Colorado hands out public money to preschools, public and private, Catholic ones included. The state also tells every preschool that takes that money the same thing: give every kid an equal shot at a seat, no matter their family's religion, their sexual orientation, their disability, their housing status. St. Mary and St. Bernadette, two Catholic parishes, along with a family and the Archdiocese of Denver, said no, we won't promise that, and Colorado said then you don't get the money. On November 3, the Supreme Court hears their case.

The Receipt

The case is St. Mary Catholic Parish, Littleton, Colorado, et al. v. Roy, No. 25-581. It was docketed November 17, 2025, after the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against the parishes below. The Supreme Court granted the petition on April 20, 2026, but only part of it: the Court agreed to hear Questions 1 and 2 of the three the parishes asked it to take up. Argument is set for Tuesday, November 3, 2026, confirmed on the Court's own docket as of October 4, 2026.

Here's what the Court did not agree to hear: whether to overturn Employment Division v. Smith. The parishes asked for that, as their third question presented lays out. The Court said no to that one. Whatever happens November 3, the question of whether to overrule Smith itself stays undecided.

How the Machine Works

Start with the program. Colorado runs a Universal Preschool Program that puts tax dollars behind a family's pick of preschool, whether that's a public classroom or a private one, religious schools among them. Any provider who wants a share of that money has to meet standards the state sets first.

One of those standards is not a side detail the department tacked on. The legislature wrote it directly into the statute that created the program: each preschool provider must give "eligible children an equal opportunity to enroll and receive preschool services regardless of race, ethnicity, religious affiliation, sexual orientation, gender identity, lack of housing, income level, or disability, as such characteristics and circumstances apply to the child or the child's family." That's Colorado Revised Statutes § 26.5-4-205(2)(b), passed by the state's elected legislature.

The department's own regulation then restates almost the identical sentence as a condition providers must meet to take the money: "[Eligible preschool providers] must ensure that children receive an equal opportunity to enroll and receive universal preschool services regardless of race, ethnicity, religious affiliation, sexual orientation, gender identity, lack of housing, income level, or disability, as such characteristics and circumstances apply to the child or the child's family." That's 8 CCR 1404-1, Rule 4.110(B), the version of the regulation now in force, effective July 30, 2026. The parishes' case was argued against an earlier numbering of the same rule, Rule 4.109(B); the equal-opportunity sentence itself hasn't moved. The rule lists it among the "minimum requirements as a condition of participating in the Preschool Program," in the regulation's own words; the statute is where the legislature put the requirement in the first place.

St. Mary and St. Bernadette, two Catholic parishes in the Denver area, along with a family and the Archdiocese of Denver, sued. They lost at the Tenth Circuit; per the parishes' own question presented, the appeals court applied Smith and held that Colorado's other exemptions and discretion in the program don't undermine the rule's general applicability. That's the ruling the parishes are asking the Supreme Court to reverse.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Colorado's own brief to the Supreme Court makes the state's case in its own words, and it's worth reading past the headline. The state argues the equal-opportunity requirement isn't something an agency invented and could waive if it wanted to: "[t]he UPK statute does not permit any exceptions to its equal-opportunity requirements," and the department's regulations "make clear" that any adjustment to how children get matched to providers must still comply with that same statutory requirement, filed August 17, 2026. The state says it has authority to let providers adjust how the matching algorithm weighs things like disability status or family income, but no authority to excuse any provider from the equal-opportunity rule itself. In the state's telling, there's no carve-out sitting there for Catholic parishes to ask for. There isn't one for anybody.

The parishes' petition tells a different story, and it's fair to say so plainly: it's their story, not a finding. The parishes argue Colorado "permits numerous exemptions from this requirement, both categorical and discretionary," allowing some preschools to admit only "children of color," "gender-nonconforming children," or "the LGBTQ community," along with low-income families or children with disabilities, while, in the parishes' telling, excluding Catholic preschools that want to admit only families who share its beliefs on sex and gender. That framing comes from the petitioners' own question presented; the Supreme Court hasn't ruled on whether it's accurate, and neither has this show.

Why It Costs You

Strip away the Supreme Court and what's left is a plain trade: public money for preschool, in exchange for a promise that every family's kid gets an equal shot at a seat. If the parishes win, a state that wants to keep funding Catholic preschools may have to let some of them keep public money while turning away kids over their parents' religion, orientation, or family makeup, something the legislature specifically wrote the statute to prevent. If the state's reading holds, religious providers that want the public dollars keep taking them on the same terms as everyone else, or they opt out and run on tuition and donations instead.

Either way, the fight isn't really about this one preschool program. It's the same argument that keeps showing up wherever public money and a religious provider's own rules meet: who sets the terms when the public is footing part of the bill.

What You Can Actually Do

Read the questions the Court actually agreed to decide. The petition's question presented page lists all three questions the parishes asked for, and marks which ones were granted.

Read the statute and the rule side by side. C.R.S. § 26.5-4-205(2)(b) and 8 CCR 1404-1, Rule 4.110(B) say almost the same thing in almost the same words. Decide for yourself whether that looks like an agency overreaching or a legislature being specific.

Watch November 3. Transcripts and audio of the argument post on the Court's own oral arguments page the same day.

The So-What

This isn't the case that decides whether Smith survives; the Court said no to that question before it even got to the argument stage. It's a narrower case about whether one state's specific equal-opportunity rule, written into statute by elected lawmakers and echoed in regulation, can coexist with a religious provider that wants different terms. Narrow cases still set the terms for the next fight. Pay attention to what the Court does with Questions 1 and 2, because that's the opinion that will actually get written.

Come back for the rest

More cases like this are coming. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's receipts land in your inbox.


The Receipts

  • Docket, No. 25-581 (Supreme Court of the United States; accessed October 4, 2026): docketing date, cert grant limited to Questions 1 and 2, and the November 3, 2026 argument date.
  • Question Presented, No. 25-581 (Supreme Court of the United States, cert. granted April 20, 2026; accessed September 15, 2026): the three questions the parishes asked the Court to decide and the petitioners' framing of Colorado's exemptions.
  • Colorado Revised Statutes, Title 26.5 (Colorado General Assembly, 2024 printout; accessed October 4, 2026): § 26.5-4-205(2)(b), the statutory equal-opportunity requirement.
  • 8 CCR 1404-1, Rule 4.110(B) (Colorado Secretary of State, Code of Colorado Regulations, Universal Preschool Program Rules, entire rule effective July 30, 2026; accessed October 4, 2026): the regulation's near-identical equal-opportunity requirement, numbered Rule 4.109(B) in the version the parties cite in the case record.
  • Brief for Respondents, No. 25-581 (Colorado Department of Early Childhood, merits brief, filed August 17, 2026; accessed September 15, 2026): the state's argument that neither the statute nor the regulation permits exceptions to the equal-opportunity requirement.
  • Oral Arguments, Supreme Court of the United States (accessed October 10, 2026): transcripts post the afternoon of argument day, audio later the same day.