Here is a sentence buried in a spending bill: none of that bill's money may be used to take away a tax exemption, as long as the rule doing the taking away took effect after August 22, 1978.

That sentence is Section 103 of an appropriations act, approved September 29, 1979. The exemptions it protected belonged to private schools, including, the IRS's own history says, schools built to get around desegregation. The IRS wrote the whole story down for its own staff. Here it is, in the order the agency tells it.

The Receipt

The law is Public Law 96-74, approved September 29, 1979. Section 103 reads:

"None of the funds made available pursuant to the provisions of this Act shall be used to formulate or carry out any rule, policy, procedure, guideline, regulation, standard, or measure which would cause the loss of tax-exempt status to private, religious, or church-operated schools under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954 unless in effect prior to August 22, 1978."

A second section does the same work by naming names. Section 615 blocks funding for two specific IRS proposals by their own Federal Register citations: the one published February 13, 1979, and the one published August 22, 1978. Nothing already in effect before that August date was touched. Everything the IRS was trying to write after it was defunded.

How the Machine Works

The IRS's own account, written for its tax examiners in its continuing-education materials, starts well before 1979.

Racial discrimination in public schools became illegal with the Supreme Court's 1954 decision in Brown v. Board of Education, reported at 347 U.S. 483. After that, the agency's history says, efforts began to build a workaround: private schools, so-called "segregation academies," formed to get around public-school desegregation, starting in the early and mid-1960s.

The IRS moved slowly at first. In 1965 it froze its own rulings on private schools' tax status while it studied the problem. In 1967 it decided that racially discriminatory private schools receiving state aid didn't qualify for a tax exemption.

Then came the lawsuit that forced the issue. In 1970, parents of Black children in Mississippi public schools sued to stop the IRS from granting tax exemptions, and the tax deductions that go with them, to discriminatory private schools in that state. While that case, Green v. Connally, was still pending, the IRS announced on its own that racially discriminatory private schools weren't entitled to a tax exemption anywhere, state aid or not. The court decided Green v. Connally in 1971, affirmed by the Supreme Court the same year in a one-line summary affirmance, with no opinion of its own, under the name Coit v. Green. The IRS's own history states the holding plainly: "the court held that racially discriminatory private schools are not entitled to recognition of exemption and that persons making gifts to such schools are not entitled to charitable deductions." But the court's injunction itself reached only Mississippi schools, ordering them, per the IRS's own account, "to adopt and publish a nondiscriminatory policy" and give the IRS the information to check it.

In 1976, the original plaintiffs went back to court arguing the IRS still wasn't enforcing that order, and a companion suit, Wright v. Blumenthal, argued the agency's enforcement had failed nationwide. That litigation, the IRS's own history says, is what pushed the agency to review its policies and draft a tougher procedure, the one Congress would go on to defund.

Congress folded the fix into the act it would go on to cite as the "Treasury, Postal Service, and General Government Appropriations Act, 1980." The IRS's own history credits two sponsors by name for those amendments: Rep. Ashbrook and Rep. Dornan.

Why It Costs You

A tax exemption isn't free. Every dollar a school doesn't pay is a dollar other taxpayers make up somewhere else, or a dollar the government doesn't have for anything else. That's true whether the school is teaching algebra or avoiding integration.

For one fiscal year, Congress made sure the IRS couldn't use a cent of that act's funds writing or enforcing a new rule that would strip that exemption from a private, religious or church-run school, so long as the rule doing it took effect after August 22, 1978. Not the schools the IRS had already moved against under the 1971 order. The next ones.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

The rider wasn't a blank check, and the record shows Congress knew the difference. Section 615 named two specific drafts, not every IRS rule that would ever touch a school's exemption. And the same year, a federal court in Washington dismissed the nationwide companion suit, Wright v. Blumenthal. The IRS's own history says why: "the court based its decision in part on the expression of Congressional disapproval of the policy contained in the proposed revenue procedure."

There's also a case that this was supposed to be temporary, not permanent. The same IRS history records that the House Ways and Means Committee's Oversight subcommittee was already studying private schools and racial discrimination, intending its findings to help Congress write something more lasting "than the restrictions of P.L. 96-74." The rider bought time for a different process, in that reading, not a dead end.

Here's the answer to that. Whatever the subcommittee intended, the IRS's own conclusion is blunt: "the proposed revenue procedure and the standards discussed in it are not to be utilized." The specific procedure the IRS drafted in response to that 1976 litigation was dead. A temporary rider that kills the one rule the agency had just written isn't temporary in the way that matters.

What You Can Actually Do

Read the law yourself. The IRS's own publication reprints Sections 103 and 615 of Pub. L. 96-74 in full, right alongside the agency's own account of why Congress wrote them.

Follow the citations. Brown v. Board of Education, reported at 347 U.S. 483; Green v. Connally, 330 F. Supp. 1150, affirmed per curiam as Coit v. Green, 404 U.S. 997 (a one-line summary affirmance, with no opinion of its own). All public record, all one search away. This piece cites Brown from the Court's own opinion; Green v. Connally's holding is cited only as the IRS's own history recites it, because that opinion was not retrieved for this piece.

Watch what a tax exemption actually requires. The fight over who gets to keep Section 501(c)(3) status, and on what condition, didn't end in 1979. It's one line item in a much longer federal ledger.

The So-What

A tax exemption looks like paperwork. It's a subsidy with the price tag left off. In 1979, the IRS was trying to take that subsidy away from private schools built to dodge desegregation, and Congress stopped it with two sentences in a spending bill.

That's the whole mechanism. Not a debate, not a referendum. A rider.

Come back for the rest

Appropriations riders don't announce themselves. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's receipts land in your inbox.


The Receipts

Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on the line.

  • Public Law 96-74 (93 Stat. 559; govinfo.gov, approved September 29, 1979; accessed October 10, 2026): Sections 103 and 615, and the Act's own short title and approval date.
  • IRS Exempt Organizations Continuing Professional Education Text: D. Private Schools (Internal Revenue Service; reprints Pub. L. 96-74, §§103, 615 at 1979-48 I.R.B. 19; accessed October 4, 2026): the agency's own enforcement history from Brown through the 1979 rider.
  • Brown v. Board of Education (347 U.S. 483 (1954); Library of Congress, from the Court's own opinion; accessed October 10, 2026): the 1954 ruling that made school segregation illegal, the starting point of the IRS's own timeline.
  • Green v. Connally, as the IRS's own history recounts it (Internal Revenue Service; accessed October 4, 2026): the holding and the Mississippi-only injunction, stated only as the IRS's account states them; the opinion itself was not retrieved.
  • Coit v. Green docket (CourtListener; accessed October 10, 2026): confirms it is a one-line summary affirmance with no opinion of its own.