On Oct. 2, the Treasury Department and the IRS published proposed regulations for the new federal K-12 scholarship tax credit, the one the IRS announcement says is commonly called the Education Freedom Tax Credit. The public gets until December 1, 2026, to comment. There's a public hearing on the calendar for December 15, and the notice says it will be canceled if nobody files an outline of topics by December 1.

If you read our explainer on the federal voucher credit, you already know how the credit works and what Florida spends on its own scholarships. This piece is about the rulebook. What it does, what it says and doesn't say about who a school can turn away, where Florida stands, and exactly how you put your name on the record before the window shuts.

The Receipt

The document is 91 FR 62818, a notice of proposed rulemaking under docket REG-117199-25, according to the Federal Register's record for it. It writes the working rules for 26 U.S.C. 25F, the statute that created the credit. The notice says it reaches three groups: the people who give, the states that opt in by certifying scholarship granting organizations, and the organizations themselves.

The statute caps the credit: it "shall not exceed $1,700" per taxpayer. The IRS release says married couples filing jointly could claim up to $3,400 under the proposal.

The same day's Federal Register carried a second document, temporary regulations on state elections and on certifying scholarship organizations. Those take effect December 1, the same day comments on the proposal close.

Now the projections, in the government's own words. Treasury and the IRS expect over 11 million taxpayers to give $26 billion a year to these organizations. The notice's cost-benefit table says donors will see their taxes reduced by up to $11 billion a year in the aggregate. And the IRS release says that under the proposed income rules and safe harbors, about 96% of the children in participating states would qualify.

Who Can Be Turned Away

Here is what most coverage misses. The loudest line in this rule isn't about students. It's about states.

Proposed § 1.25F-5(e)(2) says a participating state can't require scholarship organizations to operate more restrictively than the federal requirements, and the example it gives is "limiting the type of school that scholarship recipients may attend." The IRS release puts the same idea as a ban on "restrictions based on the type of school scholarship recipients may attend" or on the kinds of expenses the scholarships can cover.

Now read what the rule doesn't say. We searched the full text of the notice. The word "religious" isn't in it. Neither is "admission." Its one line on disability law says nothing in the statute or the proposed rules would change states' duties under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act.

So here's our read, and it's a read. Under this proposal, a state couldn't fence these scholarships away from a school because of what kind of school it is, and the proposed rule sets no standard for whom that school may turn away.

One separate rule, kept separate. You may have seen a different IRS proposal in September. On Sept. 3, Treasury and the IRS proposed rules that would deny tax-exempt status to private schools that discriminate based on race, color, or national or ethnic origin. That release says religious schools "may continue to select students based on genuine religious affiliation or membership" to stay consistent with existing federal law. That's a rule about a school's tax exemption. It isn't the scholarship credit rule, it isn't on this docket, and a comment on REG-117199-25 is a comment on the credit.

Where Florida Stands

The IRS participation page lists Florida among 30 states that have made an advance election for 2027, as of September 14, 2026.

An advance election isn't the finish line. Under the proposal, a state signing up for 2027 files its advance election on Form 15714 by January 1, 2027, then perfects it by sending its list of scholarship organizations by February 15, 2027. Miss that list deadline and, the notice says, no organization in the state would qualify for that year.

And if the rule is finalized as proposed, the type-of-school provision applies to Florida like every other participating state. Florida couldn't use its role in this federal credit to limit the type of school these scholarships pay for.

Why It Costs You

The credit equals the gift, up to $1,700, under 25F(a) and (b)(1). Give $1,700 to a qualifying scholarship group and you may claim $1,700 off your federal tax. That's money the Treasury doesn't collect, which is why the government's own notice counts up to $11 billion a year in reduced taxes for donors. Everyone who pays federal income tax shares a budget with that number.

How to File a Comment

This is the part with a deadline. Every step below comes from the notice itself or the regulations.gov record for it.

1. Go to the docket. On regulations.gov, the docket is titled "Federal Scholarship Tax Credit (REG-117199-25)," docket ID IRS-2026-1354. The comment form for the proposed rule is at regulations.gov/commenton/IRS-2026-1354-0001. The notice strongly encourages electronic comments through that portal and tells you to indicate IRS and REG-117199-25.

2. Beat the clock. The notice's deadline is receipt by December 1, 2026. The regulations.gov record lists the comment period ending at 04:59:59 UTC on December 2, which is 11:59 p.m. Eastern on December 1, and it shows late comments are not allowed.

3. Write it like it's public, because it is. The notice says comments can't be edited or withdrawn once submitted, and that Treasury and the IRS will publish them. Leave out anything you wouldn't put on a sign in your front yard.

4. Say something specific. Treasury and the IRS say they want comments on all aspects of the proposal. The strongest comments name the section. If you have a view on the type-of-school ban, cite § 1.25F-5(e)(2). If you think the rule should say something about which students a school can refuse, say that the notice is silent on it and say what you want it to say.

5. Paper works too, if it arrives in time. The notice gives a mailing address for paper comments: "CC:PA:01:PR (REG–117199–25), Room 5503, Internal Revenue Service, P.O. Box 7604, Ben Franklin Station, Washington, DC 20044." The deadline is when it's received, not when you mail it.

6. If you want the hearing to happen, file an outline. The hearing is set for Tuesday, December 15, at 10 a.m. Eastern, in the Internal Revenue Building auditorium in Washington, with the option to attend by phone. To speak, you must submit an outline of your topics and the time you'll spend on each by December 1, and each speaker gets 10 minutes. To testify, email publichearings@irs.gov. The notice says the subject line must carry REG-117199-25, the regulation number, plus the words "TESTIFY in Person" or "TESTIFY Telephonically," depending on how you'll testify; its sample for phone testimony is "Request to TESTIFY Telephonically at Hearing for REG-117199-25." If no outline arrives by December 1, there's no hearing. Requests to attend without testifying are due by 5 p.m. Eastern on December 10.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Here's the case for the rule at full strength. The money comes from private donors, not an appropriation. Scholarships are limited by household income. And under the statute, states choose whether to join. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said the credit "marks a new chapter in educational freedom and opportunity" and urged all 50 states to participate.

The type-of-school ban has its own defense, and the notice makes it. Treasury and the IRS say the ban answers stakeholders who warned that letting states add requirements, or drop qualifying organizations at their discretion, could lead to "arbitrary determinations and improper discrimination." That's a real worry about state officials picking winners.

Now the answer, and it starts with the math. A credit that offsets a donor's federal tax dollar for dollar, up to $1,700, means the Treasury gives up that revenue. An income limit that leaves 96% of children eligible does little to aim the money at low-income families. And look at whose discrimination the notice is guarding against. The stakeholders it cites were worried about state officials discriminating against organizations. The proposal answers that worry in detail. It says nothing about which students those organizations' schools can refuse.

What You Can Actually Do

File by December 1. Use the steps above. A short comment that names a section and says what you want changed is a real comment.

Read the section before you write. Proposed § 1.25F-5 is the state rules, including (e)(2), the type-of-school ban, and (c)(3), the advance election deadlines. The notice also points to a plain-language summary posted on the docket.

Ask your state officials what Florida will send by February 15. The proposal says Florida's advance election only counts once the state sends its list of scholarship organizations. Ask who is on it.

If you want a public hearing, make one happen. One outline filed by December 1 keeps December 15 on the calendar.

The So-What

The federal government wrote the rules for a credit it projects at $26 billion a year in donations. The rules tell Florida it can't limit what kind of school the scholarships pay for. They don't say a word about whom the school can turn away. You have until December 1 to tell them what you think of that, in writing, on the record.

Come back for the rest

We read the rule so you can check our work line by line. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's receipts land in your inbox.


The Receipts

Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.