Florida Policy Institute counts 14 Florida counties with a dedicated program taxing themselves, on purpose, to fund children's programs: summer camps, early learning, wellness screenings, kids kept out of juvenile detention. Thirteen of those run a dedicated taxing council for children's services (most, though not all, created by referendum); a new report from the Florida Policy Institute says Amendment 3's property-tax cuts would take almost $278 million away from those 13 councils over two years. Jacksonville is the report's 14th: its version of that agency, Kids Hope Alliance, doesn't tax itself the same way, and it isn't in the dollar estimate at all. The report can't tell you what Jacksonville stands to lose: its own footnote says Kids Hope Alliance was left out because it "was not created in statute or ordinance and is part of the Jacksonville Mayor's Office." That's the reason the report gives. Its body text, on the same page, describes Kids Hope Alliance differently.

The Receipt

Florida Policy Institute, a research and advocacy nonprofit, published the analysis on Sept. 10 and updated it the next day. Its math: if Amendment 3 passes, Children's Services Councils and Trusts, the local taxing districts that FPI counts in 14 Florida counties, lose $100 million in the first full fiscal year, FY 2027-28, and almost $278.1 million over FY 2027-28 and FY 2028-29 combined. That's 15 percent of what those councils are projected to bring in over those same two years.

Those 14 counties hold more than half of Florida's children. Statewide, the councils bring in more than $900 million a year, primarily from property taxes outside the school levy. Run it three years without Amendment 3 and that revenue tops $1.8 billion. The report puts the cost to the taxpayer funding it at $25 to $80 a year, depending on your county and your property's value.

How the Machine Works

Children's Services Councils aren't a state program. Each of the 13 counties created its own, mostly by referendum, one at a time, going back to 1945, when Pinellas County's Juvenile Welfare Board became the first in the nation. Miami-Dade's Children's Trust loses the most in dollar terms, $60.4 million over the two years, on a council that put $234.5 million into programs serving "nearly 200,000 children, youth, parents, and professionals" last year. Palm Beach loses $49.7 million; Broward loses $47.8 million; the Pinellas board that started it all loses $46 million; Hillsborough's Children's Board loses $33.9 million. Every council's tax rate is capped by a maximum millage set in statute or by the local ordinance that created it; when Amendment 3 shrinks the tax base under that cap, the cap itself doesn't move to make up the difference.

Part of what that money buys: $30 million a year in state and federal child-care funds that the councils draw down by putting up local match dollars first. Cut the local match and you don't just lose the local dollar. You lose the federal and state dollars that were coming with it.

Why It Costs You

Jacksonville doesn't have a Children's Services Council. It has Kids Hope Alliance, and the report lists its loss as "Not available." Not zero: unavailable. KHA ran on more than $57 million in FY 2025-26: $26.3 million for out-of-school programs, $9.2 million for kids with disabilities, $6.8 million for early learning, $3.1 million for juvenile-justice prevention, $1.4 million for teens. That money served nearly 500,000 meals, kept afterschool programming running for 7,657 kids, funded summer camp for 5,625, and diverted 1,008 kids out of the juvenile justice system last year alone.

The report can't model what Amendment 3 does to that budget. Here's why that matters to you if you live in Duval County: the same report that can't estimate KHA's loss also can't agree on what KHA legally is. In the body of the report, Kids Hope Alliance "was enacted by the city council" in 2017. In the report's own footnote on that same page, Kids Hope Alliance "was not created in statute or ordinance and is part of the Jacksonville Mayor's Office." Those two sentences describe two different cities. One has an agency the City Council created by ordinance. The other has a program that sits inside the Mayor's Office with no ordinance behind it. This show isn't going to pick a side the report itself won't pick. We traced it as far as the public record would let us in the time we had, and we're saying so instead of guessing: which one is true is a real legal question for Jacksonville, and the answer needs its own article, not a parenthetical in somebody else's.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Amendment 3's backers aren't arguing children's programs don't matter. The ballot language the Legislature itself adopted frames the trade as protecting homeowners while "Ensuring funding for core services," meaning public safety, education and schools, infrastructure, and natural resources, the same uses the amendment's own spending-restriction clause lists for counties and cities. And the report's own numbers show these councils aren't starving today: Miami-Dade alone put nearly a quarter-billion dollars into children's programs last year. A county funding at that level has more room to absorb a cut than a household facing the same percentage loss in take-home pay.

The report also doesn't model any offset: a new state appropriation, a shifted local priority, anything that might replace some of what's lost. It measures what Amendment 3 removes from the current structure, not what happens next. That's a real gap. The report's own words give away its posture: "Floridians cannot afford property tax reductions and elimination and the steep service reductions that will result." It's making the case against the amendment, not forecasting what happens next.

What You Can Actually Do

Find your county's council. If you live in Alachua, Broward, Escambia, Hillsborough, Indian River, Leon, Manatee, Martin, Miami-Dade, Okeechobee, Palm Beach, Pinellas, or St. Lucie, you already fund one of these. Look up what it buys before you decide what losing 15 percent of it costs your kid's afterschool program.

If you're in Duval, ask the follow-up question. Was Kids Hope Alliance created by ordinance or not? Ask your City Council member. The report's own body text and its own footnote give two different answers, on the same page.

Read the report yourself. It names every council and every dollar amount by county, table and all.

The So-What

Thirteen counties built something worth protecting: a dedicated tax, most of them voter-approved, that keeps kids fed, in school, and out of the system. Amendment 3's enrolled text doesn't name children's services once, and the seven uses it lists for counties and cities to keep taxing for don't include it either. It just shrinks the tax base those councils depend on, and leaves the math to whoever's left holding the budget. Jacksonville's math is worse than any of theirs: nobody can even tell you the number, because the report excludes Kids Hope Alliance by its own footnote's reasoning, then contradicts that reasoning in its own body text.

Come back for the rest

Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's receipts land in your inbox.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts

Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.

  • Local Services for Florida Children and Parents Would See Deep Funding Cuts Under Amendment 3 (Florida Policy Institute, by Norín Dollard, PhD, published Sept. 10, 2026, updated Sept. 11, 2026; accessed September 16, 2026): every dollar figure, county list, and the Kids Hope Alliance passage, including its self-contradicting footnote.
  • CS/HJR 1F, Enrolled (Florida Legislature, 2026F Special Session, signed and filed with the Secretary of State June 16, 2026; accessed October 10, 2026): the full enrolled text of Amendment 3, including the spending-restriction list of what counties and cities can still tax for.