On September 22, Council President Nick Howland introduced a bill that would let the Jacksonville Transportation Authority spend up to $30 million of its gas tax money paying off debt, with no interest, and put it back by September 30, 2037. A week later, Jacksonville Today reported that Florida's Office of Statewide Prosecution had subpoenaed JTA.
Two documents. One asks JTA for its records. The other asks your city, through its council, for a loan.
The subpoena is a demand for records, and the copy the public can read names no defendant and no charge. The loan is a vote, and it has a date. The City Council's public hearing on Ordinance 2026-0780 is October 13.
So we're going to ask the two questions this show always asks. Who gets paid first. And who waits.
The Receipt
Start with the subpoena. The copy Jacksonville Today posted, which the newsroom obtained through a public records request, is captioned "IN RE: CRIMINAL INVESTIGATION" in Duval County's circuit court, the Fourth Judicial Circuit. It's addressed to Cleveland Ferguson III as executive director. Jacksonville Today calls him JTA's interim CEO. The last page says the subpoena is issued under the circuit court's authority "at the request of the Office of Statewide Prosecution."
JTA's answer, in a statement Jacksonville Today quotes from a spokesperson, is that it "is prepared to fully cooperate."
The list is specific. The subpoena asks for:
- contracts with Dreambuilders, Jones-Worley Designs, Jacobs Project Management Company and Mason Nye Murals, plus JTA's payables to Mason Nye Murals and every email that names it;
- any request for proposals or contract for "wellness" services including massage, and the number and cost of the massages;
- the purchasing card policy and the card statements;
- the tuition reimbursement policy, and who got any scholarship or tuition reimbursement as a JTA employee or board member, and how much;
- the ridership reports JTA filed with the American Public Transport Association, including the reports for NAVI, which Jacksonville Today describes as the downtown autonomous vehicle shuttle;
- the minutes and recording of the February 7, 2025 board meeting, and the board packets.
Then the messages. It asks for texts and emails among three accounts, one of them belonging to Nathaniel Ford, the former chief executive, who Jacksonville Today reports was picked this summer to run the Dallas Area Rapid Transit system. It asks for Ford's emails from a single day, March 3, 2025. And it asks for messages between Ferguson and one JTA employee "related to scholarships and tuition." The two other people whose accounts are listed beside Ford's are private individuals, and this piece doesn't name them.
Now read the dates, because the posted copy doesn't agree with itself. Page one commands an appearance on "the 20th day of February 2026." It sets the subpoena period as October 1, 2023 through March 31, 2025, and sets production "On or before October 30, 2026." Page three says "A response is due on or before October 20, 2026." Page one carries subpoena number 2026-435-JAX. Pages two and three carry 2026-0047-JAX. And item e asks for the number and cost of massages "provided pursuant to 'c' above," when item c is a line about charges and payments and the massage request is item d.
The window moves outside the document too. Jacksonville Today reported that Ferguson told the board in a memo that investigators want documents primarily from October 1, 2023 through October 21, 2025. That runs nearly seven months past the end of the period the copy prints.
The copy doesn't explain any of that, and this piece won't guess. What it shows is that the version the public can read doesn't line up with itself in four places: the appearance date, the two due dates, the two subpoena numbers and the item e cross-reference. The subpoena as served, with any cover letter, is a public record worth asking for.
None of this says anybody did anything wrong. A subpoena is how investigators collect paper. It isn't a finding.
How the Machine Works
The loan is where the money is, so here's how it runs.
In 2021 the council passed Ordinance 2021-223-E, part of the capital program called "Jobs for Jax," and levied a five-cent and a ninth-cent local option gas tax on fuel sold from January 1, 2022 through December 31, 2051, the bill's recitals say. Under the city's 2021 interlocal agreement with JTA, JTA gets two and one-half cents of every five cents the five-cent tax collects, and one-half cent of the ninth-cent tax, by appropriation. JTA may spend that money only on the "Additional JTA Projects" listed in the agreement, which it runs as its MobilityWorks 2.0 program. Any other use needs the council's approval first, then an amendment to the agreement.
That's what 2026-0780 is. JTA has told the city that about $47 million of its share sits unspent. The First Amendment, attached to the bill as Exhibit 1, lets JTA spend up to $30 million of it on two things:
- paying off, paying down or defeasing JTA debt issued or incurred to finance or refinance transportation capital projects; and
- operational and maintenance spending "directly related to, and incurred in connection with," that debt retirement.
The council's research summary says JTA may also put the money toward eligible public transportation operations and maintenance. The amendment itself is narrower: operations and maintenance count only when they're tied to retiring the debt.
The amendment spells out what the money can't buy: "costs of workforce reduction and organizational right-sizing actions, including severance, accrued leave payout," required notice pay and outplacement. It can't go to the federal Build Grant from the U.S. Department of Transportation, and it doesn't touch the older six-cent gas tax.
The window to spend closes on the "Sunset Date," the earlier of September 30, 2027 or the day a successor agreement between the city and JTA takes effect. The $30 million is a one-time cap. New gas tax money coming in doesn't refill it, and whatever JTA hasn't spent by the sunset stays locked to the 2021 projects.
Now the loan. Section 6 says the money is "advanced as a loan to JTA on a reimbursable basis." It bears no interest. JTA restores it "from JTA operational funds not later than September 30, 2037." Then comes the sentence to read twice. JTA pays "as and when JTA is financially able to do so," and "no minimum periodic payment or interim balloon payment is required." What comes back is restricted to the 2021 projects.
The paperwork is real. At least 15 days before its first dollar goes out, JTA has to hand the council president, the Council Auditor's Office and the city's chief financial officer a written plan naming the debt it will retire, down to "the specific series and maturities." Every quarter, JTA's chief executive and chief financial officer have to certify in writing that each expenditure met the amendment's conditions, and each plan and report goes to two committees defined in the city code and to the online accountability dashboard. After the sunset, JTA reports the unpaid balance to the Council Auditor's Office by March 1 every year until it's paid back. And if JTA determines that spending the money will delay, shrink or prevent a 2021 project, it has to tell the city and come back to the council for another amendment.
Two more lines matter. In Section 4, the city "makes no representation or warranty" that these uses meet the state gas tax statute, and JTA "shall be solely responsible" for that call. And the bill reaches past the loan. Its Section 2 rewrites the city code, adding the words "to the full extent permitted by F.S. § 336.025" to the rule for how the five-cent tax is used. The bill's expiration clause, in its Section 4, is written for the First Amendment. The code change in Section 2 carries no end date of its own in the bill text.
Why It Costs You
The gas tax is a tax on fuel sold in the county, and state law says the money goes only to transportation. You pay it at the pump. The 2021 deal decided which transportation. Jacksonville Today reports that the 2021 increase was set, in part, to put $247 million toward the second phase of JTA's autonomous vehicle program and $132 million toward building the Emerald Trail.
The council's vote decides whether gas tax money set aside for the projects in the 2021 deal goes to JTA's debt first. JTA has told the city that the money available in the 2027 fiscal year still covers the projects scheduled for that year after the loan. That's JTA's assurance, and the bill writes it into its recitals. By JTA's own approximate figure, $30 million out of about $47 million leaves roughly $17 million in the fund.
Now look at who gets paid first. Action News Jax reported that the borrowed money would retire a $40 million line of credit JTA opened earlier this year. The bill's emergency section says JTA's debt "accrues interest continuously" and that each cycle of delay "results in avoidable interest carrying costs payable from public funds." Under the bill, JTA's lenders would get paid now. The gas tax fund would get paid later, with no interest, whenever JTA can.
One question sits right there. The amendment lets JTA retire only debt issued or incurred to finance or refinance transportation capital projects. Whether that $40 million line of credit is that kind of debt is exactly what the Section 9 plan has to show, series and maturities included.
And look at who's already paying. When he announced his departure on July 3, Ford said the agency was "operationally strong and well-positioned for the future," Action News Jax reported. What surprised Howland, Jacksonville Today reports, was that JTA and city leaders, two months ago, were projecting a $2 million shortfall for the 2025-26 fiscal year. After Ford left and JTA hired a new chief financial officer, the paper reports, the projection changed to nearly $31 million. In August this show went through the Council Auditor's quarterly reports and watched JTA's projected deficit grow $29.5 million in a single quarter. In September, we read JTA's plan to close a $39 million gap and what it does to a rider: weekday buses on a generally Saturday-level schedule, and the Skyway set to pause November 2. Jacksonville Today reports JTA announced a layoff of up to 194 employees.
The loan can't pay a dollar of their severance. The amendment rules that out in writing. It pays the debt.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
The case for the loan is a good one, so here it is at full strength.
The money is JTA's share already, sitting in a restricted fund. Borrowing from yourself at zero interest to kill debt that charges interest is what any careful household would do. The bill says every cycle of delay costs public money. The guardrails are real: a hard $30 million cap, a sunset, no severance, a named-debt plan before the first dollar, quarterly certifications signed by JTA's chief executive and chief financial officer, a yearly balance report until it's paid back, and a tripwire that sends JTA back to the council if it finds a 2021 project would slip. Howland has also formed a select committee on JTA's finances, with a final report due December 4, Action News Jax reported. His order of operations, as Action News Jax quoted him: "First, we need the buses to roll. Jacksonville families and businesses depend on it, then we'll look at the heads."
And the mayor's office says this isn't the city's mess to own. "It's important to remember that JTA is a state agency," Mayor Donna Deegan's office said in its statement, as Jacksonville Today quotes it.
Here's the answer.
Read the mayor's statement to the end. The next words are "Its staff is made up of state employees, the majority of its board is appointed by the governor, and its budget is reviewed and approved by the Jacksonville City Council." Jacksonville Today reports that three of the board's seven members are the mayor's picks, confirmed by the council. And the 2021 agreement says JTA can't put this money to any other use unless the council authorizes it first. The state-agency line doesn't move this vote to Tallahassee. It's on the council's calendar.
The guardrails watch how the money goes out. They're thin on how it comes back. No interest, no minimum payment, a 2037 deadline, and repayment "as and when" JTA is able, out of the operating budget of an agency that's cutting service to close a gap.
And look at the calendar. The public hearing is October 13, and the bill asks for one-cycle emergency passage instead of a regular legislative cycle. The select committee's final report is due December 4. Howland put it plainly to Jacksonville Today: "Right now, it looks like we have two investigations going on. One looking for misconduct and the other looking to do a forensic financial audit." The subpoena's production date, by either page's count, falls after the hearing too. The council is being asked to lend on a calendar that runs ahead of both.
Speed may be worth something. So are terms. A loan that pays no interest and requires no payment before 2037 is a loan the lender has decided to wait on. The lender here is the gas tax fund, and the 2021 projects are what's waiting.
What You Can Actually Do
Go to committee. Matter 2026-0780 is on four committee agendas on the city's Legistar calendar, all in the Council Chamber, 1st Floor, City Hall: Rules, Monday, October 5 at 9:00 AM; Neighborhoods, Community Services, Public Health and Safety, October 5 at 1:00 PM; Transportation, Energy & Utilities, Tuesday, October 6 at 9:00 AM; and Finance, October 6 at 1:00 PM. Agendas change, so check the page the day before.
Show up October 13. That's the council's public hearing on 2026-0780, per the bill's record.
Ask for the debt list before the vote, not after. The amendment makes JTA name the debt it will retire, series and maturities, 15 days before it spends. Ask your council member to get that list in public before voting, and to ask whether the $40 million line of credit counts as debt issued or incurred for transportation capital projects.
Ask for a payment schedule. As written, JTA isn't required to pay anything back before September 30, 2037. Ask your council member whether they'll vote for a loan with no minimum payment.
Read the two documents yourself. Exhibit 1 is seven pages; Sections 2, 6, 7 and 9 are the loan. The subpoena is three.
The So-What
A state prosecutor wants JTA's paper. The council president wants JTA's buses running first. Both of those can be true at once.
But only one of those efforts comes with your gas tax money attached, and it has a public hearing on October 13.
"JTA is a state agency" is a sentence. Ordinance 2026-0780 is a vote. And a loan with no interest, no minimum payment and a 2037 due date is a promise that somebody else will be patient. Somebody already is. They're standing at the bus stop.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- State attorney general subpoenas JTA amid transit agency's budget woes (Jacksonville Today, September 29, 2026; accessed September 30, 2026): the subpoena report, JTA's and the mayor's statements, the Ferguson memo and Howland's remarks.
- Subpoena duces tecum, In re: Criminal Investigation, OSWP No. 2026-OSP-0705 (Circuit Court of the Fourth Judicial Circuit, 3 pages, as posted by Jacksonville Today; accessed September 30, 2026): the caption, the requests, the dates and both subpoena numbers.
- Ordinance 2026-0780, matter record (City of Jacksonville Legistar, introduced September 22, 2026; accessed September 30, 2026): the introducer, the committees and the October 13 public hearing.
- Ordinance 2026-780, original bill (Jacksonville City Council, 2026; accessed September 30, 2026): the 2021 recitals, the code change, the expiration clause and the emergency request.
- First Amendment to the Interlocal Agreement for Local Option Gas Taxes, Exhibit 1 (City of Jacksonville and JTA, unexecuted 2026 form; accessed September 30, 2026): the cap, authorized uses, sunset, loan terms and reporting.
- Legislative Summary, Ordinance 2026-780 (City Council Research Division, September 24, 2026; accessed September 30, 2026): the introduction date and the summary's description of permitted uses.
- Jacksonville City Council President forms committee to probe $30M+ JTA deficit (Action News Jax, September 30, 2026; accessed September 30, 2026): the select committee, its December 4 report, the line of credit and Ford's July 3 remark.
- Rules Committee meeting, October 5, 2026 (City of Jacksonville Legistar; accessed September 30, 2026): 2026-0780 on the 9:00 AM agenda.
- Neighborhoods, Community Services, Public Health and Safety Committee meeting, October 5, 2026 (City of Jacksonville Legistar; accessed September 30, 2026): 2026-0780 on the 1:00 PM agenda.
- Transportation, Energy & Utilities Committee meeting, October 6, 2026 (City of Jacksonville Legistar; accessed September 30, 2026): 2026-0780 on the 9:00 AM agenda.
- Finance Committee meeting, October 6, 2026 (City of Jacksonville Legistar; accessed September 30, 2026): 2026-0780 on the 1:00 PM agenda.