The day after Florida voters passed Amendment 3, Jacksonville's City Council Finance Committee was asked to sign off on a $28,250,000 cash grant to a Downtown developer. It split down the middle. The council's own record for Ordinance 2026-0541 logs the Nov. 4 vote as "11/4/26 F Amend/Approve 3-3 (Defer) (Lahnen, Diamond, Gay)." Jacksonville Today reports that "with no debate Wednesday, the Jacksonville City Council's Finance Committee deadlocked 3-3 on Ordinance 2026–0541."
So the bill for an apartment tower with a Publix on the ground floor is stuck in committee, and one man, Council President Nick Howland, decides whether the full council gets to vote on it Nov. 10, the date the Daily Record reports.
This show always asks two questions. Who decided? And who pays? On this one, the first answer is about to be Howland. The second is the city's General Fund, which is to say, you.
The Receipt
Start with what the ordinance actually commits, because the title of the bill says most of it out loud.
It approves a redevelopment agreement "Among the City, the DIA & 119 Beaver St W, LLC." The bill itself says Gateway Companies, LLC "serves as the development manager and operator" of that company. Then the money, in two pieces.
A property tax refund. A 75 percent, 17-year Recaptured Enhanced Value grant "Not to Exceed $21,412,000," paid out of the Downtown Northbank CRA's trust fund, per the matter title. The Council's legislative summary says it's "payable solely from the Downtown Northbank CRA Trust Fund and not constituting a debt or obligation of the City."
A cash check. "A $28,250,000 Completion Grant to the Developer Payable by the City in 2 Installments Upon Completion of the Proj," the title reads, "to Be Appropd by Subsequent Legislation." The summary's fiscal line names the account: "payable from the General Fund, subject to subsequent appropriation."
Add the two and it's $49,662,000, by our math.
The bill was amended in committee in October, and the amendment is in the file. The Neighborhoods committee's amendment, posted to the Legistar file Oct. 9, splits the check into "$26,090,000 payable upon completion of the improvements and execution of a 10-year grocery store lease" and "$2,160,000 payable upon opening of the grocery store to the general public." It also waives the city's own Public Investment Policy, which the council set in Ordinance 2024-286-E, "to authorize Completion Grant incentives totaling $28,250,000." On Nov. 4 the Finance Committee's motion was to amend and approve. The record doesn't say what Finance's amendment would have changed.
What does the city get? The DIA's term sheet, attached to the bill as Exhibit 1, calls for a building "with a minimum of 14 floors," about 259 apartments, and "Approximately 37,000 sf of ground floor Leasable Retail Space." Of that, "Not less than 30,000 sf shall be designated for use by Publix grocery store (or other similarly well-known regional or national grocer as approved by the DIA in its sole discretion)."
That settles a number the news got sideways. Jacksonville Today's photo caption calls it a "37,000-square-foot Publix," and the Jacksonville Daily Record says "a 31,000-square-foot Publix." The documents say 37,000 is all the retail and the grocer gets at least 30,000. On height, Jacksonville Today's text says 14 stories, while its photo caption and the Daily Record say 15. The term sheet sets a floor of 14.
The developer's side of the bargain: at least $140,156,500 in private capital, per the bill, which the Daily Record rounds to "a minimum investment of nearly $140.16 million." And the cash only pays out if, at completion, there's a signed lease with Publix or another grocer the DIA approves, for at least 30,000 square feet and at least ten years, the term sheet says. One more line in it is worth a look: before any completion grant is paid, the developer has to show a "Minimum Equity Requirement of $49,662,000." That's the same figure as the two incentives added together.
One limit on all of this. The redevelopment agreement itself is "On File" with the council's Legislative Services office, the bill says, and the amendment swaps in a "Revised On File" version. Neither is posted on Legistar. We read the term sheet, not the agreement.
Who Voted How
The council's vote record for the Nov. 4 Finance item shows three ayes: Michael Boylan, Rahman Johnson and Randy White. Chair Will Lahnen, Rory Diamond and Mike Gay voted nay. Chris Miller is marked excused; the Daily Record calls it an excused absence. The matter record's history lines show Miller among the no votes twice in the Neighborhoods committee on Oct. 5.
How the Machine Works
Here's how a tie turns into one person's call. "City Council rules say a tie vote constitutes a deferral of the bill and locks the bill in committee," Jacksonville Today reports. Only an order from the council president gets it out.
"Under Council rules, the 3-3 vote means Council President Nick Howland will decide whether to allow a Council vote Nov. 10 or let the ordinance be deferred for a cycle," the Daily Record reports. In a text message, Howland "said he would decide by Nov. 6." Howland said he'd make the call at his standing agenda session with Legislative Services, held on the Thursday or Friday ahead of each council meeting. If he doesn't discharge it, the Daily Record reports, it waits at least two weeks.
The Nov. 10 date wasn't an accident. The Daily Record reports the schedule came out of an agreement between Howland and Gateway Jax CEO Bryan Moll, after Howland and Finance members said they were reluctant to vote before the Nov. 3 election. And here's the twist: Lahnen, who voted no, told the paper he supports a full council vote Nov. 10.
This committee has been sitting on the bill since summer. The Legistar history shows Finance deferring it six times, on Aug. 4, Aug. 19, Sept. 1, Sept. 15, Oct. 6 and Oct. 20, before the tie.
Why It Costs You
Lahnen's no is a budget case, and he made it with numbers. "If the Publix passes, we're back up to about $100 million in total unbudgeted cash completion grants," he told the Daily Record. "We're going to be solving for a $200 million reduction next year and $300 million the year after that."
Check his math against the record. Jacksonville Today reports about $68.1 million in unbudgeted completion grants already outstanding, citing the council auditor. Add this $28.25 million and you get $96.35 million, by our math. That's his "about $100 million."
His $200 million and $300 million are rounder than the record. The Council Auditor's handout for the Aug. 13 Finance budget hearing reports the Property Appraiser's calculation: $193 million in fiscal 2027-28 and $300 million in fiscal 2028-29 and the years after.
Now the page that should stop you. The same handout's revised five-year forecast, on page 44, already lists "Gateway N7 – Publix/Apt Building" at 28,250,000 among the city's one-time economic incentives. And the notes on that page say: "Impact of any potential future property tax referendum is not part of this analysis." So the Council Auditor's revised forecast counted this check, and it didn't count Amendment 3. Voters passed Amendment 3 on Nov. 3. The check is still on the table.
Diamond put it bluntly. "The first thing that needs to be cut in Jacksonville is every dollar people want to send to Downtown developers. It's ridiculous," he said, per Jacksonville Today, which reports he plans to file bills to eliminate Community Redevelopment Areas, where the city awards incentive dollars.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
The developer's case is real, and Moll made it with Amendment 3 itself. "Now, more than ever, commercial property tax is going to become important to the city's budget," he said, per the Daily Record. "And in my opinion, there is not any greater investment that we could make Downtown to help with commercial property tax increases than investing in our N7 project." If homeowners pay less, the argument goes, the city needs more taxable buildings, not fewer.
He also says time costs money. In October, the Daily Record reports, Moll told council members that investors in the tower were getting anxious, eager to get going before interest rates climb. "I don't think it behooves anyone to sort of be in purgatory," he said Nov. 4. Gateway has already torn down the old First Baptist Church main auditorium that stood on the lot, the paper reports.
And the deal isn't a blank check. The cash pays only at completion, with a ten-year grocery lease signed, per the term sheet. The bill adds a Public Benefit Payment: the city gets a cut of the project's cash flow above a twenty percent return on the developer's equity. Downtown residents and business owners told the committee a grocery store and pharmacy is reason enough, Jacksonville Today reports. Council member Matt Carlucci, who sat in, told members, "We can't let this derail us," per the Daily Record.
Here's where it runs out. Jacksonville Today reports Gateway "has already been awarded almost $30 million in completion grants for other components of Pearl Square." This would be another check to the same developer, voted on the same week voters passed a tax cut the Council Auditor's handout prices at $193 million in its first year. And the grocer clause still reads Publix "or other similarly well-known regional or national grocer." Publix is the name on the rendering. The bill leaves room for somebody else.
We read this bill in October, when the committee was still waiting on the election: Jacksonville Wants a Downtown Publix. The $28.25 Million Check Is Waiting on Amendment 3. The election came. The wait didn't change the check.
What You Can Actually Do
Watch for Howland's call, due by Nov. 6. He said he'd decide by then, the Daily Record reports, at the agenda meeting he holds the Thursday or Friday before council meets. The matter record updates when the bill moves. If it's discharged, the Daily Record reports, it goes to the full council Nov. 10. If not, it waits.
Find the Nov. 10 meeting before you go. As of the morning of Nov. 5, the council's Legistar calendar didn't list a Nov. 10 meeting yet. The last two regular council meetings, Oct. 13 and Oct. 27, started at 5 p.m. in the Council Chamber, 1st floor, City Hall. Check the calendar again before you plan your evening around it.
Write your council members before Nov. 10, the vote date the Daily Record reports. The city's council members page lists every member, Howland and all six who voted included. Ask three things, in writing:
- Will the council see the "Revised On File" redevelopment agreement before it votes, posted where the public can read it?
- The Council Auditor's forecast lists this $28,250,000 and leaves Amendment 3 out. What gives way in the General Fund when it comes due?
- The amendment waives the city's Public Investment Policy for this grant. Why does this deal need an exception to the city's own rule?
Read the four documents yourself. The bill, the term sheet, the amendment and the two-page summary. That's twenty-three pages, by our count. They're the deal.
The So-What
A grocery store Downtown isn't the fight. The fight is whether a city that just lost a vote on its own property tax base should promise $28,250,000 from its General Fund on a Council Auditor forecast that left the loss out.
Three council members said yes, three said no, and the tie handed the decision to one man. Whatever Howland decides by Nov. 6, the next vote belongs to the whole council. Make sure yours hears from you first.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- Ordinance 2026-0541, matter record (Jacksonville City Council, Legistar; accessed November 5, 2026): the title's grants, parties and funds, the Oct. 5 tallies and the Nov. 4 tie.
- Matter 8626 history (Jacksonville City Council, Legistar; accessed November 5, 2026): the six Finance deferrals, Aug. 4 to Oct. 20.
- Ordinance 2026-541, original bill (Office of General Counsel, introduced June 23, 2026, 7 pp.; accessed November 5, 2026): Gateway's role, the investment floor and the Public Benefit Payment.
- Exhibit 1, DIA Resolution 2025-12-02 and term sheet (Downtown Investment Authority, attached to Ord. 2026-541, 12 pp.; accessed November 5, 2026): floors, retail, the grocer lease and the equity requirement.
- NCSPHS Amendment to File No. 2026-541 (Neighborhoods committee, posted Oct. 9, 2026, 2 pp.; accessed November 5, 2026): the two installments and the policy waiver.
- Legislative Summary, Ordinance 2026-541 (City Council Research Division, analysis dated June 22, 2026, 2 pp.; accessed November 5, 2026): the trust fund, the General Fund and no appropriation.
- Meeting 1 Handout - Final (Council Auditor's Office, Finance Committee budget hearing Aug. 13, 2026, pp. 44 to 45; accessed November 5, 2026): N7 in the forecast and the $193M and $300M.
- Finance Committee votes, event item 124574 (Jacksonville City Council, Legistar, Nov. 4, 2026; accessed November 5, 2026): the roll call by name, three ayes, three nays, Miller excused.
- Events since Oct. 1, 2026 (Jacksonville City Council, Legistar calendar; accessed November 5, 2026): no Nov. 10 listing yet; Oct. 13 and Oct. 27 at 5 p.m.
- City Council Members (City of Jacksonville; accessed November 5, 2026): where to find every member.
- "Could a Downtown Publix be the first casualty of Amendment 3 in Jacksonville?" (Jacksonville Today, Mike Mendenhall, Nov. 4, 2026; accessed November 5, 2026): the tie rule, Diamond, $68.1 million and Gateway's prior grants.
- "Council committee deadlocks on incentives for Downtown tower" (Jacksonville Daily Record, Ric Anderson, Nov. 4, 2026; accessed November 5, 2026): Howland's timing, Lahnen, Moll and Carlucci.