Two federal courts read the wildlife paperwork behind Florida's wetlands permitting program and threw it out. Now five members of Florida's congressional delegation want Congress to declare that same paperwork good enough, by law.
The bill is H.R. 9017, the "Restore Florida Water Independence Act," introduced May 22, 2026. It runs three pages. Rep. Byron Donalds sponsors it, and Reps. Brian Mast, Jared Moskowitz, Mike Haridopolos and Vern Buchanan cosponsor it: four Republicans and one Democrat. It went to the House Transportation and Infrastructure and Natural Resources committees, the bill itself shows.
So we're going to ask the two questions this show always asks. Who decided the rules were too slow to follow. And who pays when Congress agrees.
The Receipt
Read Section 2. It's the whole working part of the bill.
It names one agency action: EPA's approval of Florida's request to run the federal dredge-and-fill permit program that Clean Water Act Section 404 sets up, as described in a December 22, 2020 Federal Register notice. And it names one document: the biological opinion the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service issued on November 17, 2020, including the incidental take statement on pages 69 through 73.
Then it does the thing. For that approval, the bill says, the opinion is deemed compliant with the Endangered Species Act, and its long title puts the goal plainly: "compliance with a certain biological opinion is deemed to be compliance with the requirements of" the act. It adds that "no additional consultation" is required.
That's it. The bill doesn't tell the Fish and Wildlife Service to fix the opinion the courts rejected. It doesn't order a single new species review. It takes the opinion as written and declares it good, by legislative command rather than agency correction.
What that's for, the sponsor says himself. His May 27 release says the bill would restore the state's permit authority "by codifying the biological opinion," to set up "an expedited, state-run system."
How the Machine Works
Here's how it runs.
Under the Clean Water Act, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers issues the federal permits to dredge and fill wetlands. A state can ask EPA to take that job over. Florida asked on August 20, 2020. EPA said yes in December 2020, and as U.S. District Judge Randolph Moss wrote, it had done that only twice before: Michigan in 1984 and New Jersey in 1994. Florida was the third.
Florida didn't just want the paperwork. Moss wrote that Florida "proposed something novel." Under a state-run program, Moss explained, a developer who can't avoid harming a listed species has to get its own federal take permit, or EPA can pull the application up to the federal level, which triggers consultation. Florida called those paths "burdensome," "time consuming[,] and resource-intensive," the opinion records. So the state proposed one consultation up front, at the approval, to give "broad ESA liability protection on all future state permittees."
That one consultation produced the November 2020 biological opinion. Environmental groups led by the Center for Biological Diversity sued: the Sierra Club, Defenders of Wildlife, Miami Waterkeeper, St. Johns Riverkeeper, Florida Wildlife Federation and the Conservancy of Southwest Florida alongside it.
On February 15, 2024, Moss ordered that the service's biological opinion and its take statement "are VACATED," and he threw out EPA's approval of the Florida program with them. Unless a limited stay issued, the order said, "all Section 404 permitting authority in the State of Florida is vested in the Army Corps of Engineers." He found that the service's opinion and take statement "fail to satisfy the" requirements of the Endangered Species Act. And he wrote one sentence worth carrying around: "of the over one hundred protected species in Florida, the BiOp names just a handful and, even for those, offers little analysis."
The D.C. Circuit affirmed on March 27, 2026. Judge Pan's opinion for the court opens with a trucking company owner who promises to inspect his own trucks, and a vehicle inspector who signs off on the promise. The problem, she wrote, is that the inspector "no longer has any obligation to make sure that the trucks are safe." The court said the service "abdicated its responsibility to enforce" the Endangered Species Act, and that it and EPA let Florida and its permittees "evade the ESA's exacting procedures for protecting listed species." It also held that EPA erred by skipping a required formal consultation with the National Marine Fisheries Service. The backers haven't stopped. Bonnie Malloy, a senior attorney at Earthjustice, told Florida Phoenix there have been "five attempts so far." By Florida Phoenix's account, some tried to slip the program's language into the federal budget, and when a stand-alone bill went nowhere, the language moved into a bill rewriting the Endangered Species Act, which House leaders pulled. That last part, Phoenix says, comes from Casey Darling Kniffin, who tracks the effort for Friends of the Everglades. H.R. 9017 is the latest.
Why It Costs You
The thing this bill waves through is a no-jeopardy finding for an entire state permit program. A judge read that finding and said it named "just a handful" of more than a hundred.
These aren't abstractions. When two of the groups asked Moss to block state permits for two developments, they said the projects threatened the Florida panther, which is critically endangered, and the crested caracara, a threatened bird of prey. That's the kind of permit this program issues.
The cost lands on everybody who isn't at the permit counter. The Endangered Species Act's consultation is the federal backstop, the step where somebody whose job is the species gets to look at the project. Pass this bill and, for the program it covers, the backstop is a 2020 document two courts found wanting, frozen into law.
Amber Crooks, who works for the Conservancy of Southwest Florida, one of the groups that sued, put it to the House subcommittee in fewer words, as Florida Phoenix reported: a program "with no guardrails or backstops," and "essentially a free pass for development."
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
Here's the case for the bill, in its backers' own words.
"In 2024, the D.C. District Court stripped Florida of its efficient and robust Section 404 permitting authority, creating unnecessary bureaucratic delays," Donalds said in his release. Florida went after the program to cut redundant oversight, the release says, because roughly 85 percent of what the state and federal reviews required was the same. Applicants now have to go through the Corps, it says. Florida Coastal Conservation Association and Bonefish & Tarpon Trust endorsed the bill, the release says, and it's bipartisan: Moskowitz is a Democrat.
At the hearing, Florida Phoenix reported, Donalds testified that the rulings involved "procedural paperwork, not an environmental failure," and that restoring the program would cut "unnecessary red tape imposed by Washington." A Fish and Wildlife Service official told the subcommittee the agency is working "in alignment with the administration's priorities" to reduce environmental review.
The defense in court wasn't nothing, either. The federal agencies themselves, EPA, the wildlife service and the Corps, appealed alongside Florida and defended the opinion. In their view, as Moss described it, the species-specific analysis for a whole state program would have been too difficult to do up front, and a "technical assistance process" would handle it permit by permit. And the appeals panel wasn't unanimous on everything: Judge Henderson concurred in part and dissented in part.
That's the strongest version. Here's the answer.
Both courts heard that argument. Moss was "unpersuaded that the non-statutory technical assistance process is a lawful substitute" for what Congress wrote into the act. The D.C. Circuit said the wildlife service, by handing that job to Florida, abdicated its own. "Procedural paperwork" is the sponsor's phrase for the species analysis itself, and the procedure is the protection: it's how the act finds out whether a permit will harm a panther before it's issued. Calling it paperwork doesn't make the analysis exist. This bill doesn't make it exist either. It just says nobody has to do it.
What You Can Actually Do
Read the bill. H.R. 9017 is three pages, and Section 2 is the whole operative text. Read it before anyone tells you what it does, including us.
Read the first two pages of the appeals opinion. The D.C. Circuit's trucking analogy is the clearest explanation anyone has written of what went wrong.
Ask your representative where they stand. The bill was referred to the House Transportation and Infrastructure Committee and the Natural Resources Committee. This piece reports nothing past the September subcommittee hearing, so check the bill's status yourself before you call, and ask the specific question: should Congress deem a biological opinion compliant after two federal courts found it wasn't?
The So-What
Florida asked to skip the step where somebody checks on the panther. Two courts said no. Five members of Congress now want to pass a law saying the step already happened.
That's not streamlining a permit. That's rewriting the verdict.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- “H.R. 9017, Restore Florida Water Independence Act of 2026” (U.S. House, 119th Congress, introduced May 22, 2026, 3 pages; accessed October 2, 2026): sponsors, committee referral and the Section 2 deeming language.
- “Donalds Introduces the Restore Florida Water Independence Act” (Office of Rep. Byron Donalds, press release, May 27, 2026; accessed October 2, 2026): the sponsor's case, the 85 percent figure and the endorsements.
- Center for Biological Diversity v. Regan, Memorandum Opinion (U.S. District Court for D.C., No. 21-119 (RDM), Judge Moss, February 2024; accessed October 2, 2026): the novel proposal, the handful of species and the holding.
- Order, Center for Biological Diversity v. Regan, Dkt. 164 (U.S. District Court for D.C., No. 21-119 (RDM), signed February 15, 2024, via CourtListener RECAP; accessed October 2, 2026): vacatur, and permitting authority vested in the Army Corps.
- Center for Biological Diversity v. Zeldin (U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit, No. 24-5101, decided March 27, 2026; accessed October 2, 2026): affirmance, the trucking analogy and the abdication finding.
- “Congress tries end-run around Florida court decision protecting wetlands” (Florida Phoenix, commentary by Craig Pittman, October 1, 2026; accessed October 2, 2026): the hearing, witness quotes and the count of past attempts.