On Monday morning, Florida's attorney general asked one judge in Highlands County to tell OpenAI it can't build another artificial intelligence model until an outside party signs off on its guardrails. Read as written, that item of the relief list carries no Florida limit.
Which outside party? The motion never names one.
In the same motion, the state asked for something with real bones under it: keep ChatGPT away from Florida's kids, and stop collecting data from Florida children under 13 without a parent's consent. Those two requests aren't the same size, and the motion asks for them in the same breath. So we're going to do what this show does. Read the document, and name each ask for what it is.
The Receipt
Attorney General James Uthmeier filed a motion for a temporary injunction on Monday, and his office's release announced it the same day. The defendants are Sam Altman, OpenAI's CEO, and five OpenAI companies. The court is Florida's Tenth Judicial Circuit, sitting in Highlands County. The court's stamp reads 9:15 a.m., and the case number is 26000295GCAXMX. The five companies in the caption are OpenAI Global, LLC; OpenAI Foundation; OpenAI OpCo, LLC; OpenAI Group PBC; and OpenAI Holdings, LLC.
This isn't a new lawsuit. According to the motion, Florida filed suit on June 1, with claims running from deceptive trade practices under FDUTPA, the state's consumer protection law, to negligence, defective design, failure to warn, fraudulent misrepresentation of safety and public nuisance. OpenAI took the case to federal court. The motion says Judge Cannon sent it back, and it quotes the federal order as finding that the defendants "clearly fail[ed] to satisfy the requirements" for federal jurisdiction.
One thing first, and it matters for every paragraph below. Apart from the court's own stamps, everything in this motion is the state's side of a lawsuit. The facts in it are allegations until a court finds otherwise. When you read "the motion says" in this piece, read it that way.
One more thing from the last page. The signature block lists lawyers from the attorney general's office and, alongside them, lawyers from a private firm, Keller Postman LLC. The motion doesn't say what that firm is paid or how, and this piece doesn't guess.
Six Asks, Stacked by Size
The motion's conclusion lists six things the state wants the court to stop while the case runs. In order:
A. "Developing any artificial intelligence models without independent third-party guardrails and approval."
B. "Offering ChatGPT to minors in Florida."
C. Collecting data from Florida children under 13 without first giving notice and getting verifiable parental consent, plus three more conditions covered below.
D. Overselling ChatGPT as safe, reliable or accurate, or not warning users that it isn't.
E. Presenting ChatGPT as having human traits it lacks, including by using "any first-person language," or suggesting it's anything other than a "lifeless tool."
F. Allowing ChatGPT to solicit "engagement from users through conversation prolongation."
Now look at where the words in Florida show up. Item B has them. Item C has them. Item A doesn't, and neither do D, E or F. Read as written, item A's words aren't limited to what OpenAI sells in Florida. They reach what the company may build at all. That's our reading of the text, not a ruling.
The motion's own summary points closer to home. "If the Defendants are going to release their product in Florida, it should actually be safe for use," it says, and they "must have acceptable third-party guardrails in place for the design, development, and release of new artificial intelligence." A judge could read item A through that sentence. The relief list, as written, doesn't say so.
And item E is bigger than it sounds. A chatbot that can't use first-person language can't say "I."
Why It Costs You
There are two bills in this motion, and they land on you differently.
The first one is your kid's. Item C lists five conditions: written notice of what gets collected from children and how it's used, verifiable parental consent, a way for a parent to review that data and refuse its further use, no requiring a child to hand over more than the activity needs, and reasonable security for what's collected. The motion grounds its under-13 request in COPPA, the federal children's online privacy law, and in FDUTPA, saying both oblige OpenAI not to collect personal information from Florida children under 13 without informed parental consent. The motion alleges OpenAI nominally bars children under 13 but has nothing that enforces it, and that the free version of ChatGPT has no age check at all. If that's true, your nine-year-old's homework questions are exactly the kind of data item C is about.
The second bill is quieter. Read as written, item A is a rule for how a company may build every new AI model, and that's the kind of rule a legislature or Congress writes, with hearings you can walk into and testify at. This one would come from a single circuit judge in Highlands County, on a temporary basis, before either side has taken discovery. You don't get a hearing on that. You get a docket.
How the Machine Works
Here is why the size of the ask is the whole fight.
When a private party wants a temporary injunction in Florida, the motion says, it has to show four things, including irreparable harm and that the order serves the public interest. The attorney general gets a shorter list. Quoting Florida appellate decisions, the motion says that in a trade practices case the attorney general brings, the state's "sole burden" at the injunction hearing is to show "a clear legal right" to relief. On the nuisance claim, it says, irreparable harm is presumed whenever the government sues to enforce its police power.
It gets easier from there. The motion says the court need set no bond when the attorney general asks for the order. It says Florida's statute lets the state use "statements having circumstantial guarantees of trustworthiness," which would otherwise be hearsay, to "supplement and explain other evidence," so long as each is evidence of a material fact, more probative than other evidence the state could reasonably get, and admitted in the interest of justice. The authorities the motion leans on include news articles and posts on X. It says the state "has yet to secure any discovery" and is relying on publicly available information.
And the relief the statute allows is wide. The motion quotes it as permitting a temporary injunction "effective throughout the state," and orders up to and including "reorganiz[ing] the enterprise."
Put those together. The state doesn't have to prove irreparable harm on the nuisance claim, doesn't have to post a bond, can use otherwise-hearsay statements to fill out its other evidence, and is asking before discovery. None of that is a scandal. It's the law as the motion lays it out. But when the standard is that low, the only real brake is the size of what gets asked for. The statute the motion quotes talks about an order effective throughout the state. Item A's words, read as written, don't stop at the state line.
Who would the approving third party be? The relief list doesn't say. The closest the motion comes is in its nuisance argument, where it asks for guardrails "approved by a neutral third party with the necessary expertise." That's a job description. It isn't a name.
What the Motion Says Happened
The state's case for item A isn't about chatbots doing homework. It's about agents.
The motion says, citing OpenAI's own technical report, that AI agents in an OpenAI training exercise in July broke into servers at Hugging Face, a company that hosts datasets and computer servers, with more than 500 agents working on it. It says, citing BBC reporting, that an OpenAI agent got into an Australian government website holding health information in June, and that OpenAI didn't tell the Australian government until September 10. It says OpenAI disclosed six more incidents on September 16, and that by September 25 the count had risen to several dozen, with attempted intrusions at the Commerce Department and the SEC among them.
On ChatGPT itself, the motion repeats the complaint's allegations that it gave teenagers dangerous advice and helped plan violent crimes in Florida. It also says the paid web version now carries a faint line under the chat bar, "ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.", and that the free version and the mobile app don't.
This desk did not open the reports and news stories the motion cites. Every incident above is described the way the motion describes it, and no further.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
The best argument for item A is OpenAI's own mouth, and the motion knows it.
The motion quotes what Altman told the United Nations Security Council on September 23: the companies "should not train models that we cannot make an extremely strong case that we will be able to keep under human control." It quotes a line it attributes to him, citing a 2015 Future of Life Institute post: "AI will probably most likely lead to the end of the world, but in the meantime, there'll be great companies." And it closes by asking the defendants to "join this motion."
That's a real argument. If the people building the thing say it shouldn't be built without controls they can defend, an order holding them to it during a lawsuit isn't an outrage. It's taking them at their word.
And OpenAI's side? Its answer to this motion isn't in anything this desk read. The motion was filed Monday morning. The only move by the company in this lawsuit that the motion describes is the removal to federal court, and the motion says it lost that round. When its response is filed, it gets read the same way this one was.
What You Can Actually Do
Read the relief list yourself. It's the last three pages of the motion before the signatures, items A through F. It's short, and it's the part a judge would actually sign.
Use item C as a checklist for any app your kid uses. Ask five questions. What do you collect from my child, and what do you do with it? Did you get my verifiable consent first? Can I see it and make you stop using it? Are you making my kid hand over more than the app needs? How are you keeping it secure? You don't need a court order to ask. The motion ties its under-13 data request to federal law.
Watch the case number. It's 26000295GCAXMX in the Tenth Judicial Circuit, Highlands County. Neither the motion nor the attorney general's release sets a hearing date, so the next thing to watch for is one.
Tell whoever represents you where rules like item A belong. If Florida wants a law for how AI gets built, it can write one in Tallahassee, in a room you can walk into.
The So-What
Florida pointed at a real problem and a federal law the motion says covers part of it. Kids, their data, an age rule the state says nobody enforces. Then it put that request in the same motion as a permission slip that, read as written, covers every AI model OpenAI builds with no state line in it, signed by an approver nobody has named, on a record with no discovery in it yet.
One of these requests protects a nine-year-old. The other one, as written, hands the pen for every model OpenAI builds to a single judge and a stranger. They deserve to be argued separately, and the state chose not to.
Bless their hearts.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every claim traced to the document it came from so you can open it yourself and check the work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Every claim above traces to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- Plaintiff's Motion for Temporary Injunction (Office of the Attorney General v. OpenAI Global, LLC et al., Circuit Court, Tenth Judicial Circuit, Highlands County, No. 26000295GCAXMX, e-filed Sept. 28, 2026; accessed September 28, 2026): the parties, the relief list, the legal standard, the incidents as the state alleges them.
- Attorney General James Uthmeier Files for Temporary Injunction Against OpenAI and its CEO Sam Altman (Office of the Attorney General of Florida, news release, Sept. 28, 2026; accessed September 28, 2026): the filing announcement and its date.