SAVE, the Homeland Security system that checks citizenship for states, has not been working the same way everywhere. In Florida, Ohio, Indiana and Iowa, a federal court ordered DHS to reinstate SAVE's Social Security search and bulk upload, and the government told the Supreme Court on September 8 that it had restored certain features of the updated system for those four states and kept them disabled for everyone else. Two federal judges, two orders pointing in opposite directions, and a stay application at the Supreme Court were the reason. On September 25, the Court granted the stay.
Here is where it stands. On September 25, 2026, the Supreme Court granted the government's application in No. 26A308 and stayed the Washington court's June 22 order while the appeal in the D.C. Circuit and any petition for certiorari are decided. The unsigned majority opinion says the League's side likely has standing, but "their claims likely lack merit," because in 8 U.S.C. 1373, passed in 1996, Congress authorized DHS to request and receive citizenship information "[n]otwithstanding any other provision of Federal, State, or local law." In dissent, Justice Jackson, with Justices Sotomayor and Kagan, faulted the Court for acting "without full briefing or oral argument" and for disregarding "the harms that the modified SAVE system has caused, and will likely continue to cause, to lawful voters." The majority also conceded a limit. Under the National Voter Registration Act, a state must complete any program meant to "systematically remove the names of ineligible voters" at least 90 days ahead of a federal primary or general election, and the majority wrote that this moratorium "limits the potential impact" of the stay. A stay is not the end of the case. The Court said the League's claims likely fail, not that they do, and the appeal goes on. The documents below still tell you how four states ended up with their own version of a federal system.
The Receipt: A Settlement That Wrote the Features Down
SAVE is the Homeland Security system that checks citizenship for states. According to the government's stay application, in May 2025 DHS changed SAVE so users could search by Social Security number rather than an alien registration number, and send requests in bulk. The government says the updated system "processed more than a million requests each day."
Florida had already sued DHS in the Northern District of Florida in 2024, later joined by Iowa, Indiana and Ohio. On November 28, 2025, the four states and DHS signed a settlement agreement. Paragraph 10 is the receipt. It says that no later than 60 days after execution, DHS will ensure SAVE has, at a minimum, free use by state, local, tribal and territorial agencies, searches with full Social Security numbers, searches with the last four digits, and bulk uploads so requests need not be entered one at a time. Paragraph 17 adds that nothing in the agreement requires DHS to do anything that would conflict with the Constitution or a federal statute then in force.
On December 1, 2025, the Florida court dismissed the case, approved the settlement and incorporated it into its order, and kept jurisdiction for 20 years to enforce it, the court's July 7 order recounts. That order says DHS performed its obligations from December 2025 to June 2026, including the bulk-upload and Social Security search functions.
How the Machine Works: Two Courts, Two Orders
The League of Women Voters and allied advocacy groups sued over the modified system in federal district court in Washington in September 2025, the stay application says. On June 22, 2026, that court vacated the notices announcing the SAVE updates and the modified system itself. It found the system broke three federal laws, according to the application: the Privacy Act, the Administrative Procedure Act and the Social Security Act. The government disabled the modified system, and the Florida order puts the date at June 23.
Now the second court. On June 30, the four states filed an emergency motion in Florida to enforce the settlement, with declarations from officials in Florida, Iowa and Ohio. According to the Florida order, Iowa said it could not meet a state law requiring citizenship checks on people applying for professional licenses, and Florida and Ohio said they could not meet their own laws requiring citizenship checks on registered voters. The League and the Electronic Privacy Information Center weighed in as amici, arguing DHS was not in violation.
On July 7, 2026, U.S. District Judge T. Kent Wetherell II granted it. He ordered DHS to "immediately comply" with the settlement by reinstating the states' access to the bulk-upload and Social Security search features. He wrote that his court is not bound by the Washington order and, "with all due respect, the Court disagrees with the conclusions in that order." He named the bind plainly: DHS now faced two contradictory orders, and "One of the orders has to give."
Read his footnote five, because it carries the weight. The judge conceded he had not closely examined whether the settlement's features were legal when he approved it, and said he would not have signed off if he had any concern they were unlawful. Then, having read the Washington ruling, he said it outright: in his view, neither the Privacy Act nor the Social Security Act forbids the features. In another footnote he called it unfortunate that the parties in his case did not raise the Washington case before he approved the settlement "and/or" that the parties in the Washington case did not bring his approval order to that judge's attention sooner.
The government told the Supreme Court on September 8 that it had restored certain features of the updated system for the four states in the Florida case while keeping them disabled for everyone else. The League joined the Florida case and took the order up to the Eleventh Circuit. The League's Supreme Court opposition, filed September 15, lists that appeal as No. 26-12533 and says: "That appeal is ongoing." Meanwhile, back in the Washington case, a divided D.C. Circuit panel denied the government a stay, with Judge Katsas dissenting, and on September 8 the Solicitor General took the stay request to the Supreme Court.
Why It Costs You: What a Non-Match Starts
The government says SAVE does not disqualify any voter and never says outright that someone is not a citizen. When a search fails to confirm citizenship, its application says, the user is prompted to "contact the [individual] to obtain proof of U.S. citizenship." The application also quotes the agency that runs SAVE saying the system does not decide who qualifies for a given benefit; the agency handing out the benefit, usually a state or local office, does.
So the cost of a bad match lands on the voter who is asked for proof. The League says the modified system has produced error rates "as high as 81% in some localities," and its brief says at least 81 percent of the modified system's answers to St. Louis County, Missouri were wrong. It also says the government has never disclosed the system's error rate. The 81 percent is the League's figure, from an advocacy filing, and this piece did not open the data behind it.
If you are registered to vote in Florida, you live in one of the four states where the government says those features are back on.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
The government's case starts with a statute. Under 8 U.S.C. 1373(c), DHS must answer a state's citizenship inquiry, and the application argues that duty trumps whatever limits the Privacy Act and Social Security law might place on sharing those records. It says turning the features off means returning to "an older, more cumbersome, and less reliable version of the system." Texas told the Court it ran all 18 million voters on its list through the program in bulk and at no cost, and that doing it before would have meant paying DHS record by record. And the Florida judge wrote that the interests the League's side was vindicating are far outweighed by the states' sovereign interests in keeping noncitizens off their voter rolls.
That is a serious argument, made by a federal court and two governments, and it deserves to be read that way. The answer is in the same stack of paper. The League opens its brief with this: "Congress has not authorized the federal government to create a master database of U.S. citizens." Its counter is that a duty to answer a state is not a license to build, and that nothing is lost by waiting: "Agencies remain free to use SAVE for individualized citizenship checks as they did for decades prior to 2025." The League also points to the timing, saying the four states and DHS executed the Florida agreement two months after the Washington suit was filed and eleven days after the Washington judge wrote that she doubted the lawfulness of the government's actions. And the Florida order itself calls one of the amici's arguments "not without some merit": the agency whose cooperation the Social Security search needs is not a party to the Florida case. The League names that agency as the Social Security Administration.
What You Can Actually Do
Check your registration. The Florida Department of State's voter lookup says: "Check here for your voter registration status." It asks for your name and date of birth as they appear on your registration record. For where to vote, a sample ballot or the status of a mail ballot, the page points you to your Supervisor of Elections' website.
If an election office asks you for proof of citizenship, know what that step is. By the government's own description, it is what SAVE prompts when a search cannot confirm a match. It is not SAVE declaring you a noncitizen, and SAVE is not the office deciding your eligibility.
Watch two appeals, not one. The Supreme Court granted the stay in No. 26A308 on September 25, and it holds while the D.C. Circuit decides the appeal in the Washington case, No. 26-5243, and through any petition for certiorari. The League's appeal of the Florida order is No. 26-12533 in the Eleventh Circuit. They are separate cases in separate courts.
Read the Florida order. It runs 10 pages, and the judge's reasoning, including footnote five, is all there.
The So-What
A citizenship check that runs against Social Security records has worked one way in four states and another way everywhere else, and the line between them was drawn by a settlement agreement and a court order, not by a vote in Congress. On September 25, the Supreme Court stayed the Washington order that switched the features off for everyone else. Whether the government now turns them back on everywhere, the records we opened do not yet say, and the appeals will decide how long the stay holds.
Come Back for the Rest
We read the settlement, the order and the briefs so you can hold this piece up against them. For the last time the Court's emergency docket and your ballot met, read what the mail ballot order did not decide. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and subscribe to The Long Pour so the next ruling lands in your inbox with the receipts attached.
The Receipts
- Docket for No. 26A308, Department of Homeland Security v. League of Women Voters (Supreme Court of the United States; accessed September 26, 2026): the filings from September 8, the D.C. Circuit case number and the September 25 order granting the stay.
- Per curiam opinion and dissent on application for stay, No. 26A308 (Supreme Court of the United States, September 25, 2026, per curiam pp. 1-7 and dissent of Justice Jackson pp. 1-12; accessed September 26, 2026): the stay, the majority's section 1373 reasoning, the 90-day concession and the dissent.
- Application to Stay the Order of the U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia (Solicitor General, No. 26A308, September 8, 2026, pp. 2-10; accessed September 16, 2026): the SAVE update, the lower-court rulings and the four-state restoration, as the government tells it.
- Respondents' Opposition to Application for a Stay (League of Women Voters et al., No. 26A308, September 15, 2026, pp. 1-3, 10, 12; accessed September 16, 2026): the League's objection, its 81 percent figure and the Eleventh Circuit appeal.
- Brief of the State of Texas in Support of Applicants (State of Texas, No. 26A308, September 15, 2026, p. 2; accessed September 16, 2026): Texas's 18 million voters run in bulk at no cost.
- Settlement Agreement, Florida v. Department of Homeland Security (N.D. Fla. No. 3:24-cv-509, Doc. 30-1, November 28, 2025, paras. 10 and 17, via CourtListener RECAP; accessed September 16, 2026): the features DHS agreed SAVE would keep.
- Order granting motion to enforce settlement agreement (N.D. Fla. No. 3:24-cv-509, Doc. 45, Judge T. Kent Wetherell II, July 7, 2026, via CourtListener RECAP; accessed September 16, 2026): the order to reinstate the four states' access and its reasoning.
- Check Your Registration and Voting Status (Florida Department of State, Division of Elections; accessed September 16, 2026): where a Florida voter checks registration status.