The number was 11,383. That is how many people FEMA would employ in fiscal year 2026 under the staffing plan its acting head sent to the Department of Homeland Security on December 4, 2025, a figure a federal court describes as "approximately half of prior levels."
So the court went looking for where 11,383 came from. The DHS official who told FEMA to include a 50 percent option "could not explain where the number came from." The only contemporaneous trace of the figure in the record is one line in the acting head's daily planner, written after a call with a DHS adviser: "the number is 11,383." And then the sentence this whole story turns on: "Frankly, the FEMA staffing plan number appears as if pulled from thin air."
The Receipt: One Court Order, and the Two Pages That Matter Most
The document is the order in American Federation of Government Employees v. Trump, No. 3:25-cv-03698-SI in the Northern District of California, filed September 11, 2026 and signed by U.S. District Judge Susan Illston. It grants the unions and other plaintiffs partial summary judgment on their Administrative Procedure Act claims against DHS and FEMA, sets their ultra vires claims aside without deciding them, and denies the government's cross-motion.
Under the Post-Katrina Act, the court held two acts unlawful. DHS stripped FEMA of its power to renew its CORE employees, then restored that power only briefly and on terms DHS set. And DHS ordered FEMA to hand in a staffing plan with a 50 percent cut. The court found DHS acted unlawfully by taking over FEMA's authority over its own people, and that FEMA acted unlawfully by going along.
Hold one fact in your hand before anything else: this order grants no remedy. It reinstates nobody and enjoins nothing. It orders the two sides to meet and confer on the scope of relief and, if they cannot agree, to file a joint statement on what relief is still outstanding no later than October 9, 2026.
Why It Costs You: The People Who Show Up After the Storm
FEMA's disaster workforce leans on people who are not permanent civil servants. CORE stands for the "Cadre of On-Call Response/Recovery Employees": temporary full-time staff hired for terms of two to four years who move from disaster to disaster instead of signing on for a single one. The court notes CORE staff make up nearly half of FEMA's workforce.
For years, keeping them was FEMA's call. The employee and a supervisor sent the renewal paperwork up to FEMA leadership, and DHS was not part of it. In 2025 that changed, and DHS began demanding a justification from FEMA for every CORE it wanted to keep.
On May 14, 2025, with hurricane season ahead, FEMA's then-acting head asked the DHS Secretary to give FEMA back its renewal power, and put the stakes in writing: "If terms are allowed to expire, it may impact FEMA's ability to conduct its mission during the 2025 hurricane season." DHS approved the request on May 19, 2025, but that renewal power stopped short of any CORE whose term ran past December 31, 2025.
In December, FEMA supervisors wanted 303 COREs whose terms ended in January kept on, and FEMA staff got the paperwork ready. The acting head never sent it. Starting January 1, 2026, COREs whose terms were up were not renewed, "regardless of their supervisors' recommendations." As a rule, the email arrived the day a term ended or the day before, and access to agency systems went with it.
Then it stopped, and the reason is the part to sit with. FEMA paused the non-renewals on January 22, 2026, because of winter storm warnings. The court's reading is blunt: the cuts began on January 1 "because there happened not to have been a winter storm on that date," and a storm on some other day would have meant a different set of workers out the door.
That is who pays: the surge workforce of the agency you call when the water comes up, trimmed by calendar date, with the power over who stays pulled out of FEMA's hands. FEMA's own leadership had already warned, in May 2025, what expiring terms could do in a hurricane season.
How a Number Becomes a Plan
In early December 2025 a new official took over as FEMA's acting head, the "Senior Official Performing the Duties of FEMA Administrator." On December 4, she sent DHS the plan with 11,383 in it. Where did the 50 percent come from? The evidence, the court says, shows it came from DHS. A DHS deputy chief of staff told her to include an option for a 50 percent cut. Her planner notes show several conversations about FEMA staffing with DHS officials in the days before she filed, and FEMA's chief human capital officer sat in on none of her meetings with that deputy chief of staff.
Two staffing exercises in late 2025, built from numbers FEMA's program and regional offices sent in, put the fiscal year 2026 need at 24,812 and 23,146. FEMA's chief human capital officer had advised keeping staffing where it was, and did not learn the plan carried a 50 percent cut until a month after it went in.
The planner line is the one contemporaneous mention of the figure anywhere in the record, and the record indicates the acting head sent the number first and then "worked backwards to figure out how to support it."
Keep the numbers apart, because they come from different papers. 11,383 is the fiscal year 2026 projection in the December 4, 2025 plan. 11,500 is a separate figure from a separate document: a December 17, 2025 email in which the acting head wrote that 11,500 was "what we have provided to OPM/OMB at a high level" and had not been made public. The plaintiffs' brief describes the plan as a cut "from roughly 23,000 to 11,500 employees." That 23,000 is the plaintiffs' framing, which the court quotes; it is not a number the court found.
The court also had to weigh all this with part of the record gone. It found that senior FEMA and DHS officials talked about FEMA and CORE staffing over Signal, on personal phones, with auto-delete timers the officials set themselves; that messages from mid-November 2025 through January 2026 are deleted for good; and that the destruction was intentional. So the court will presume those lost messages would have hurt the government. In a footnote to the thin-air sentence, the court says it is possible the deleted messages "would have shed light on how this number came about."
After Hurricane Katrina hit the Gulf Coast in August 2005, the White House's own lessons-learned review found the federal response plan's mission-assignment process "far too bureaucratic to support the response to a catastrophe." Congress answered with the Post-Katrina Act, Title VI of Public Law 109-295, approved October 4, 2006. The Act transferred FEMA's functions to the agency, "including all of its personnel," now 6 U.S.C. § 315. It says FEMA "shall be maintained as a distinct entity within the Department" and, as the order explains, limits the DHS Secretary's power to reorganize it. The line doing the work, 6 U.S.C. § 316(c)(1), says the Secretary "may not substantially or significantly reduce" FEMA's authorities, responsibilities, functions, or capability to perform its missions.
The court found DHS and FEMA broke that law with the two acts above. Section 120 of Public Law 119-37, the continuing resolution approved November 12, 2025, says "no federal funds may be used to" carry out a reduction in force, and it reaches positions "whether permanent, temporary, full-time, part-time, or intermittent." The court read that bar as running through at least January 30, 2026, and held it reached FEMA's COREs even though they are classed as temporary. The court found DHS and FEMA violated it through the steps they took after November 12, 2025 and on through January 2026 to halve FEMA's staff, starting with the COREs. The government's brief never answered that argument.
The court held that taking FEMA's renewal power away was arbitrary and capricious, with no reasoned decisionmaking behind it in the record. It held the January non-renewals arbitrary and capricious as well, because FEMA and DHS stopped renewing COREs by end date starting January 1, 2026, with no look at agency need or individual performance. The December 4 plan itself, which "has not been revoked, as far as the record reflects," failed the same test.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
The government's case deserves a fair hearing, and some of it landed.
DHS is allowed to oversee FEMA. The government argued the Post-Katrina Act "did not render FEMA wholly independent from DHS oversight." That is true as far as it goes: FEMA sits inside DHS. The court's answer is that the statute's text is plain on the two things at issue here, FEMA's control of its own personnel and the bar on the Secretary substantially shrinking it.
The approvals came from a presidential hiring freeze. The government traced the DHS sign-off requirement to the hiring freeze the President ordered on January 20, 2025. The court found DHS itself was exempt from that freeze, and that DHS then read "new hires" under it to cover FEMA's CORE renewals.
The acting head made the call herself. The government pointed to her deposition. The court did not credit that hindsight testimony, given the deleted messages and her shifting accounts, and at the hearing the government conceded it was not meaningfully disputing the facts.
It is over. The government argued the claims are moot: FEMA offered new appointments to the COREs let go in January, and both DHS and FEMA have new leadership. A government declaration says FEMA decided to offer 148 of those COREs new terms of six months or one year. The court's answer: FEMA's authority to renew COREs without DHS approval "has not been restored," and renewals now run six months to a year instead of the two-year terms of the past or the four-year terms FEMA had more recently offered.
The relief asked for is too big. Here the court agreed, in part. It called some of the plaintiffs' requested relief "quite broad" and said it no longer seems to fit the facts. Since January 22, FEMA has not been systematically non-renewing COREs, and the court sees no sign FEMA is otherwise acting on the December 4 plan. The order also leaves open whether a 50 percent cut would leave FEMA unable to carry out its statutory mandates, and in June the court denied the plaintiffs a preliminary injunction.
A department can oversee its agencies. For this one agency, after this one catastrophe, Congress wrote down that the Secretary may not substantially reduce it. That rule is the point of the law.
What You Can Actually Do
Read pages 28 and 29 of the order yourself. That is where the arbitrary-and-capricious findings, the thin-air sentence and the planner line sit.
Put October 9, 2026 on your calendar. That is the deadline for the joint statement on remaining relief in No. 3:25-cv-03698-SI, on the case docket, if the two sides cannot agree. The court said it would then rule on relief "forthwith." Until that ruling, nothing in this order reinstates a worker or blocks a cut.
Check the headline against the order. If you see "judge restores FEMA jobs" or "judge blocks FEMA cuts," it does not describe this document. This order finds the conduct unlawful and sends the parties to confer on relief.
Keep the numbers attached to their papers when you share this. 11,383 belongs to the December 4, 2025 plan. 11,500 belongs to a December 17, 2025 email. 23,000 belongs to the plaintiffs' brief.
Ask the people who wrote the law. Congress passed the Post-Katrina Act. Write your U.S. representative and both senators and ask, in writing, what they will do to make sure DHS follows § 316(c)(1) at FEMA. A written question gets a written answer you can keep.
The So-What
A staffing plan is supposed to be the dullest paper in government: a count of the work and the people it takes. This one carried a number that FEMA's own offices did not ask for, that the official who asked for it could not explain, and that a federal judge compared to something pulled from thin air. The workers it reached first were the ones who deploy when disaster hits, let go in the order their paperwork came due, until the weather intervened.
Congress wrote into the Post-Katrina Act that the Secretary may not substantially reduce the disaster agency. A court has now held that DHS broke that law. What happens to the workers is the next fight, and it has a date.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week: pull the order, read the pages behind the headline, and keep every number tied to the document it came from. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet cut clears the building. Subscribe to The Long Pour and the next filing in this case comes to you, read and sourced.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Everything in this piece traces to one court order and the laws and report it quotes.
- AFGE v. Trump, Order on DHS/FEMA Cross-Motions for Partial Summary Judgment (U.S. District Court, N.D. Cal., AFGE v. Trump, No. 3:25-cv-03698-SI, Dkt. 491, September 11, 2026; accessed September 13, 2026): the holding, the staffing record, and the conditional October 9 deadline.
- 6 U.S.C. § 316 (Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives, current U.S. Code; accessed September 13, 2026): the distinct-entity rule and the bar on substantially reducing FEMA.
- 6 U.S.C. § 315 (Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. House of Representatives, current U.S. Code; accessed September 13, 2026): the transfer of FEMA's functions, including all of its personnel.
- Public Law 119-37 (U.S. Congress, approved November 12, 2025; accessed September 13, 2026): Section 120's bar on funding reductions in force, temporary positions included.
- Public Law 109-295 (U.S. Congress, approved October 4, 2006; accessed September 13, 2026): the appropriations act whose Title VI is the Post-Katrina Act, and its approval date.
- Hurricane Katrina: Lessons Learned, Chapter Five (The White House, archived report page, undated in capture; accessed September 13, 2026): the finding that the mission-assignment process was far too bureaucratic.