Federal homelessness law has a phrase that decides who gets a bonus: proven to be effective. Congress wrote down what counts. On September 11, the Department of Housing and Urban Development published a notice in the Federal Register proposing to add five more things to that list, and it is asking the public what it thinks before it does.

You have until October 13, 2026 to answer.

So here are the two questions this piece is going to ask. Who gets to decide what counts as proven? And what did they have to show to do it?

The Receipt

The document is HUD's notice, docket FR-6628-N-01. Its summary says it "seeks public comment on activities HUD proposes to incent through the Continuum of Care (CoC) program," and that "These activities are proven to be effective at reducing homelessness or preventing homelessness." The notice calls the Continuum of Care the largest federal homelessness assistance program.

Here is what HUD says it has determined are proven effective activities, in five items:

  • Transitional housing with supportive services aimed at employment income and behavioral health care, "particularly for homeless youth, families, and survivors of domestic violence."
  • Supportive services, including treatment for substance use disorder and mental illness, delivered wherever people are: housing, shelter, a separate facility, or outreach on the street.
  • Participation agreements that engage people in services tailored to their needs.
  • Housing for people who have a substance use disorder or are recovering from one, "by providing drug-free housing, sober housing, and on-site behavioral healthcare and recovery support services."
  • "Coordination with law enforcement and first responders as crucial partners in addressing homelessness."

HUD says none of it is a new kind of project. The notice points to its existing rules at 24 CFR part 578, where transitional housing, services-only projects, participation agreements and sober housing are already eligible, and says the determination "does not establish new CoC Program components, create new eligible activities, or expand HUD's statutory authority." What changes is what gets rewarded. After the comments come in, HUD says it will either publish revisions or adopt the determinations as part of future Continuum of Care funding opportunities.

Congress Wrote a List, and a Door

Here is how the machine runs, and the whole fight lives in one section of the law.

Section 428(d) of the McKinney-Vento Homeless Assistance Act, codified at 42 U.S.C. 11386b, says "The Secretary shall provide bonuses or other incentives" for activities "that have been proven to be effective at reducing homelessness generally, reducing homelessness for a specific subpopulation, or achieving homeless prevention and independent living goals."

Then Congress wrote down what that includes. First on the list is "permanent supportive housing for chronically homeless individuals and families." Second, for homeless families: rapid rehousing, short-term subsidies to get past barriers to rehousing, and services that raise incomes to pay rent.

And then the door. The third item is "any other activity determined by the Secretary, based on research and after notice and comment to the public, to have been proven effective." Two locks on that door: research, and public comment. HUD's notice is HUD walking up to it.

One more line in that section matters here. Congress told the Secretary to "seek to maintain a balance among strategies targeting homeless individuals, families, and other subpopulations."

Why HUD Went to the Door Now

The notice says why, and it starts with a court. According to HUD's notice, the federal district court in Rhode Island ruled on August 7, 2026 that HUD's fiscal year 2026 Continuum of Care funding notice could not set aside money for transitional housing and "supportive services only" projects unless HUD first went through notice and comment. The notice names the cases as Washington v. HUD and National Alliance to End Homelessness v. HUD. The orders themselves were not read for this piece; they are described here only the way HUD describes them.

HUD doesn't accept those orders. The notice says HUD "does not concede the lawfulness of those orders" and "fully stands by its ability to implement all of the parts of its 2026 NOFO without going through notice and comment." It says it is publishing this notice "to reinforce its ability to establish the set-aside."

That funding notice is real money. HUD's June 1 announcement put it at $4.04 billion and said it included "a $1.3 billion investment in new projects, with a priority for Transitional Housing and Supportive Service projects." Secretary Scott Turner said in that announcement: "Housing alone will not solve a crisis driven by addiction and mental illness."

Why It Costs You

This is a competition. The notice says Congress directed HUD to award grants "on a competitive basis" in a "national competition," and that bonuses are one of the tools HUD uses to carry out its policies in that competition.

In a competition, a bonus for one kind of project is an edge over the application sitting next to it. The people living in whichever program loses the points are the ones who feel it. HUD's case is that since 2013 the programs losing out were transitional housing and services, which it says work especially well for homeless young people, families with kids and people surviving domestic violence. The law's own list puts permanent supportive housing, for people who are chronically homeless, first. Either way, the list decides whose program gets funded, and that is why five bullet points in the Federal Register are worth your evening.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

HUD has a real argument, so let's make it properly.

The money moved one way. The notice says 36 percent of the national Continuum of Care award went to transitional housing or services-only projects in 2009, and only 6 percent in 2024. It says the nationwide supply of permanent housing has increased 100 percent since 2013, and that over the same time the supply of transitional housing decreased 59.7 percent. HUD pins the shift on its own 2013 implementation of Housing First, which it quotes itself describing as "rapid placement and stability in permanent housing in which admission does not have preconditions."

The results didn't follow. The notice says chronic homelessness increased 80.5 percent since 2013 "despite a 44 percent increase nationwide in Permanent Supportive Housing beds during the same period."

It isn't against permanent housing. HUD writes that "Permanent Supportive Housing and re-housing services for families are not tied to a Housing First approach in statute," and it concedes that some people "may require long-term assistance."

It has research. On sober housing, the notice describes a 2025 systematic review in which people living in sober housing did better on drug and alcohol use, work, income and trouble with the law than people getting usual care or nothing at all. It describes an Oxford House study where people assigned to sober living homes had significantly lower substance use, higher monthly income and lower incarceration rates. On policing, it describes a program called the Homeless Outreach Services Team that it says resolved more than 1,500 encampments "with no arrests, no use of force, and no litigation," and it says unsheltered homelessness in Austin decreased by one-third two years after the city reinstated a ban on public camping.

Cities are already moving. HUD lists San Francisco, which it says stepped up the police response to illegal drug use in public, put money into housing that requires treatment and sobriety, and passed an ordinance for drug-free housing. It lists Portland's camping ban and its spending on short-term shelter and housing, Anchorage reporting its major encampments gone for the first time in a decade, and the mayor of Houston declaring he would be "reclaiming our public spaces."

That is the case at full strength. Services matter. People in recovery need somewhere to live that supports it. Take that seriously.

The Answer Is in the Same Two Documents

Now the catch, because the show doesn't sell you a clean ending. You don't need an outside expert to test HUD's case. Read the law it quotes and the notice it wrote.

Congress's list didn't do the crowding out. HUD's funding notices did, by HUD's own account. The notice says that beginning with the 2013 Continuum of Care funding notice, HUD "dramatically de-prioritized" transitional housing and services-only projects. The statute still names permanent supportive housing and rapid rehousing as proven effective, and HUD's determination adds five activities without taking either one off. The shift HUD describes was made in HUD's own rules for its own competitions.

The law's test has three parts, "reducing homelessness generally, reducing homelessness for a specific subpopulation, or achieving homeless prevention and independent living goals," and the outcomes are worth reading closely. The sober-housing studies HUD describes report outcomes like substance use, employment, income and incarceration, and its summary adds housing stability. HUD has an answer ready: the statute also counts "independent living goals," which the notice says cover homeless youth and families with kids, and take in problems like substance use disorder and barriers to employment. That is a fair reading to argue about. It is also worth noticing that HUD describes sober housing as "designed specifically for individuals living in recovery," so the question for a comment is whether research on people in recovery shows the same thing for everyone the program serves.

Fewer tents is not the same count as fewer homeless people. The Austin figure is unsheltered homelessness. The Anchorage milestone is major encampments. HUD's summary of those results doesn't say where the people went. Those figures speak to the part of the law's test about reducing homelessness, generally or for a specific subpopulation, only if the people counted stopped being homeless rather than moved. A comment can ask.

A trend line is not a study. HUD's own comparison says homelessness decreased 8.8 percent from 2007 to 2013 and increased 27 percent from 2013 to 2026. Those are counts over time. They don't show what would have happened under a different policy, and that is exactly what "based on research" is supposed to settle. To be fair, HUD cites controlled studies too, including randomized trials with young homeless mothers. The studies behind every figure in the notice were not opened for this piece; they are described here the way the notice describes them.

Whatever HUD says it needed, the process is yours. HUD says it didn't need notice and comment for its 2026 funding notice. The Rhode Island court, as HUD's notice describes it, held that HUD did need it for the set-aside. This notice goes through notice and comment under the clause that requires research and public comment before the Secretary adds to the list. That makes your comment one of the two locks, not a formality.

What You Can Actually Do

Comment by October 13, 2026. Go to Regulations.gov, docket HUD-2026-1453. The notice says every submission has to cite the docket number and the title: FR-6628-N-01, "Notice of Research Justifying Additional Incentives for Certain Activities To Reduce Homelessness." You can also mail a comment to "the Regulations Division, Office of General Counsel, Department of Housing and Urban Development, 451 7th St. SW, Washington, DC 20410."

Don't wait for the last night. Regulations.gov's record for the notice lists the comment period ending at 11:59 p.m. Eastern on October 13 and marks late comments as not allowed.

Assume it will be public. The Federal Register's comment form says "All comments are considered public and will be posted online" once HUD has reviewed them. Leave out anything you wouldn't put on a flyer.

Make it about the research. The law asks whether an activity is proven effective, based on research, at "reducing homelessness generally, reducing homelessness for a specific subpopulation, or achieving homeless prevention and independent living goals." Pick one of the five items. Say what outcome the evidence measures and which of those it speaks to. One fair question to press: does it show fewer homeless people? If you run a program, work in one, or have lived in one, say what you saw, plainly.

Read the two sections that matter yourself. The notice's research sections on sober housing and on law enforcement are long, and they are the whole case. The statute is short.

The So-What

Congress wrote a list and a door. HUD is walking through the door, and the law lets it try. But the door has two locks, research and the public, and one of them is you. Bless its heart, a federal agency asked what you think. Tell it, by October 13.

Come back for the rest

We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts

Every claim above traces to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.