St. Johns County commissioners are scheduled to hold a public hearing on Tuesday, October 20, on four more requests to certify farmland as an "agricultural enclave." The county's own application records put all four on that day's calendar: Adler Creek at about 594 acres, Carter Road Associates at about 201, Star IV at about 71, and Pacetti Oaks at about 40.5. By our math that's roughly 906 acres.
Here's why the date matters more than it looks. Under the law Tallahassee passed earlier this year, that hearing is the one public hearing the process requires. Once a parcel is certified, the county can't make the owner go through another one on what gets built there.
So we're going to ask the two questions this show always asks. Who took this decision away from your county? And what's left for you to say about it?
The Receipt
The law is CS/CS/CS/SB 686, now Chapter 2026-34, Laws of Florida. The Senate's bill page shows it passed the Senate 34-2 and the House 90-20, the governor approved it April 20, and it took effect July 1. The Senate bill page lists Sen. Stan McClain as its sponsor, and the House companion, CS/CS/HB 691, lists Rep. Adam Botana; that bill was laid on the table once the Senate's passed. The Florida Trib reported that McClain is an Ocala Republican and Botana a Bonita Springs Republican.
The enrolled text opens its operative section with a phrase worth reading twice: "Notwithstanding any other law or local ordinance, resolution, or regulation," an owner may apply to have land certified as an agricultural enclave. Then it starts a clock. The county must report on the application within 30 days and hold a hearing within 30 days after that. If it doesn't approve or deny within 90 days of receiving the application, the land "must be certified as an agricultural enclave." Silence is a yes.
Certification is the whole ballgame. After it, the owner can submit plans for single-family housing matching the uses and density of an adjacent parcel or development, and those homes "must be treated as a conforming use, notwithstanding the local government’s comprehensive plan, future land use designation, or zoning." Final approval of the plans "may be administrative in nature." The county can't require a process longer than 180 days, or one that includes further review in a quasi-judicial process or "public hearing."
And if the county says no, it has to put the denial in writing "with detailed findings of fact and conclusions of law," and the applicant can take it straight to circuit court. These changes expire January 1, 2028.
Why It Costs You
Read that conforming-use sentence again. The comprehensive plan, the land-use map and the zoning are the county's own rules for where houses go and how many. The statute lets a certified enclave's housing plans step around all three.
The density doesn't come from what your county planned for that land, either. It comes from the neighbors. The county's records spell out what that means for the four parcels on the October 20 list. Carter Road's statutory maximum is 13 units per acre. Star IV's is 6. Pacetti Oaks lists 5 units per acre, citing the Six-Mile Creek North Phase 1 development. Adler Creek's record says Ordinance 2021-87 limits the property to 1,682 homes.
You've seen how big this gets. The record for Heritage Development East lists a requested density of 13 units per acre. When commissioners reversed course and denied Heritage East and West on September 28, the Trib reported, it blocked about 15,000 homes on nearly 1,200 acres.
The law does ask something on that front. Its definition requires that public services, water, transportation and schools among them, be available, scheduled in the county's capital plan, available through another infrastructure provider, or covered by the applicant's proportionate share. Commission Chair Clay Murphy, a Republican, still told the Trib, "We're beginning to get very overrun with houses," and said the county needs "a break to catch up on infrastructure." And everybody in the county pays for the fight. Murphy also told the Trib the denials set the county up for lawsuits it can't afford, and that the county is "looking at potentially millions of dollars to fight each and every one of these ag enclaves." That's your county's money, paying lawyers to argue with a law your own legislators voted for.
How the Machine Works
Here's how it runs. To count as an enclave under the amended definition, land must, as of January 1, 2025, be held by one owner, in bona fide agricultural use for five years, and surrounded on at least 75 percent of its perimeter by development, or meet one of several alternative tests that count land the county has only designated for development. Most enclaves are capped at 1,280 acres, but the cap rises to 4,480 acres when the surrounding area is dense enough, and the county must have 1.75 million people or fewer. The county also can't apply rules to an enclave that are "more burdensome" than for comparable applications.
That perimeter test is where the game is played. The Trib reported that some St. Johns applicants withdrew failed bids and refiled with redrawn boundaries. One is Osceola Lakes: a 143-acre property that came back on September 14 as two filings, Osceola Lakes North at about 103 acres and Osceola Lakes South at about 40.
Two of the October 20 filings carry earlier ones on their records. Adler Creek's county record lists ENCERT 2026-03 as its parent project, and Star IV's lists ENCERT 2026-04. In July, Jacksonville Today reported a 176-acre Star Investors IV proposal, and 610 acres proposed by Windcrest Farms together with Pacetti Investment Group. The filings now on the calendar are about 71 and about 594 acres. The records don't say what changed.
The county's biggest application, ENCERT 2026-01, covers about 4,462 acres north of Nocatee Parkway. The Trib, in a story republished by WUSF, reported that commissioners denied it 3-2 on September 15, officially because the developer had altered parcel boundaries to meet the definition, and that the county plans to fight it in court.
Now watch the clock on the four in front of you. All four records list a September 1 issue date. Adler Creek's record logs the fee paid September 1, a letter to the applicant due October 1, and a hearing requirement "by 10/31/2026...tentatively schedule BCC for 10/20/2026." Carter Road's record shows the county's report emailed to the applicants October 1. By our math, 90 days from September 1 lands on November 30. If the board doesn't decide by the deadline, the law decides for it.
And it's not just St. Johns. Statewide, the Trib reported, at least 17 landowners have filed 21 enclave applications covering more than 9,400 acres in five counties, 16 of them in St. Johns. Botana told the Trib in June he expected "probably, in total, five or 10 around the whole state" by 2028. The one approval so far, the Trib reported, is a 142-acre development on North Merritt Island in Brevard County, where commissioners had turned down the rezoning in April, then had to certify the same land once the developer refiled under the enclave law.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
Supporters argued, Jacksonville Today reported, that the law helps owners of farmland that's already surrounded by development. Take that seriously. A field with subdivisions on three sides isn't much of a farm anymore, and a county commission can say no forever for reasons that have nothing to do with the land. Commissioner Christian Whitehurst made a version of that case on September 28, as Jacksonville Today reported: denying certification based on "which way the political winds happen to be blowing" instead of the evidence, he said, invites "more and more state interference." Murphy himself voted to approve the Heritage applications, the Trib reported, because he believed they met the criteria.
Here's the answer. Following the evidence is exactly what a public hearing is for, and this law keeps one hearing on whether land qualifies and writes the hearing out of everything after it. The law's own definition reaches past the hemmed-in farm, too: under its alternative tests, a parcel can qualify partly on land the county has only designated for future development, or on an interstate highway. And Botana told the Trib why he sponsored it, in his own words: "sometimes certain municipalities and counties get a little big for their britches, and they need to be either restricted or cut back." That isn't a farmer's relief bill. That's a leash.
The pushback isn't partisan, either. The man saying where growth goes is "a decision we need to make locally" is the Republican who chairs the commission.
What You Can Actually Do
Go, or plan to. The county's commission meeting calendar lists a commission meeting Tuesday, October 20, at 9 a.m. It's in the county auditorium, 500 San Sebastian View, in St. Augustine. The four enclave records list their public hearing for that date. The calendar notes that most public hearings are advertised for 9 a.m. and that the board can change its schedule, and none of the records we opened says where the enclave items fall on the day's agenda.
Check the agenda the week of. The Clerk's agendas page posts each meeting's agenda, with links to the back-up for each item and to video on GovTV. When we checked on October 6, the newest agenda posted was for that day's meeting; October 20's wasn't up yet. The calendar says questions about the agenda go to County Administration at (904) 209-0530.
Read the four applications before you go. Adler Creek, Carter Road Associates, Star IV and Pacetti Oaks. Each record lists acreage, location and the statutory maximum density.
Know that it's been done. The board approved both Heritage applications on August 19, each by a 3-2 vote, according to the Clerk's minutes. On September 28, the Trib reported, residents in the room spoke unanimously against them during public comment, and then the board reversed itself, 3-2. Neither the calendar nor the clerk's page spells out the speaking rules, so call County Administration before you go.
Know your legislators' votes. The Senate and House roll calls show Sen. Tom Leek and Reps. Kim Kendall, Sam Greco and Judson Sapp voting yes. The Trib reported that those four Republicans are the lawmakers who represent St. Johns. It also reported that Murphy is gathering signatures against the law and means to press legislators for repeal. The changes are written to expire January 1, 2028. Ask your legislators, before the next session, whether they'll let that happen.
The So-What
Tallahassee set the clock. It picked the density. It wrote the public out of the plans. What it left your county is one hearing per application, inside a 90-day window, with a lawsuit waiting on the other side of a no.
Four of those hearings are on October 20. That's the room where you still get a word in.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- CS/CS/CS/SB 686, enrolled text (Florida Legislature, 2026, Chapter 2026-34; accessed October 6, 2026): the application, 90-day clock, conforming use, no plan hearing, enclave definition and 2028 expiration.
- CS/CS/CS/SB 686: Agricultural Enclaves (The Florida Senate, bill history; accessed October 6, 2026): McClain as sponsor, the 34-2 and 90-20 votes, April 20 approval and Chapter 2026-34.
- CS/CS/HB 691: Agricultural Enclaves (The Florida Senate, House companion bill page; accessed October 6, 2026): Botana as sponsor; laid on the table when SB 686 passed.
- CS/CS/CS/SB 686, Senate roll call (The Florida Senate, third reading, February 26, 2026; accessed October 6, 2026): Leek and McClain voting yes.
- CS/CS/CS/SB 686, House roll call (Florida House of Representatives, March 11, 2026; accessed October 6, 2026): Kendall, Greco, Sapp and Botana voting yes.
- ENCERT 2026-10, Adler Creek (St. Johns County Application Submittal Management; accessed October 6, 2026): about 594 acres, Oct. 20 hearing, review dates, parent project, 1,682-unit limit.
- ENCERT 2026-11, Carter Road Associates (St. Johns County Application Submittal Management; accessed October 6, 2026): about 201 acres, Oct. 20 hearing, Oct. 1 report, 13 units per acre maximum.
- ENCERT 2026-12, Star IV (St. Johns County Application Submittal Management; accessed October 6, 2026): about 71 acres, Oct. 20 hearing, parent project, 6 units per acre maximum.
- ENCERT 2026-13, Pacetti Oaks (St. Johns County Application Submittal Management; accessed October 6, 2026): about 40.5 acres, Oct. 20 hearing, 5 units per acre maximum.
- ENCERT 2026-01, N Palm Valley Rd (St. Johns County Application Submittal Management; accessed October 6, 2026): about 4,462 acres north of Nocatee Parkway.
- ENCERT 2026-05, Heritage Development East (St. Johns County Application Submittal Management; accessed October 6, 2026): requested density of 13 units per acre and the Sept. 28 special hearing.
- ENCERT 2026-14, Osceola Lakes North (St. Johns County Application Submittal Management; accessed October 6, 2026): about 103 acres, filed Sept. 14.
- ENCERT 2026-15, Osceola Lakes South (St. Johns County Application Submittal Management; accessed October 6, 2026): about 40 acres, filed Sept. 14.
- BCC meeting calendar (St. Johns County Board of County Commissioners; accessed October 6, 2026): the Oct. 20 meeting time and place, schedule caveat and County Administration number.
- Agendas and Minutes (Clerk of Court, St. Johns County; accessed October 6, 2026): where agendas post; newest posted was Oct. 6.
- Minutes, Board of County Commissioners special meeting (St. Johns County Clerk, August 19, 2026; accessed October 6, 2026): the 3-2 approvals of ENCERT 2026-05 and 2026-06.
- “Unleashed by Florida lawmakers, landowners move to convert farms into subdivisions” (The Florida Trib via WUSF, Nicolas Rivero, October 5, 2026; accessed October 6, 2026): statewide count, St. Johns votes, Murphy and Botana quotes.
- “6,500-plus acres in St. Johns County could be developed under new state law” (Jacksonville Today, Noah Hertz, July 23, 2026; accessed October 6, 2026): supporters' argument and the July proposals.
- “St. Johns County reverses decision on developments totaling 1,000-plus acres” (Jacksonville Today, Noah Hertz, September 28, 2026; accessed October 6, 2026): the 3-2 Heritage reversal and Whitehurst's remarks.