Twelve minutes to confirm they got the request. Two years to answer it. The only thing that changed in between was what the first batch of records showed.


Here is a number that tells you everything, and it isn't the two years.

It's twelve minutes.

In October 2024, the Florida Phoenix sent Florida's Department of Juvenile Justice a public-records request. The department acknowledged it twelve minutes after it landed. Somebody was at their desk. Somebody read it. Somebody typed back that they had it.

That was the last useful thing that happened. Nearly two years later, the records still haven't come. The Phoenix reports that its follow-ups came back with "Your request is still in process" and "I have no updates at this time," and that the department has given no reason for the delay and no date it might end.

So the agency can move in twelve minutes. It just decided not to.

The part that makes the silence loud

The Phoenix had asked DJJ for the same kind of records once before, in 2024: anonymized behavior reports from inside juvenile detention. That time the department produced them in about three months.

The Phoenix had already asked for the next batch a month before the reporting on that first batch ever ran, the reporting that said the state's new education program was letting kids in juvenile detention watch pornography on state-issued laptops, and that the program was running ten million dollars over budget.

That's the request that's been "in process" for nearly two years.

I'm going to stay flat on this next part, because it's about children the state locked up and is responsible for, and there's no joke in it. The records aren't the scandal. The records are the smoke alarm. When an agency fills a request in three months and then goes dark on a nearly identical request the moment the first one embarrassed it, the delay stops being about staffing. It starts being about what page four says.

What the law promises, and what it doesn't

Florida loves to call itself the Sunshine State, and the open-records law is one of the few things about this government that genuinely earns the pride. It's in the constitution. Article I, Section 24 gives you a right to inspect the records of any state agency. Chapter 119 spells out how.

So go read what Chapter 119 actually says an agency has to do. Section 119.07(1)(a):

"Every person who has custody of a public record shall permit the record to be inspected and copied by any person desiring to do so, at any reasonable time, under reasonable conditions, and under supervision by the custodian of the public records."

At any reasonable time. And a few lines down, custodians have to "acknowledge requests to inspect or copy records promptly and respond to such requests in good faith."

Now hold that against DJJ's own public-records page, in the department's own words, telling you to include your information "so that we can respond promptly and accurately."

Promptly was twelve minutes when "prompt" cost them nothing but a receipt. "Reasonable time" and "good faith" became two years the moment the record itself had teeth. The whole scam lives in that gap. The law sets a standard (reasonable, prompt, good faith) and then sets no clock and no automatic penalty for blowing it. An agency that never wants to hand something over doesn't have to say no. Saying no is illegal. It just says "still processing," forever, and dares you to prove that's not true.

Why this is your problem, not a reporter's problem

It's easy to read this as inside baseball, a newspaper's paperwork fight with a state office.

It isn't. The public-records law is the one oversight tool in this whole state that doesn't cost you a lawyer or a lobbyist's retainer. You don't need standing, you don't need a press badge, you don't need to know anybody. You have the exact same right to those records that the Phoenix does. That's the deal Florida actually offers working people: you paid for this government, so you get to look inside it.

An agency that can run out the clock with no consequence quietly cancels that deal. And it cancels it most reliably in the exact moment you'd most want to look, when the records are ugly. The right that only works when the government has nothing to hide is not a right. It's a courtesy. And courtesy is the thing they withdraw first.

Bless their hearts down in Tallahassee, they found the one loophole in the Sunshine State: the sun still has to be let in.

The lever: § 119.12 puts the bill on their desk

You don't just have to sit in the "still in process" line.

The same Chapter 119 has teeth if you're willing to use them. Section 119.12 says that when an agency unlawfully refuses to let a record be inspected or copied, and you gave the custodian written notice of your request at least five business days before you sued, the court "shall assess and award the reasonable costs of enforcement, including reasonable attorney fees." The law hands the agency the bill. That's the part they'd rather you not know.

So here's your baby class war, and it's free to start: pick something your county or a state agency spends your money on, and file a records request. It's your right under Article I, Section 24. If they answer, good. That's the government working. If they stall you into next year, now you know something too, and you know exactly which statute puts the legal fees on their side of the table.

Twelve minutes to say they got it. Two years to say nothing. Somewhere in that gap is every record they'd rather you never read.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts

Every claim above, traced to a primary source. Access date noted with each source below.

  • "For two years, Florida Juvenile Justice department ducked records request" (Florida Phoenix, August 24, 2026; accessed August 24, 2026): the twelve-minute acknowledgment, the three-month fill in 2024, the "still in process" replies, and no reason or completion date given.
  • Fla. Const. Art. I, § 24 (Florida Legislature, Florida Constitution; accessed September 6, 2026): the constitutional right to inspect the records of any state agency that Chapter 119 implements.
  • Public Records Request page (Florida Department of Juvenile Justice; accessed August 24, 2026): the department's own stated policy, which promises no timeframe and asks requesters to help it "respond promptly and accurately."
  • Fla. Stat. § 119.07(1) (Florida Legislature, Online Sunshine; accessed August 24, 2026): the "reasonable time" and "reasonable conditions" standard and the duty to acknowledge promptly and respond in good faith, verbatim.
  • Fla. Stat. § 119.12 (Florida Legislature, Online Sunshine; accessed August 24, 2026): the fee-shift, "reasonable costs of enforcement, including reasonable attorney fees," after five business days' written notice.