Florida passed a law this spring that puts a stopwatch on farmland. If a county doesn't approve or deny certain development applications within 90 days, the land gets certified anyway. St. Johns County has spent its fall fighting that clock, and News4JAX reported on September 28 that the county had taken back two of its own yes votes.
The state calls the land an agricultural enclave. The law is CS/CS/CS/SB 686, it became Chapter 2026-34, and it took effect July 1. It's worth reading slowly, because the deadline is the least of what it does.
So we're going to ask the two questions this show always asks. Who decided a county's vote should come with a timer. And who pays when it runs out.
The Receipt
Here's the sentence, from paragraph (c) of the enrolled text of the law: "If the local government does not approve or deny certification of the parcel or parcels as an agricultural enclave within 90 days after receipt of the application, the parcel or parcels must be certified as an agricultural enclave."
Silence counts as a yes. That's the design, written down.
The rest of the clock sits around it. Within 30 days of receiving an application, the county owes the applicant a written report on whether it complies. Within 30 days of that report, the county has to hold a public hearing and approve or deny. A denial has to come in writing "with detailed findings of fact and conclusions of law," and the applicant then has 30 days to take it to circuit court.
The Senate Rules Committee's staff analysis calls agricultural enclaves "pockets of agricultural land that are mostly surrounded by development." The law judges the land as it stood on January 1, 2025. In the main test, it's owned or controlled by one person or entity, it's been in bona fide agricultural use for five years, and at least 75 percent of its edge borders existing development, or land the county has marked for development in its plan and maps, at least half of which is already built. The law adds other routes in, including land beside an interstate and land inside a rural study area the county's plan meant for housing.
It can be big. The cap is 1,280 acres, which is two square miles. Where at least 75 percent of the edge is residential development that will reach 1,000 residents per square mile at buildout, the cap is 4,480 acres, which is seven. The application St. Johns County voted down on September 15 covered about 4,400 acres, News4JAX reported. That's close to seven square miles of what the Senate's own staff analysis calls a pocket.
One line decides where the law reaches. It covers only land in a county "with a population of 1.75 million or less," counted by the state's most recent official estimate.
How the Machine Works
Certification is the door. Here's what's on the other side of it.
Once the land is certified, the owner may submit plans for single-family homes that match what a neighboring parcel or development is allowed, down to its density. Then paragraph (e) says that development "must be treated as a conforming use, notwithstanding the local government’s comprehensive plan, future land use designation, or zoning."
Read that one twice. The comprehensive plan is the document every Florida county keeps to guide its growth, and the Rules analysis itself says all development, public and private, has to be consistent with it. Paragraph (e) says an enclave's houses conform anyway.
Paragraph (f) sets the ceiling. A local government "may not enact or enforce a law or regulation for an agricultural enclave which is more burdensome than for other types of applications for comparable uses or densities." It also has to treat an enclave that borders an urban service district as though it sat inside one.
Paragraph (g) sets the second clock. Within 30 business days of getting the plans, the county and the owner must agree in writing on a process and schedule for final approval, which may be administrative. The county can't require a process longer than 180 days, and it can't require any further review of the plans "in a quasi-judicial process or public hearing."
Now count the public hearings. There's the certification hearing in paragraph (c). After that, the county can't require another one for the plans. The one place in this law where a neighbor gets a microphone is a hearing that runs on a timer.
Why It Costs You
Houses need roads, water, sewer and schools, and the law knows it. To qualify, an enclave has to have public services available or scheduled, or the applicant can offer "to enter into a binding agreement to pay for, construct, or contribute land for its proportionate share of such improvements." A promise to pay a share can meet the test. The statute names the enclave's share. It doesn't say who covers the rest.
That's the question St. Johns County residents carried to the microphone. At the meeting where the commission reversed itself, residents stood up about their water supply and traffic, stormwater and roads, schools and emergency services, and the building that keeps coming, News4JAX reported. Commissioner Taylor wanted to know where the county had identified and set money aside for the road, water and sewer projects this land would need, the station reported, and answered herself: "Clearly we don’t have that. We don’t have that."
Now look at what the Legislature's own staff wrote down. The Rules analysis's fiscal impact statement scores the government sector impact as "None." A law that hands every county under the population line a deadline, a ceiling on its rules and an automatic yes was scored as having no fiscal impact on government.
St. Johns County's summer says otherwise. News4JAX reports the county received multiple enclave applications on July 1, the day the law took effect.
What St. Johns County Did With It
The station has reported three votes. On August 19, the commission approved two enclave applications. On September 15, it voted 3-2 to reject the application for the property of about 4,400 acres. Then, in a report published September 28, News4JAX said the commission had voted 3-2 to deny the two applications it approved in August.
Before one of the hearings, the deputy county attorney told the board what the law let it decide, according to the station: "The board is not being asked today whether it supports or opposes a particular development as a matter of policy. Rather, the board’s role is to determine, based upon the evidence presented, whether each application meets the requirements established by state law."
That's the machine in one breath. An elected board doesn't get to weigh whether it wants the houses. It gets to check boxes.
So the fight moved to the boxes. Some of the law's perimeter tests turn on an "urban service district, area, or line." County staff told the board it had used the county's development area boundary in place of that term, News4JAX reported. Taylor disagreed: "The development area boundary is a very general growth management line whereas an urban service area is a very specific designation that the statute specifically defines."
Commissioner Christian Whitehurst brought the two August approvals back for a discussion of the standards the county was using, the station reported, and said the decision should rest "on the evidence, not on politics." The applicants' attorney questioned whether the commission had the authority to reconsider and asked it to uphold the August votes. After the September 15 denial, News4JAX reported, the decision was expected to end up in a legal fight. The law has already said where that goes: a petition in circuit court, filed within 30 days.
Who Set the Clock
The bill history shows the bill filed in the Senate on December 1, 2025, with Senator McClain as its introducer. Then came three committees. Community Affairs passed it 8-0. Judiciary passed it 11-0. Rules passed it 23-0. Nobody in three committee rooms voted no.
The full Senate passed it 34-2 on February 26. The two no votes are printed on the roll as Davis-5 and Smith-17. The House passed it 90-20 on March 11. The governor approved it April 20.
News4JAX identifies state Rep. Kim Kendall as a House member who represents St. Johns County. The House roll call prints Kendall-18 as a yes. The station reports that in a video posted in mid-July, Kendall said the bill didn't look to her like it would preempt local control. It also reports her saying that had she known it would cause a problem, she'd have voted no.
Hold that phrase next to paragraph (e), which makes an enclave's houses a conforming use "notwithstanding" the county's own plan and zoning. Local control is a phrase. Paragraph (e) is the law.
The station also names state Sen. Tom Leek as representing the area and reports he didn't respond. The Senate roll call prints Leek-7 as a yes.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
The case for the law is housing, and it isn't a silly case. A leftover field boxed in by subdivisions is an obvious place to build. A deadline keeps an application from sitting in a drawer for years. And the law does put fences around it.
To apply at all, a neighboring parcel or development has to allow the same density as the proposed homes, or higher. The Rules Committee added a rule that an applicant can't use the edge of another certified enclave to qualify, which its analysis says was "to avoid a domino effect." The law leaves existing protections in place for the Wekiva Study Area, the Everglades Protection Area, areas of critical state concern, land under a recorded conservation easement and military installations. It encourages wildlife-friendly site design where a project affects an established wildlife corridor. The county can still say no. And the whole thing is temporary: the enclave changes expire January 1, 2028, and the text reverts to what it said on June 30, 2026.
Here's the answer. A deadline to decide is fair. A deadline where silence becomes a yes, plus a ban on any rule "more burdensome" than for comparable projects, plus a bar on further public hearings for the plans, isn't a deadline. It moves the decision. The county keeps its no only if it says it on time, in writing, with findings that can hold up in circuit court.
And temporary is a window, not a brake. The law runs 18 months, from July 1, 2026 to January 1, 2028. St. Johns County found out how fast that window opens when its applications came in on day one.
What You Can Actually Do
Read paragraphs (c), (e), (f) and (g). They're on pages 3 and 4 of the enrolled text, and they're short.
Ask your county how many. If your county is under 1.75 million people, ask the planning office how many agricultural enclave applications it has received since July 1, and the date each one's 90 days runs out.
Ask what your county uses for "urban service area." That's the term St. Johns County's commissioners and staff fought over, and the answer decides which land qualifies.
Show up to the certification hearing. Paragraph (c) requires one for every application, within 30 days of the county's report. It's the one public hearing this law builds in.
Check your legislators' votes. The Senate roll call and the House roll call list every member. As written, these rules expire January 1, 2028. Keeping them longer would take a new vote. Ask yours which way they'll go.
The So-What
Florida didn't take the vote away from St. Johns County. It put a timer on it, capped the rules the county can apply, and wrote that when the timer runs out, the answer is yes.
A county can still say no. It just has to say it in 90 days, in writing, with findings built for a courtroom, about land the state has told it not to burden, for houses the state has already called conforming.
That's not local control. That's a countdown with a public hearing attached.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- CS/CS/CS/SB 686: Agricultural Enclaves (The Florida Senate, bill page, 2026 Regular Session; accessed September 28, 2026): Chapter 2026-34, the July 1 effective date, the bill history and committee votes.
- Enrolled text of CS/CS/CS/SB 686 (Florida Legislature, 2026686er, 9 pages; accessed September 28, 2026): the 90-day clause, paragraphs (a) through (i), the definition and the 2028 expiry.
- Bill Analysis and Fiscal Impact Statement, CS/CS/CS/SB 686 (Florida Senate Committee on Rules staff, February 25, 2026; accessed September 28, 2026): the enclave definition, the domino rule and the "None" government sector fiscal line.
- Senate roll call, CS/CS/CS/SB 686 third reading (The Florida Senate, February 26, 2026; accessed September 28, 2026): the 34-2 vote and each senator's vote.
- House roll call, CS/CS/CS/SB 686 passage (The Florida House of Representatives, March 11, 2026; accessed September 28, 2026): the 90-20 vote and each member's vote.
- “St. Johns commissioners deny two previously approved agricultural enclave applications” (News4JAX / WJXT, September 28, 2026; accessed September 28, 2026): the 3-2 reversal, the boundary dispute and the commissioners' remarks.
- “Who helped write SB 686? Inside the law reshaping development in St. Johns County” (News4JAX I-Team / WJXT, September 28, 2026; accessed September 28, 2026): the September 15 vote, July 1 applications, and the legislators' responses.