Domestic violence killed 21 people in Duval County in 2025. The year before, it killed 19. That count comes from the 2025 Domestic Violence Fatality Review Report, which Jacksonville Today reports was presented Thursday to mark the start of Domestic Violence Awareness Month.

In July, Sheriff T. K. Waters stood in front of a District 5 crowd and told them crime fell 16 percent in 2025, News4Jax reported. Both numbers can be true at once. This piece is about the one that went the other way.

If you are in danger right now, call 911. The National Domestic Violence Hotline is free, confidential and open 24/7 at 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788. In Northeast Florida, Hubbard House runs a 24-hour hotline at (904) 354-3114 and a 24-hour textline at (904) 210-3698. If someone may be watching your phone or computer, the Hotline warns that internet use can be monitored and can't be erased completely.

The Receipt

The report is the work of Duval's Domestic Violence Fatality Review Team, convened this year for its 29th year and co-chaired by Assistant State Attorney Khary Gaynor and Stephanie Brown of Hubbard House. It names no victims and no suspects. It counts.

Here is the count. In 2025 the team reviewed 16 homicide cases tied to domestic violence, with 21 people dead. In 2024, according to last year's report, it was 14 cases and 19 deaths. That's two more cases and two more deaths.

Three of the 21 who died in 2025 were perpetrators who died in a homicide-suicide. Two of the cases, with one victim each, were ruled justifiable homicides. The report also says a domestic violence homicide happened in every one of the sheriff's patrol districts last year, which it says underscores that domestic violence happens in every neighborhood.

Where the Increase Came From

Here is what most coverage misses, and you only see it if you put the two reports side by side.

Intimate partner killings didn't drive the rise. The 2025 report puts ten of the 16 cases between intimate partners. The 2024 report put 11 of 14 there. One fewer.

The increase came from inside families. The team calls it family violence: killings between relatives who aren't partners. It counted three of those cases in 2024 and six in 2025. The 2025 report calls six the most since 2021, and says those cases killed seven people, the most in that category since 2019. In five, a grown child killed a parent. That is the most the review has recorded since it began in 1997.

So the total went up by two cases, partner cases went down by one, and family cases went up by three. The report's own numbers say the growth is in homes where a grown son or daughter kills a mother or father.

How the Machine Works

The partner cases still follow the pattern this review has documented for nearly three decades. Six of the ten in 2025 were men killing women. In the four cases where a woman did the killing, two were ruled justifiable. Since 1997, the report's own chart counts 173 intimate partner cases in which a man killed a woman and 60 in which a woman killed a man.

Guns did most of it. A firearm was the weapon in nine of the 16 cases in 2025, and in seven of the ten partner cases. Since 1997, the report says, firearms have been the weapon in 58 percent of all the domestic violence homicides the team has reviewed.

The warning signs were there in most of these cases. The report found serious lethality indicators, the history and threats that predict a killing, in 11 of the 16. In four cases the victim was planning to leave or was leaving, which the team calls one of the most dangerous times. In 11 of the 16, the two people lived together.

Then there's mental health, the team's first finding. Twelve of the 16 cases involved a suspect, a victim or both with noted mental health concerns. At least five weren't in treatment. Among those not in treatment, two pointed to cost and one to medication side effects. In one case, the report says, deputies went to the home several times in the days before the killing, and the sheriff's office had no legal standing to have the suspect committed.

Gaynor put it plainly at the presentation, as Jacksonville Today reported it. Making officers the first responder to a mental health crisis is "fraught," he said, because they "rarely have standing and often do not have tools to combat these issues."

Why It Costs You

This is the part the crime headline hides. A 16 percent drop in crime is a citywide number. The fatality review is a count of the deaths tied to violence inside families and relationships, including the people killed and three perpetrators who died in homicide-suicides. One number fell. The other rose.

When the help a family needs isn't there, the call that comes in is a patrol car. The report's own recommendation is to invest more in affordable and accessible mental healthcare, covering long-term psychiatric care as well as crisis counseling, paired with case managers who can help with transportation, community referrals and housing so people stay in treatment. It also asks for more support for people coming out of a Baker Act commitment, and for their families.

Cost showed up in the case files as a reason people weren't in treatment. That's the receipt for who pays.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Start with the sheriff. Waters didn't claim domestic violence fell. At that July town hall, News4Jax reported, he said overall crime fell 16 percent in 2025, with violent crime down 8 percent and property crime down 17 percent. Asked why the sheriff's office wants $38 million more in its budget when crime is falling, he pointed to rising costs, including pay and benefits. "Crime is down," he said. "You don't relax."

That last line is fair, and it cuts both ways. The fatality review doesn't measure the same thing as the sheriff's crime numbers, and a two-death change in a single year is a small number to build a trend on. This show isn't saying the sheriff's figures are wrong.

The report itself also refuses an easy story about mental health. The team writes that mental health challenges can raise the risk of a domestic killing, but in the vast majority of cases it isn't the cause on its own, and it doesn't completely remove a person's responsibility. The report also says plainly that when someone takes another person's life, the responsibility is the perpetrator's alone.

Here's the answer. Nobody needs the sheriff's figures to be wrong for the point to stand. A city can get safer on the streets and more dangerous at home in the same year, and the town hall version of 2025 only tells you the first half. The second half is in a PDF most people will never open.

What You Can Actually Do

Read the report. The 2025 Fatality Review Report puts its findings on pages 10 through 17. The report gives Gaynor's office as the contact for comments and questions.

Know the warning signs the team keeps finding. A history of abuse, prior strangulation, a threat of suicide, using or threatening to use a weapon, and the moment someone tries to leave. The team wants that information in the literature police, courts and advocates hand to victims.

Ask about the gun. The report urges law enforcement to ask victims whether the abuser has access to a firearm, and to consider a Risk Protection Order. If you're helping someone make a safety plan, the gun belongs in it.

Ask your city council member where the mental health money is. The report's first recommendation is affordable care that lasts longer than a crisis call. Ask who is paying for it.

Show up this month. Jacksonville Today lists the Barbara Ann Campbell Memorial Breakfast on October 21 and UNF's Take Back The Night on October 13. Volunteers planted 6,447 purple flags outside the Duval County Courthouse, one for each injunction for violence filed in Duval in 2025.

Keep the numbers close. Hubbard House, which serves Duval and Baker counties: (904) 354-3114, or text (904) 210-3698, 24 hours. The National Domestic Violence Hotline: 1-800-799-7233, or text START to 88788. In immediate danger, 911.

The So-What

The sheriff can stand in a church and say crime is down, and he can be right. The review team counted 21 people who died anyway, and five parents killed by their own grown children.

Crime fell. Twenty-one people still died.

Come back for the rest

Every figure here traces back to the report it came from, so you can open it and check my work. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's receipts land in your inbox.


The Receipts

Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.