On October 7, 2026, Florida's First District Court of Appeal ordered a Leon County grand jury report about Hope Florida wiped from the court record, all of it. The opinion in case No. 1D2026-2435 opens with the majority's limit on grand jury power: "A grand jury may investigate and report, but it may not declare conduct unlawful and then decline to charge it, and it may not condemn people by name without indicting them."

The governor wants the leakers charged. A U.S. senator says he still wants answers. You are going to hear a lot of people tell you what this ruling means, so here is what it actually says, what it rests on, and the one thing it never got near.

So we're going to ask the two questions this show always asks. Who decided this? And what did they decide?

The Receipt

The receipt is the opinion itself. Judge Neff wrote it, Judge M.K. Thomas joined it, and Judge Bilbrey concurred "in part and in result," which matters more than it sounds. More on that below.

The money it concerns. Here's the background, as the opinion tells it. In September 2024, the state settled claims that Centene Corporation overbilled Florida Medicaid. The deal came to $67,048,611. The State got $57,048,611. The other $10 million went from Centene to the Hope Florida Foundation, which the court calls a direct-support organization, as a donation. Hope Florida then gave $5 million apiece to two groups, Save Our Society From Drugs and Secure Florida's Future, and those two gave money to Keep Florida Clean, a political committee working against a proposed amendment to legalize recreational marijuana.

The report. A Leon County grand jury started looking at how the settlement money was handed out in August 2025. It returned no indictment. What it produced instead, dated January 28, 2026, was a 116-page report the court calls the Presentment. Over that day and the next, the opinion says, the State Attorney sent it out in two mass emails to at least 49 recipients.

The trip through the courts. The people the report named moved to repress and expunge it. On July 29, 2026, Leon County Circuit Judge James Lee Marsh struck roughly 112 of its 116 pages but refused to wipe the whole thing. On August 25, the appeals court issued a writ, personally served on the State Attorney, ordering him not to share the grand jury material with anyone until the court said otherwise. The next day, August 26, a news outlet based in Miami published the full report, unredacted.

The ruling. The appeals court reversed Judge Marsh's July 29 order to the extent it denied full expungement and sent the case back "with directions to expunge the Presentment in full."

How the Machine Works

Here's how it runs. The law at the center is section 905.28 of the Florida Statutes, and it is short. A grand jury report about a person that comes without an indictment is confidential, and it "shall not be made public or be published until the individual concerned has been furnished a copy thereof and given 15 days to file with the circuit court a motion to repress or expunge the report or that portion which is improper and unlawful." Filing that motion automatically stays public release until the appeals court rules on the circuit court's decision, or until the time to appeal runs out.

That's the whole machine. Charge somebody, and they get a trial. Don't charge them, and the law gives them fifteen days and a judge before the report goes public.

The court gave two reasons for wiping the report, and it said plainly that each one stands alone. The Presentment "exceeded the grand jury's authority," and its disclosure violated section 905.28, "each an independent ground for full expungement."

Ground one: the grand jury went past its power. This is the part the majority reached and Judge Bilbrey did not join. The majority held that a grand jury that says a law was broken but charges nobody is acting outside its authority, and that it may not condemn unindicted people by name. It also held, as a matter of law, that the two state settlement statutes at issue, sections 45.062(1) and 216.216, "reach only court actions and court settlements," and this matter settled before any lawsuit was filed. "The $10 million was paid to Hope Florida, not the State," the court wrote.

Ground two: the State let it out early. Every judge on the panel signed this one. The State Attorney's emails went to recipients who were not, in the statute's words, an "individual concerned." The court's own example is Rep. Alex Andrade, the complaining witness, who got a copy but was not someone the statute protects. "The violation lies in the disclosure itself," the court wrote, and since the State caused it, expungement follows. How the unredacted copy reached the press, the court said, "is therefore immaterial to our conclusion."

Why all of it, not just the roughly 112 pages already cut. The circuit court had already cut about 112 pages. The appeals court said that once the rest of the offending material came out, what remained was "a report of a wholly different tenor," which under its precedent means the whole report goes. And because the report was already public, it said, repression could no longer protect anyone. "Only expungement from the court's records remains a meaningful remedy."

The court did not rest on the State's disclosure alone, and it said why: "we do not rest on that ground alone," because a ruling on the disclosure by itself would have left the grand jury's main error unaddressed.

What It Did Not Decide

Here's what most coverage misses.

Judge Bilbrey only signed the narrow ground. His concurrence says he would order expungement "just because the Presentment was improperly disclosed in violation of section 905.28(1), Florida Statutes, without reaching the substance of the Presentment." So the only reason all three judges agreed on is a confidentiality violation by the State. The ruling about what the grand jury was allowed to say is a two-judge holding.

No trial was held. On review, the court said, an appeals court can't reverse a grand jury's fact findings, and "a reviewing court does not examine the evidence behind them." On the authority ground, the question was whether the report's statements were "improper and unlawful," a question of law, decided from the four corners of the document. The disclosure ground turned on record facts about who got the report. The grand jury looked at the money, but nobody was charged, so no trial was held and no trial jury ever weighed the evidence.

It did not bless third-party settlement payments as good policy. The majority went further than the narrow question in one footnote, and it is worth reading exactly: "While some may question the propriety of settlements with payments to third parties, the Florida Legislature has not made such action illegal." That is a statement about what Florida law currently forbids. It is not a finding that the $10 million was spent wisely, and the court did not call it one.

It did not rule on the leak. In a footnote, the court said the disclosure "may itself have violated" section 905.27, and then: "We express no view on the lawfulness of its publication by the press." That question is not decided.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

The Tampa Bay Times reported that Gov. Ron DeSantis wants criminal charges brought against whoever leaked the Hope Florida grand jury report.

And the majority opinion gives that side real material. It calls the settlement decision "a discretionary act of the executive branch." It says the grand jury pronounced "a lawful exercise of executive discretion" to be wrongdoing. And in a footnote it says flatly: "The $10 million provided to Hope Florida in the Centene settlement was never public money." If you are the governor, that is the paragraph you frame.

Here's where it runs out. The majority's "lawful" rests on its reading that this is conduct "no statute forbids." Its own footnote adds that the Legislature "has not made such action illegal." A gap in the law is not a clean bill of health. It's a gap. And the court told you who could have said so out loud: the grand jury, it wrote, could have "recommended that the Legislature address the statutory gap it identified." The same opinion says a grand jury "may report official incompetence or laxity even where no crime is charged." What it may not do is name people as wrongdoers and walk away without charging them.

U.S. Sen. Rick Scott isn't treating it as closed either. A day after the ruling, the Tampa Bay Times reported, Scott said he still wanted answers about what happened, and the paper's headline quoted him: "It’s still an issue."

What Comes Next

It isn't final yet. The opinion's own footer says it is "Not final until disposition of any timely and authorized motion under Fla. R. App. P. 9.330 or 9.331," the rules for asking the court to rehear a case.

Then it goes back to Leon County. The case returns to the circuit court with directions to expunge the Presentment "in its entirety."

The side orders are gone too. The appeals court also reversed three circuit court orders that had required the State Attorney to tell outside parties who had joined the case about any appeal. The State Attorney had once appealed the partial expungement himself, the opinion notes, but dropped that appeal after the report was published.

What You Can Actually Do

Read the opinion. It's the court's own PDF. The two grounds are summed up in the Conclusion, and Judge Bilbrey's concurrence is at the end.

Read the statute. Section 905.28 is two subsections. It takes a minute, and it's the rule for any Florida grand jury report about a person that comes without an indictment.

Ask the question the court pointed at. The majority said the Legislature has not made settlement payments to third parties illegal. If you think it should, that's a question for your state representative and senator, in writing, before the next session. The court already said who gets to close that gap.

Watch the docket. Case No. 1D2026-2435 isn't final until any rehearing motion is decided. When it goes back to Leon County, the expungement order will be the next document.

The So-What

Strip the noise off and here's what the ruling is. A grand jury in Florida can investigate, and it can report on how public offices are run. It can't put people's names on a finding of wrongdoing and then decline to charge them. And when the State hands a confidential report to people the law doesn't cover before the named people get their fifteen days, the report goes.

What the ruling isn't is a verdict on the money. The only ground all three judges signed was about who got an email too early. Whether $10 million out of a Medicaid settlement should be able to go to a foundation, then to two nonprofits that gave to a political committee, is still a question Florida law doesn't answer. The court said the Legislature never made it illegal. That's not the end of the story. That's the assignment.

Come back for the rest

We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts

Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.