could have made the accounts private, removed any link to her employer, added a standing disclaimer, or declined to publish under a profile identifying her as a Duval County teacher."

And on her effectiveness, the state argued: "An educator who cannot be placed in front of students is an educator whose effectiveness as an employee of the district school board has been seriously reduced."

Read that last one twice, because this is our read of it: the district took her out of the classroom, and then the state pointed to her absence from the classroom as the proof that she could not teach.

Here is what the judge did with each argument.

On violence, he wrote that "the social media postings did not reflect any use, attempted use, or threatened use of violence" by her, and that the Commissioner had not argued that her post "was a legitimate threat to sever President Trump's head."

On harm to learning, he wrote that "the Commissioner offered no persuasive evidence, such as expert testimony from a child psychologist, to support that assertion," and no student testified that their learning or mental health took a hit. He also found that she tells students they cannot follow her on social media and blocks the ones who try.

On her service in the community, he found "no competent, substantial evidence that the social media postings at issue impaired [her] service in the community."

On speaking for her school, he wrote that "there is no evidence indicating that anyone could reasonably conclude that [her] sentiments were shared by her employers."

Count after count, the order says the same thing in different words: the state did not carry its burden.

The Question the Judge Could Not Answer

There is one argument this order does not decide, and the order says so.

At a June 5, 2026 status conference, the judge said he "had no authority to adjudicate the First Amendment argument" she had been making in her filings. He said she would be allowed to "build a record necessary for making a First Amendment argument to an appellate court." For that, the order leans on a 2025 decision of Florida's Fifth District Court of Appeal in a case against the Duval County School Board, which it quotes: a free-speech claim is one "the administrative law judge lacked authority to rule upon, but which can be asserted for the first time in a Florida appellate court, provided the record is sufficient to adjudicate the claim."

So this recommendation answers whether the state proved what its own statute and rules require. It does not answer whether Florida could punish these posts at all under the Constitution. That question belongs to an appellate court, if the case ever gets there, and the judge made room for the record it would need.

What You Can Actually Do

Read it yourself. The amended recommended order is public on the Division of Administrative Hearings site. The state's arguments and the judge's answers sit side by side in the conclusions of law. Nobody has to summarize it for you.

Watch the exceptions window. Both orders say the parties may file exceptions "within 15 days from the date of this Recommended Order." Neither says which of the two dates starts that clock, so we are not printing a deadline. After that window, the Education Practices Commission issues the final order. When it does, hold it against this one, and against the rule the order states about an agency substituting its own facts.

If you teach in Duval, read the policy. The order quotes the social media policy the district had in September 2025. And the state's own filing lists what it says a careful teacher does: private accounts, no link to the employer, a standing disclaimer. The judge did not hold her to that list. That list is still what the state argued, in writing, and you should know it before your next post. This is not legal advice; it is the state telling you its playbook.

The So-What

The state asked a judge to find that a teacher's posts after a killing were gross immorality, a danger to her students' learning, and a statement on behalf of her school. Then it had to prove it. None of the students its investigator spoke to said they had seen the posts. No colleague complained. The state brought no expert on harm. Her principal wants her back.

That is not a technicality. That is what proof means.

The recommendation is not the last word, and the Commission gets the last word. But it gets it on a record this thin, under a rule that says it may not swap in facts of its own where the judge's findings have support in that record.

Come back for the rest

We read the document, every time, and we send you what it says. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's receipts land in your inbox together.


The Receipts

Two versions of one order, both saved September 22, 2026; the amended order is cited by section.

  • Recommended Order (Florida Division of Administrative Hearings, DOAH Case No. 25-5786PL, ALJ Garnett W. Chisenhall, entered September 18, 2026, recommendation, p. 20; accessed September 22, 2026): the original recommendation, entered three days before the amended order.
  • Amended Recommended Order, Preliminary Statement (Florida Division of Administrative Hearings, DOAH Case No. 25-5786PL, ALJ Garnett W. Chisenhall, entered September 21, 2026, pp. 1 to 3; accessed September 22, 2026): the complaint, the charges, the hearing, the lawyers and the First Amendment ruling.
  • Amended Recommended Order, Findings of Fact (Florida Division of Administrative Hearings, DOAH Case No. 25-5786PL, paras. 1 to 18, pp. 4 to 8; accessed September 22, 2026): the posts, her testimony, both investigations, the reassignment and the principal.
  • Amended Recommended Order, Conclusions of Law and Recommendation (Florida Division of Administrative Hearings, DOAH Case No. 25-5786PL, paras. 19 to 39 and notice, pp. 8 to 21; accessed September 22, 2026): the burden, the state's arguments, each ruling, the cited cases and the exceptions notice.