Florida's own election-security office spent 2024 investigating the people who gathered signatures for the state's abortion-rights amendment. That same year, the amendment they qualified for the ballot went in front of voters and fell short, not of a majority, but of the supermajority the state constitution demands.
The Receipt
In a report dated December 20, 2024, addressed to Governor Ron DeSantis, Senate President Ben Albritton and House Speaker Daniel Perez, Florida's Office of Election Crimes and Security (OECS) wrote that it had "to date, opened well more than 100 preliminary criminal investigations into individual paid petition circulators and organizations involved in the collection of petitions on behalf of" Floridians Protecting Freedom, Inc., the group the report identifies as "the sponsor of Initiative Petition 23-07, 'Amendment to Limit Government Interference with Abortion.'" OECS wrote that it had "referred over a hundred individual FPF cases to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement (FDLE), which is actively pursuing dozens of criminal investigations together with the Office of Statewide Prosecution."
That initiative went before Florida voters in the November 2024 general election. Under Florida's official general-election results, it received 6,070,758 "yes" votes, 57.2% of those cast on the measure, against 4,548,379 "no" votes, 42.8%. Florida's constitution sets a higher bar for a citizen-initiated amendment than a plain majority. Article XI, Section 5(e) says a proposed amendment takes effect only "if the proposed amendment or revision is approved by vote of at least sixty percent of the electors voting on the measure." It cleared a majority of voters. It did not clear that line.
Why It Costs You
Nothing in the OECS report ties its investigations to the vote total, and this piece doesn't either; they are two separate facts about the same amendment, not one causing the other. But the practical result for anyone who voted yes is the same either way: Florida's abortion law did not change, because 57.2% is not 60%.
There's a second "who pays" in this one. The campaign the state was investigating paid the state money too. The report says Floridians Protecting Freedom "has paid over $186,000 in civil penalties to OECS for violations of Florida's election laws," including "a fine for $164,000... recently paid to OECS by FPF pursuant to a settlement agreement in December 2024," after Election Day, not before it; the report dates nothing else about the $186,000. That's money that moved from a ballot-measure campaign into a state agency's accounts.
How the Machine Works
The report's core allegation is that paid circulators, or the people who hired them, broke Florida's rules against paying circulators per signature collected. It says OECS has "received credible allegations that some of FPF's subcontractors paid individual circulators per petition collected," which it calls "a third-degree felony in Florida" under section 104.186 of the Florida Statutes. The report's own account of that statute explains why the charge is a felony: the Legislature first made per-signature payment a first-degree misdemeanor in 2019, then, because "the practice of paying per signature continued," the Legislature "increased the offense to a third-degree felony" in 2022.
The report also says plainly that its work "and its partners at FDLE and the Office of Statewide Prosecution have been stymied by a lack of recordkeeping and cooperation on the part of FPF and its agents." It says several paid FPF circulators were "arrested and charged with serious felonies" in early 2024, and that three "have since been convicted and sentenced, one to a multi-year prison term." This report is a supplement; OECS says it follows an October 11, 2024 interim report and that it expected to submit a further "Final Report on January 15, 2025." Neither of those other two reports was reviewed for this piece.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
Signature fraud is not a hypothetical problem the state invented for this campaign. Florida law has specifically targeted paying circulators by the signature since 2019, and the people the report says were arrested and charged with felonies were not merely accused: three "have since been convicted and sentenced, one to a multi-year prison term." If circulators are paid per signature, the incentive to forge one is built into the paycheck. An agency whose job is catching that kind of fraud has a plain, nonpolitical reason to open a file when a campaign's own paper trail doesn't hold up, whatever the campaign happens to be collecting signatures for.
What You Can Actually Do
Read the report. OECS's Supplemental Interim Report runs 447 pages; the letter explaining its findings is the first several.
Watch for the Final Report. OECS told the governor and legislative leaders it expected to submit one by January 15, 2025. This piece did not review it.
Check the vote yourself. Florida's official results for every 2024 constitutional amendment, including this one, are public.
The So-What
Two numbers belong to the same amendment. More than 100 criminal investigations, opened by the state, into the people who gathered its signatures. And 57.2% of voters who supported it anyway, short of the 60% the state constitution demands of any citizen initiative. Florida's government gets to police fraud in its own elections. The same constitution's 60% rule still means a clear majority of voters loses. Both things are true, and neither one explains the other.
Come back for the rest
When OECS's promised Final Report lands, we'll read it. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's receipts land in your inbox.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- OECS Supplemental Interim Report, Dec. 20, 2024 (Florida Office of Election Crimes and Security; accessed September 21, 2026): the investigation counts, FDLE referrals, fines and statute history.
- November 5, 2024 General Election, Official Results, Constitutional Amendment (Florida Department of State, Division of Elections; accessed September 21, 2026): the certified vote totals for the abortion-rights amendment.
- Florida Constitution, Article XI, Section 5 (Florida Senate, official constitution text; accessed September 21, 2026): the 60% threshold for amendments to the Florida Constitution.