Maybe somebody sent you the theory. Maybe you built it yourself, the way I did, about ninety seconds after I heard what was in the video.

It runs like this. In August 2026, Callaway Golf and a company called Good Good Golf put out a video to sell a driver. CBS News reported that the ad drew a backlash for "its depiction of a male golfer shoving a female golfer to the ground when she attempts to use his driver." People were furious, and they were right to be. And the theory says nobody at a company that size is that stupid by accident. They did it on purpose. Wreck the share price, scoop the stock up at a discount, pocket the difference.

I like that theory. It has a villain and a plan. So I did what this show does with a theory it likes. I pulled the company's filings at the Securities and Exchange Commission, to ask the two questions this show always asks. Who decided. And who got paid.

The filings do not give you the caper. They give you something duller, and I think worse.

The Receipt

Start with the ad, from the company's own mouth. In a statement posted to Callaway's Instagram account, posted in late August 2026 and signed by chief executive Chip Brewer, the company says that "Last week, Good Good Golf and Callaway posted a video to promote a co-branded driver." Then the sentence that matters: "While the video was produced by Good Good, it was approved by Callaway prior to posting. That approval should never have happened." The statement says the video "was immediately removed" once the company saw how serious it was, and that Callaway is running "both internal and external investigations."

Now the buyback. On January 5, 2026, the company, then still named Topgolf Callaway Brands, announced in a press release it filed with the SEC that its board had "authorized the Company to repurchase up to $200 million of the Company's common stock in open market or private transactions."

January 5. The statement about the video came in late August. That is more than seven months apart.

So the first leg of the theory is already in trouble. Nobody had to crash anything to get permission to buy. The permission was seven months old and sitting in a public filing.

What the company had already bought, and what it paid

Public companies have to show their work. Item 703 of the SEC's Regulation S-K requires a table in every quarterly report, month by month: shares purchased, average price paid, shares bought under the announced program, and the dollar value "that may yet be purchased."

In the first-quarter report, the company says it "repurchased 2.8 million shares of our common stock under the Repurchase Program at a weighted average price per share of $13.63, for a total cost of $37.8 million." In the second-quarter report, filed August 4, it bought another 2.9 million shares "at a weighted average price per share of $14.87, for a total cost of $42.4 million." The last row of that table leaves $119,923,033 of authority unspent on June 30.

Do the math. Two hundred million authorized, minus $119,923,033 remaining, is $80,076,967 spent under the program in six months. The company's second-quarter earnings release says it "Repurchased $84 million of common shares year to date through June 2026." The quarterly reports explain most of the gap: the tables also count shares the company withheld from employees to cover payroll taxes when stock awards vested, which are "not pursuant to the Repurchase Program."

Hold on to $13.63 and $14.87. They come back.

Now the catch, because this show doesn't sell you a clean ending

I wanted to tell you the buyback money was gone before the ad ran, so the theory is dead. The filings do not let me say that.

On June 30, about sixty percent of the authorization was still available. The program, in the company's words, "does not require the Company to acquire a specific number of shares," and the company says it "will assess market conditions, buying opportunities and other factors from time to time." Nothing in the record says Callaway bought shares after the video. Nothing in the record says it did not. The quarter that contains late August ends September 30, and the report covering it does not exist yet. Last year the company filed its third-quarter report on November 6, according to its EDGAR filing index.

Here is what I can check today. That same index shows no Form 8-K, the form for significant events, after August 4. And it lists every insider trading report, called a Form 4, filed since the video. There are five. Two were filed August 26, by officers whose restricted stock vested on the one-year anniversary of an August 26, 2025 grant; the company withheld some of those shares for taxes at $15.74 a share. Three were filed September 16, by directors who took shares "in lieu of the cash retainer" for their board service. Not one of the five reports an open-market purchase.

Earlier in August, before the video existed in public, two officers did sell. Brewer's Form 4 reports sales by family trusts on August 6, at prices from $17.55 to $18.935, and on August 7, at $18, and its footnote says the sales were made "for strategic tax planning purposes." A second officer's Form 4 reports a sale on August 6 at a weighted average of $18.7414. Those sales came two days after the earnings report and before the ad. They tell you nothing about the ad, and I am not going to pretend they do. They were sales, not purchases, and the theory needs purchases.

One more number. That $15.74 is a tax-withholding price on a stock vesting, not a price the company paid to buy back shares. It is still the only post-ad price in the filings, so set it next to the company's own averages, $13.63 and $14.87. The theory says the ad was a trick to buy cheap. The only post-ad price in the filings is higher than the average the company paid in either quarter.

How the Machine Works

Here is what the rules say. I am describing the law. I am not a lawyer, and nothing here is a conclusion about anybody's conduct.

The Securities Exchange Act, at Section 9(a)(2), makes it unlawful to effect "a series of transactions" in a security "raising or depressing the price of such security, for the purpose of inducing the purchase or sale of such security by others." Rule 10b-5 makes it unlawful "To employ any device, scheme, or artifice to defraud" in connection with buying or selling a security.

A company buying its own shares pushes on its own price, so in 1982 the SEC wrote buybacks a safe harbor. The agency's 2003 release updating the rule tells the history in one line: "In 1982, the Commission adopted Rule 10b-18." The rule shields a company from manipulation liability "solely by reason of the manner, timing, price, and volume" of its purchases if it meets four conditions every day: one broker, limits on time of day, a price ceiling pegged to the best independent bid or the most recent independent trade, and a daily volume cap of 25 percent of the stock's average daily trading. Callaway's filings say its purchases "will be made in compliance with Rule 10b-18."

Read the limits. The rule's own text says the safe harbor "is not available for repurchases that, although made in technical compliance with the section, are part of a plan or scheme to evade the federal securities laws." And the 2003 release quotes the SEC from 1982: the rule "confers no immunity from possible Rule 10b-5 liability where the issuer engages in repurchases while in possession of favorable, material nonpublic information concerning its securities."

Then there is Rule 10b5-1. A trade is "on the basis of" inside information if the person "was aware of the material nonpublic information" when trading. Insiders can defend a trade made under a written plan adopted beforehand, and for an officer or director that plan carries a cooling-off period of at least ninety days. Callaway's second-quarter report says that in those three months "none of our officers or directors adopted or terminated" such a plan.

So the scheme the theory imagines is the subject those provisions are written about. Whether anybody broke them is not something a filing can tell you, and this piece makes no such claim about anyone.

Why It Costs You

Here is the turn. You do not need the caper.

The same January press release that announced the buyback announced two other things alongside it. It does not say one paid for the other; it puts them in one document. Callaway sold "a 60% stake in its Topgolf and Toptracer businesses" to "private equity funds managed by Leonard Green & Partners," and "received approximately $800 million in cash proceeds." It repaid $1 billion of debt. And the board approved $200 million for repurchases. Brewer, in that release, said the moves were "reinforcing our commitment to delivering long-term value for our shareholders."

What follows is this show's analysis, labeled as mine. A buyback takes cash out of the company and hands it to whoever sells their shares. Every share left is a slightly bigger slice of the same company; the second-quarter report counts 178,510,521 shares outstanding on August 3. That same report says cash fell $625.1 million in six months, mostly to pay off debt, and that the company "also used cash in financing activities to repurchase shares." Eighty million dollars went out the door to buy stock. It did not go to a paycheck or a lower price on a driver.

Now who is paid in that stock. The company's 2026 proxy statement says about 70 percent of the chief executive's targeted pay in 2025 "was provided in the form of long-term equity compensation." It has a bullet headed "PRSUs Based Solely on relative Total Shareholder Return." Performance shares, in other words, that vest according to how the stock does against other companies' stock.

Since 2022, the tax code imposes "a tax equal to 1 percent of the fair market value of any stock of the corporation which is repurchased." One percent is the price we put on it.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Two other sides here, and both deserve full strength.

The theory's best case: about $119.9 million of buying power was live when the video went up, the program has no schedule, and nobody outside will see the third quarter's purchases until the report lands. All true. But buying when the price is down is what a standing program is for, and the company announced this one in January. For the theory to work, the ad has to be deliberate. The only evidence on that point is a company pulling the video, apologizing under its chief executive's name, and announcing investigations. That reads like a mistake getting cleaned up. It does not read like a plan.

The buyback's best case: the cash came from a sale, the debt got paid first, and handing extra money back to owners beats letting executives sit on it. Pay tied to shareholder return is supposed to make bosses care about owners. And it does not always pay: the proxy says the 2023 to 2025 performance shares fell "slightly below threshold, resulting in no payout." Fair, and it cuts my way too. When pay rides on the stock's return, the people deciding how to spend $200 million have a personal stake in the option that supports the stock.

What You Can Actually Do

Read the table yourself. Any public company's quarterly report has it, in Part II, Item 2. It takes five minutes at sec.gov, and it is the same habit this show used on where your political donations actually go.

Then mark your calendar. Last year's third-quarter report came November 6. When this year's arrives, read the rows for July, August and September: shares, average price, dollars remaining. If the company bought after the video, that is where it will be written down, with the price. Check Form 4s the same way. Code P is an open-market purchase, S is a sale, F is shares withheld for taxes.

And when you meet the next theory like this one, ask for the date of the authorization first.

The So-What

You wanted a heist. I did too. A heist has a villain you can indict.

What the filings hold instead is a private equity sale, a debt payoff, and $80 million spent on the company's own shares while the people in charge are paid largely in shares. All of it disclosed, in documents anybody can open. The ad was a mistake, by the company's own account. The buyback was a decision the board announced. That is not a scandal hiding behind the ad. That is the business model, in plain sight, while everybody looks at the ad.

Come back for the rest

We do this every week: the story everybody is passing around on top, the filing underneath it, and every number walked back to the page it came off of. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet transfer clears the quarterly report. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's small thefts and the one big one land in your inbox together.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts

Every filing, rule and statement below was opened and saved on September 20, 2026.

  • Form 10-Q for the quarter ended June 30, 2026 (Callaway Golf Co., filed August 4, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): second-quarter repurchases, remaining authority, share count, cash and the 10b5-1 item.
  • Form 10-Q for the quarter ended March 31, 2026 (Callaway Golf Co., filed May 8, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): first-quarter repurchases, average price and remaining authority.
  • Press release, Exhibit 99.1 to Form 8-K (Topgolf Callaway Brands Corp., dated January 5, 2026, filed January 7, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the $200 million authorization, the Topgolf sale, the debt repayment and Chip Brewer's quotation.
  • Second-quarter 2026 earnings release, Exhibit 99.1 to Form 8-K (Callaway Golf Co., filed August 4, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the company's "$84 million" year-to-date repurchase figure.
  • Definitive proxy statement, Schedule 14A (Callaway Golf Co., filed April 8, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the executive pay mix, the shareholder-return performance shares and the 2023 to 2025 zero payout.
  • EDGAR filing index, CIK 0000837465 (SEC, submissions record; accessed September 20, 2026): every filing and its date, including the Form 4s, the last Form 8-K and last year's third-quarter report.
  • Form 4, President and CEO (Chip Brewer, filed August 10, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the August 6 and 7 family-trust sales, the August 6 price range and the stated purpose.
  • Form 4, executive vice president (Callaway Golf Co. officer, filed August 10, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the second officer's August 6 sale and its weighted average price.
  • Form 4, executive vice president, restricted stock vesting (Callaway Golf Co. officer, filed August 26, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the August 26 vesting and the $15.74 tax withholding price.
  • A Message From Our CEO (Callaway Golf, Instagram post signed by Chip Brewer, late August 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the company's account of the video, its approval, its removal and the investigations.
  • Callaway Golf CEO apologizes after Good Good ad showing male golfer shoving woman sparks backlash (CBS News, updated August 28, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): attributed reporting on what the removed video showed.
  • 17 CFR 240.10b-18 (SEC, eCFR, current as of September 1, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the buyback safe harbor, its four conditions and its scheme limit.
  • 17 CFR 240.10b-5 (SEC, eCFR, current as of September 1, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the antifraud rule's text.
  • 17 CFR 240.10b5-1 (SEC, eCFR, current as of September 1, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the awareness standard, the written-plan defense and the ninety-day cooling-off period.
  • 17 CFR 229.703 (SEC, Regulation S-K Item 703, eCFR, current as of September 1, 2026; accessed September 20, 2026): the required monthly repurchase table.
  • 15 U.S.C. 78i (Securities Exchange Act of 1934, Section 9, Office of the Law Revision Counsel; accessed September 20, 2026): the anti-manipulation text of Section 9(a)(2).
  • 26 U.S.C. 4501 (Internal Revenue Code, added by Pub. L. 117-169, August 16, 2022, Office of the Law Revision Counsel; accessed September 20, 2026): the 1 percent tax on repurchased stock.
  • Purchases of Certain Equity Securities by the Issuer and Others (SEC, Release No. 33-8335, November 10, 2003; accessed September 20, 2026): the 1982 adoption of Rule 10b-18 and the SEC's inside-information caveat.