Florida's Department of Health wants four vaccines off the list a school or daycare checks before it lets your kid in the door: hepatitis B, varicella (that's chickenpox), Hib and pneumococcal conjugate. On Oct. 8 the department held the public hearing on that plan at the Orlando Marriott Lake Mary. And WUSF reported that the department will keep taking written comments until Oct. 19 at 5 p.m., by email to vaccinerule@flhealth.gov.
That's the window. This is a reader's guide to using it: which four vaccines, what the law says versus what the department can drop on its own, what happened in the ballroom, and how to put your name on the record.
The Receipt
The rule is 64D-3.046 of the Florida Administrative Code, titled "Immunization Requirements: Public and Nonpublic Schools, Grades Preschool, Kindergarten Through 12, and Adult Education Classes." The department's own press release from hearing day says what it's doing in one sentence: "Under the proposal, hepatitis B, varicella, haemophilus influenzae type b (Hib) and pneumococcal conjugate vaccines would no longer be required as part of school and child care entry requirements established through Department rule."
Same release, next sentence: the shots for polio, measles, mumps, rubella, diphtheria, tetanus and pertussis, the ones written into state law, "remain in place."
And the four aren't the whole filing. Per the release, the proposal also rewrites the immunization and exemption forms and the guidelines, the rules for opting out of Florida SHOTS, how schools report compliance, and who gets access to the Florida SHOTS system.
How the Machine Works
Start with the law. Section 1003.22 of the Florida Statutes says, in subsection (3): "Immunizations shall be required for poliomyelitis, diphtheria, rubeola, rubella, pertussis, mumps, tetanus, and other communicable diseases as determined by rules of the Department of Health."
Seven diseases are named in that sentence. Rubeola is measles. Those seven stay, and per WUSF, taking any of them out would take an act of the Legislature.
The four on the table aren't named anywhere in it. They rest on the last clause, "other communicable diseases as determined by rules of the Department of Health." The Legislature handed that call to the health department, so the agency that put those four on the list by rule can take them off by rule. WUSF said it flat: "The requirements are an agency rule, not in state law, and can be repealed by the agency itself."
The same statute sets the exemptions. It says the department's rules "must include procedures for exempting a child from immunization requirements," and subsection (5) lays out who gets one: a parent who "objects in writing that the administration of immunizing agents conflicts with his or her religious tenets or practices," and a child a licensed physician certifies in writing should be permanently exempt for medical reasons, among others.
That's where the department already backed up once. When this show first read this filing in August, the proposed rule, published in the Florida Administrative Register on Aug. 24, said it would update the religious exemption form, "providing for the inclusion of moral and ethical beliefs." The hearing packet the department posted for Oct. 8 carries a Notice of Change that strikes the form's line about "a sincerely held moral or ethical belief." So the exemption stays tied to religion, the way the Legislature wrote it. WUSF reported the department dropped its attempt to expand exemptions the week before the hearing.
Here's how the department got to a ballroom in Lake Mary. WUSF reported that Gov. Ron DeSantis and Surgeon General Dr. Joseph Ladapo announced the push to repeal all vaccine mandates over a year ago. Florida Phoenix reported that the administration's proposals died in the regular session and then in a special session, and that the administration then "returned its focus to making the changes administratively." Per WUSF, a "Medical Freedom" bill to expand vaccine exemptions passed the state Senate and failed in the House.
So the part the Legislature wouldn't do, the department can't do either. The part the Legislature never wrote, the department can.
And nothing is final. The department's release says the hearing "is one step in Florida’s rulemaking process and does not constitute final adoption of the rule." Per Florida Phoenix, after a rule hearing the agency can revise the proposal to address what it heard, and any changes have to be published within 21 days. Or, Phoenix reported, "the agency can go ahead and adopt the rule." Phoenix also reported that the state's administrative procedure law lets any affected party file a rule challenge with the Division of Administrative Hearings and ask for an administrative law judge to hear it.
What Happened in Lake Mary
The hearing was noticed for 9 a.m. to noon in Grand Ballroom E, F, G and H, per the state's notice. WUSF reported that activists praised the proposal and doctors and other health professionals heavily criticized it.
Ladapo made his case to the room, as WUSF quoted him: "A public health system where parents are actively making decisions and choices about their health, about the health of their children, rather than just going along with something because they don’t feel like they have a choice, leads to a much stronger public health system."
Then he said the quiet part, per Florida Phoenix: the repeal "isn't about the scientific effectiveness of one vaccine or the other, the safety of one vaccine or the other." Public health, he said, "cannot supersede the right of a parent to make a decision about what's best for their child."
Dr. Sarah Nosal, board president of the American Academy of Family Physicians, told the department, as WUSF reported, that the four vaccines "were not selected because the evidence changed" and "are still vital to protect children’s health." Dropping them, she said, "sends a message that these vaccines are no longer important."
Dr. Brandon Chatani, the Florida Chapter vice president for the American Academy of Pediatrics, said the department hadn't given him "adequate scientific answers," WUSF reported. "I urge you to consider the children who do not have a choice in their immune status," he said.
A mother from Orange County who said she lives with long-term COVID answered the parents' rights argument head on, Florida Phoenix reported: "my rights as a parent, do not exceed the rights of other humans to exist."
WUSF also reported that supporters of the change spoke against the COVID and MMR vaccines, "repeating unfounded claims, such as that doctors make money from vaccines and that vaccines cause autism."
Why It Costs You
This show won't tell you what goes in your child's arm. That's you and your pediatrician.
What we can tell you is what a requirement is. It's the thing the school or daycare checks before your kid walks in, and the department's release says this one reaches "school and child care entry." The department's answer is that "Removing rule requirements does not prohibit parents from choosing these immunizations for their children." That's true, and it answers a different question. Nobody at the hearing was arguing about whether you're allowed to vaccinate your own kid. The argument was about the kids sitting next to yours, the ones Chatani meant when he asked the department to "consider the children who do not have a choice in their immune status."
And the cost of how it's done lands on everybody, whatever you think of these four shots. An agency a governor appoints can add a vaccine requirement to a rule, and take it back out, without a single vote in the Legislature. No roll call. No name you can look up in two years. A written comment is one way to put your own name on the record before the department decides.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
The department's case is a real one, so here it is, starting with its own words. "Parents know their children best, and they should be the ultimate decision-makers about their children’s health," Ladapo said in the release, and the changes, he said, "preserve the requirements established in Florida law." The release frames the whole proposal as an effort to "align the Department’s administrative requirements with the immunizations specifically identified in Florida statute." The Legislature never voted on these four. An unelected agency put them in. If you're uneasy about agencies making rules nobody voted on, the argument goes, you should be glad to see one hand a decision back to parents.
Here's where it runs out. The statute doesn't stop at seven. It says "and other communicable diseases as determined by rules of the Department of Health," which means the Legislature told the health department to make exactly this judgment, as a health judgment. Lining the list up with the seven named diseases isn't something the law requires. It's a choice. And the Surgeon General told the room the choice "isn't about the scientific effectiveness of one vaccine or the other, the safety of one vaccine or the other." When the state's top health officer says the science isn't the point of a health rule, the public comment is where somebody gets to answer him on the record.
What You Can Actually Do
Write it down and send it. Email vaccinerule@flhealth.gov. The department's own hearing agenda says written comments can go to that address, and WUSF reported the department will accept them until Oct. 19 at 5 p.m. That date comes from WUSF's report; the department's agenda gives the address but no date. Before you hit send, pull up the rule on flrules.org and look for any newer notice on 64D-3.046 that sets or moves the date.
Name the rule and the vaccine. Put "Rule 64D-3.046" in the subject line. Say which of the four you're writing about (hepatitis B, varicella, Hib or pneumococcal conjugate), whether you support or oppose dropping it, and why. If you're a parent, a nurse, a teacher or a daycare operator, say so. A specific comment from a specific person is harder to wave off than a form letter.
Know it's public. The state's rules site prints this line on its notice pages: "Under Florida law, E-mail addresses are public records." Assume the same goes for what you send the health department, and write accordingly.
Read the packet yourself. The hearing agenda and meeting materials include the Notice of Change and the proposed rule text. The agenda lists Thomas Bendle at VaccineRule@flhealth.gov or 850-245-4342 for the present text of the forms.
Watch for the next notice. Per Florida Phoenix, any change the department makes after the hearing has to be published within 21 days. Check the rule's page on flrules.org after Oct. 19. That's where a revised proposal, or the next step, shows up.
The So-What
Seven diseases are in the law, and only the Legislature can take them out. Four are in a rule, and the people who wrote the rule are the ones deciding whether to drop it. They held one hearing in one hotel ballroom on a Thursday morning. You don't have to drive to Lake Mary to be heard: the department's agenda takes written comments by email, and WUSF reported they're due Oct. 19 at 5 p.m. Check flrules.org, then send it.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check our work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- Agenda and Meeting Materials, Rule 64D-3.046 Hearing (Florida Department of Health, October 8, 2026; accessed October 9, 2026): the comment email, the Notice of Change, the original proposed rule summary.
- Notice of Meeting, Hearing, or Workshop, Rule 64D-3.046 (Florida Administrative Register, notice 31431412, Vol. 52/190, September 30, 2026; accessed October 9, 2026): the rule title, hearing time and place.
- Florida Department of Health Holds Public Hearing on Proposed Revisions to School Immunization Rule (Florida Department of Health, press release, October 8, 2026; accessed October 9, 2026): the four vaccines, the seven kept, Ladapo's statement.
- Section 1003.22, Florida Statutes (Florida Legislature, 2026 Florida Statutes; accessed October 9, 2026): the seven named diseases, the rulemaking clause, the exemptions.
- Activists, doctors clash over Florida's proposal to repeal four school vaccine requirements (WUSF / News Service of Florida, Ana Goñi-Lessan, October 8, 2026; accessed October 9, 2026): the Oct. 19 deadline, hearing testimony, the legislative record.
- Ladapo: Eliminating vaccine mandates isn't about science, it's about parents' rights (Florida Phoenix, Christine Sexton, October 8, 2026; accessed October 9, 2026): Ladapo's remarks, testimony, and the steps after a rule hearing.