On Friday, Oct. 23, Florida's attorney general filed a complaint in circuit court in Polk County against First Street Technology, Inc., the company behind the Flood Factor number that sits on a home listing next to the square footage. The state says the number is deceptive. The first sentence of the pleading says it plainer than that: "Deciding to buy a home these days is hard enough without dealing with fake flood risk."

I've read all 45 pages, and I'll tell you what's in them. But I want you to hold one question the whole way through, because it's the one this show always asks. When a number on a listing is about to go away, who decided it should go, and who gets paid when it does?

The Receipt

The complaint's best evidence is a house. Paragraph 107 describes "a residential property, listed on Redfin, in Oldsmar, Pinellas County, Florida," and calls it Property A. The complaint says FEMA's National Flood Hazard Layer puts that house in "Zone X-Area of Minimal Flood Hazard," the lowest federal classification there is.

Paragraph 108 says First Street scored the same house a 7 out of 10 on its Flood Factor, with the label "Major," and that the listing told a buyer that score meant "an estimated 74-82% chance of a flood reaching the building in the next 30 years."

Then the state reads First Street's own rulebook back to it. Paragraph 109 quotes the company's methodology page, that properties "with at least a 99% chance of flooding over 30 years will have a Flood Factor of 6 or higher," and calls the gap between that rule and the 74 to 82 on the listing "an internal inconsistency within First Street's own scoring framework." The pleading calls it a 25-point gap nobody explains on the page.

The same listing, paragraph 110 says, carried a heat score of 10 and a line promising "7 days above 108° expected this year."

A federal map and a private score, on one house, and they can't both be right. That's the receipt, and it's a good one. The complaint's footnote gives the street address. This show doesn't. It's a house in Oldsmar, somebody lives there, and that's all you need.

Why It Costs You

Start with where the number lives. The complaint says First Street's scores are, or have been, displayed on listings at Zillow, Realtor.com and Redfin, and that the average buyer never goes looking for them. The score comes to you. And per paragraph 6, the number is free while the data behind it sits behind a paywall, so what most buyers get is a foreboding digit with no explanation they can check.

Now the two sides of a sale. If you're selling, the complaint's first paragraph has you covered in three words: "Sellers suffer, too." A buyer who sees a 7 and the word "Major" either walks or asks for money off, and the state's pleading leans on Zillow's and Realtor.com's own research to argue that high-score homes sell slower and for less. If you're buying, the number is the thing standing between you and a house you can afford, and you've got no way to tell whether it's right.

Here's the part that makes it a trap instead of a quirk. The complaint quotes First Street's own dispute page: "[a]s a rule, we do not update Factor scores based on individual ... disputes." So the seller can't fix it, the buyer can't verify it, and the company that put it there says it won't move it.

Meanwhile the federal map does something the private score doesn't. The complaint lays it out in paragraph 38: a federally backed mortgage requires flood insurance if the house sits in a FEMA flood zone, and most private lenders insist on it too. The FEMA map is the one that reaches into your closing costs. The First Street number reaches into your nerve.

How the Machine Works

The law is short. The suit rests on section 501.204(1) of the state's deceptive and unfair trade practices law, FDUTPA, which declares "unfair or deceptive acts or practices in the conduct of any trade or commerce" unlawful. There are two counts: one for unfair and unconscionable practices, one for deceptive ones.

What the state wants is in the prayer for relief. It asks the court to enjoin First Street from "Claiming to provide the 'most accurate estimate of risk'" without disclosing the uncertainty in its scoring, and from calling its scores "peer reviewed" in a way a reasonable consumer would read as covering the score on a single property. It asks for consumer redress and disgorgement. And it asks for civil penalties the complaint puts at $10,000 per violation, or $15,000 when the violation involves a senior citizen, citing sections 501.2075 and 501.2077 of the statutes. I'm giving you those figures as the complaint cites them; I did not open those two sections myself.

Now the sentence that made the headlines. Paragraph 58 says First Street "is marketing fear to advance a climate activism agenda while exploiting the same fear to line their pockets." Read where it sits. That line is not from a podium. It's a numbered paragraph in a filed complaint, signed by assistant attorneys general in the Tampa consumer protection office. The news release the office put out the same day is three sentences and quotes nobody. What the attorney general did say in his own voice, in the video post announcing the suit, was that "Florida homeowners deserve facts, not alarmist scores that hit their property values and their wallets." Different register, same target. The "climate activism agenda" line belongs to the complaint, and I'm leaving it there.

Here's the turn. Ask who the plaintiff is.

The plaintiff is the State of Florida. And the State of Florida is not a bystander in the question of how risky a Florida house is. Open section 627.351 of the same statute book and you'll find Citizens Property Insurance Corporation, which the Legislature created because, in its own words, "private insurers are unwilling or unable to provide affordable property insurance coverage in this state to the extent sought and needed." Citizens exists to write policies for "applicants who are in good faith entitled to procure insurance through the voluntary market but are unable to do so." The statute is careful about what Citizens is: "a government entity that is an integral part of the state, and that is not a private insurance company."

So put the two documents side by side. The state owns the insurance company that takes the houses private insurers won't. The state has now sued the private company whose score tells a buyer a house is riskier than the federal map says. I am not telling you the one caused the other; the complaint never mentions Citizens, and I checked. I'm telling you that a state in that position has a view about which number a buyer should see, and it isn't a neutral referee between a map and a model.

And the defendant? The complaint describes a Delaware public benefit corporation based in New York, which, in the state's own telling, is "a venture-capital-backed enterprise, owned by a financial analytics firm." Nobody at this table is a charity.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

First Street hadn't answered when the Phoenix asked, so I'll build its case from what the state itself put in the record, which is fairer than guessing.

The company's explanation for disagreeing with FEMA is quoted in paragraph 40 of the complaint: FEMA "determines flood risk on the community level," its maps capture "a single 1-in-100 or 1-in-500 event from storm surges and overflowing rivers and streams," while Flood Factor "calculates flood risk on the property level, accounts for changing climate conditions, and considers the risk of flooding due to high-intensity rainfall." That's not a dodge. A map drawn for a community and a model run for a parcel are measuring different things, and rain that falls faster than the storm drains can take it has flooded plenty of houses that no surge map ever colored blue.

And the state concedes the bigger point in its own words. Paragraph 88 says that "some models may predict significant property-level risk for a particular home, while other models predict nearly no risk for the same home," and the complaint's own cited study, in paragraph 85, says there is "a great deal of uncertainty about the modelling of physical risk." If disagreeing with FEMA were fraud, every forecaster in the state would be a defendant.

Here's where that defense runs out. The Oldsmar house isn't a case of model versus map. It's a case of the model versus its own rulebook. A score the company says means at least 99 percent, shown next to a line that says 74 to 82, is a problem First Street wrote for itself, and the state is right to point at it. The question a court will have to answer is whether that's a deceptive practice or a sloppy webpage, and I don't know, and neither does anyone who tells you they do.

What You Can Actually Do

Look up any Florida address on the federal map yourself. FEMA's Flood Map Service Center is at msc.fema.gov. Type in the address and it shows you the zone. Do that before you believe anything a listing says about water, in either direction.

Read the listing's score as a model, not a map. A Flood Factor is one company's forecast, built on choices you can't see without paying. The FEMA zone is the number your lender uses. They answer different questions, and the honest move is to hold both and ask what each one is missing.

If you're selling, know which number the buyer saw. The complaint says First Street won't change a score on request. The federal map, at least, is a public record you can print and hand over.

Read the complaint. It's 45 pages and it reads fast. Every figure in this piece is in it by paragraph number.

The So-What

Two numbers sit on a listing. One comes from the federal government, and it decides whether you're forced to buy flood insurance. The other comes from a private company, and it decides whether you flinch. Florida has now sued the one that makes you flinch, in the name of the buyer, while owning the insurer that catches the houses the private market has already flinched at.

Somebody is going to decide which number a Florida buyer gets to see. A judge in Polk County, probably. Just understand that nobody arguing in front of that judge is arguing for you.

Come back for the rest

We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts

Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.