About 4 feet 3 inches on each side, and 7 feet 9 inches tall. That is the size facility staff at Alligator Alcatraz gave federal inspectors for its small metal enclosures. From July 17, 2025, through January 18, 2026, the facility put 79 detainees inside them.
The Department of Homeland Security's Office of Inspector General has issued OIG-26-22, dated September 11, 2026, its unannounced inspection of Alligator Alcatraz, formally the Florida Soft-Sided Facility, in Ochopee. The report puts each enclosure at about 18 square feet of floor space, and says using them "for any reason is unprecedented among detention facilities OIG has inspected."
The facility is closed. It ceased operations on June 15, 2026, and for that reason the inspector general administratively closed all 10 of its recommendations. So this is not a story about a place still running. It is a story about what the record shows and who answers for it, because the inspector general and the department's own response do not give the same answer.
The Receipt: 79 Detainees, About 18 Square Feet, Up to Nearly 2 Hours
Inspectors arrived on January 21, 2026, for what the report calls "a limited-scope inspection of FSSF in one day." The report finds the facility met two standards, intake and use of force, and failed six: recreation, food service, personal hygiene, medical care, special management units, and environmental health and safety.
The finding the report singles out is on PDF page 14. In the period from July 17, 2025, through January 18, 2026, "FSSF confined 79 detainees in small metal enclosures — each offering about 18 square feet of floor space — for periods ranging from several minutes to nearly 2 hours."
The report puts the average time at 59 minutes and 27 seconds, and says facility records show no detainee was held longer than the facility's 2-hour policy. The posted policy, which the report reprints, says a detainee "may leave at any time."
Staff gave inspectors their account. They described the enclosures as "calming areas," said detainees asked to spend time in them, and said detainees are not locked in, even though the inspectors observed locking mechanisms on the enclosures.
ICE officials gave the inspectors a different list. They reported that the enclosures "were used for disciplinary issues, crisis intervention, housing changes, and conflicts among detainees," and that every detainee was put in hand restraints for the walk to an enclosure, but not while inside it.
The inspectors found at least one instance in which an enclosure may have been used as discipline: facility records for a detainee held 26 minutes say the detainee "Failed to comply with a lawful command."
Here is where the report draws its own line, and this piece keeps it. The report notes that in March 2026, two U.S. Senators wrote to the department about the enclosures. The inspector general writes that it could not independently confirm or refute ICE officials' account of how the enclosures were used, or other allegations, such as being denied food or water inside them, because none of the detainees it interviewed reported experiencing those conditions during the inspection. So those allegations stay allegations here.
The inspector general's own judgment does not hedge. The use of spaces that restrictive "is highly unconventional and does not align with standards for humane treatment," the report says, and confining people in small metal enclosures "for any reason presents significant risks to detainee health and well-being." Recommendation 5, addressed to the ICE official who runs Enforcement and Removal Operations, was to "immediately discontinue the use of the small metal enclosures to hold detainees for any reason or amount of time."
Why It Costs You: Less Than Half the Space, and Water Detainees Called Dirty
The enclosures are the headline. The housing units are where detainees spent most of their time, and the report found those short on room too. The standards the inspectors applied call for no less than 75 square feet of floor space for each person in dormitory housing. "At maximum capacity, the FSSF housing units provided 28 square feet per detainee." The report calls that less than half of what is required.
General population lived in eight windowless soft-sided structures. Each held eight housing units designed for 32 detainees, furnished with bunk beds and no common areas, seating or tables. To meet the 75-square-foot standard, the report says, each unit would need to hold no more than 11 detainees, about one-third of its maximum capacity. Detainees could leave their units for meals, for recreation three days a week, an hour at a time, for showers three times a week, and for medical reasons.
Then there is the daily business of being held somewhere. When inspectors asked about clean drinking water, six of the eight detainees they interviewed answered "No" and said the water was dirty. Inspectors found the showers "infested with small bugs," and seven of the eight detainees said the facility was not clean. Detainees showered three times a week, where the standard calls for daily access to a shower. On days without a shower, detainees had to request hygiene items, and staff supervised their use. If a detainee asked for toothpaste, the report says, "a staff member applies it to his toothbrush."
In the special management unit, one detainee reported 8 days without any opportunity for recreation, and the unit's telephones, installed shortly before the inspection, did not work. The facility's medical contractor did not use standardized forms to document withdrawal monitoring.
Now the money. It is federal money, which makes it yours. FEMA reported to the inspector general that on September 30, 2025, it obligated $608.4 million for the facility to Florida's Division of Emergency Management, and that on May 15, 2026, it disbursed $58.3 million to cover allowable operational costs. At the time of the inspection, ICE had told inspectors that the grant program had paid nothing yet to the facility or the state, and a facility official asked the OIG team "if we knew when they would receive funding."
How the Machine Works: Florida's Order, ICE's Detainees, No Written Rulebook
Florida built it and Washington paid toward it. The report says the State of Florida established the facility under Executive Order 23-03, it began operations July 3, 2025, and when inspectors visited, its warden and staff worked for a company under contract with the Florida Division of Emergency Management.
DHS had no direct contract with Florida for the facility, the report says, but it had 287(g) agreements with nine Florida agencies. Section 287(g), as the report describes it, lets the DHS Secretary enter written agreements under which a state, or a political subdivision of one, performs certain functions of an immigration officer, including detention.
Then nobody could name the rulebook. When the inspectors asked, facility staff "could not clearly identify which detention standards they used for holding detainees on immigration-related charges." ICE's own list of contractually obligated standards showed "N/A" for the facility. The handbook detainees received at intake said the facility followed ICE's performance-based standards and American Correctional Association standards. One official told the inspectors it was "so gray as to whose place this is…and which standards to follow," and said that because of that ambiguity, detainees went without a commissary, without in-person family visits, and without televisions or playing cards where they lived. So when the inspectors found a concern, they checked both sets of standards and applied whichever was more restrictive.
Here is how that runs, and it is this show's read. A state runs the building. A federal agency's detainees fill it. The facility provided no written policy naming the standard it followed. And when an inspector general writes up what it found, the first thing argued is not the fix. It is whose job the fix was.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
Take the department's case at full strength. DHS's own response is Appendix C of the report, and this piece has not read it, so what follows is DHS's position as the inspector general summarizes it. DHS stated that it had no contract with Florida to run the facility's detention space. As the OIG summarizes its response, the department said Florida held people there under its Section 287(g) authority and the state maintains authority over day-to-day operations. DHS also argued that a 287(g) agreement gives Washington no authority over how any facility physically operates, and none over state employees unless they are acting as immigration officers.
Add the facility's side. Staff called the enclosures calming areas and said detainees asked to use them. The posted policy set a 2-hour limit, and the records the report cites show nobody held past it. The inspection was limited in scope and took one day. And the report says ICE gave timely responses and never delayed or denied the inspectors information they asked for.
Now the inspector general's answer. At the time of the inspection, every detainee there was an ICE immigration detainee, and the report found that "ICE did have some degree of oversight authority and engagement at FSSF even in the absence of a contract." Its evidence: detainees at intake received an ICE Detainee Handbook, ICE information posters hung across the facility, ICE personnel were on hand helping staff, the department and the state told courts the facility operated with ICE oversight under 287(g), and ICE personnel had to escort the inspectors in on the first day. Whatever the extent of ICE's oversight, the report adds, DHS keeps authority over how the facility used federal money from FEMA's Detention Support Grant Program. The report's own title calls it ICE's Florida Soft-Sided Facility.
What You Can Actually Do
Read PDF pages 14 through 17 yourself. Open OIG-26-22 to page 14 and read the enclosure finding, the posted policy and Recommendation 5 in the inspector general's words, not anybody's summary, this one included.
Ask about the facility that is still open. The report points to Baker Correctional Institution, also known as "Deportation Depot," a detention facility the state runs in Sanderson, Florida, and it is still operating. Baker opened in September 2025 and held 1,028 detainees on August 27, 2026. ICE's documentation lists its contractually obligated standards as "N/A," and the report says ICE's Office of Detention Oversight has not inspected it internally and had no inspection scheduled for fiscal year 2026 or 2027. Write your U.S. representative and both of your senators. Ask which written detention standards Baker follows, and ask when ICE will inspect it.
If you know something firsthand, use the hotline. The report directs anyone reporting fraud, waste, abuse or criminal misconduct involving DHS programs, personnel and funds to the DHS OIG Hotline.
The So-What
DHS did not address the report's 10 recommendations. Because the facility ceased operations, the inspector general administratively closed all 10. The report says the oversight questions DHS raised remain consequential anyway, and Baker is its example.
Florida built it. Washington paid toward it. The inspector general says ICE had some degree of oversight. DHS, as the inspector general summarizes it, says the state had authority over the day-to-day. Closing the building closed the recommendations. It did not close the question of who answered for 79 detainees and about 18 square feet of floor.
Come Back for the Rest
We put the report's own words in front of you so you can hold this piece up against it, line by line. Subscribe to The Long Pour and the next document we read lands in your inbox.
The Receipts
Every fact in this piece comes from the inspector general's report; the other four sources are documents the report names.
- “Unannounced Inspection of ICE's Florida Soft-Sided Facility (‘Alligator Alcatraz’) in Ochopee, Florida” (DHS Office of Inspector General, OIG-26-22, final report, September 11, 2026, 33-page PDF; accessed September 15, 2026): the compliance findings, the housing space and the 10 recommendations.
- Small Metal Enclosures Used as "Calming Areas" (DHS OIG, OIG-26-22, PDF pages 14 to 17, September 11, 2026; accessed September 15, 2026): the 79 detainees, staff and ICE accounts, the discipline record and Recommendation 5.
- Background (DHS OIG, OIG-26-22, PDF pages 4 to 6, September 11, 2026; accessed September 15, 2026): Florida's order, the 287(g) agreements, FEMA's reported figures and the unclear standards.
- Management Comments and OIG Analysis (DHS OIG, OIG-26-22, PDF pages 24 to 26, September 11, 2026; accessed September 15, 2026): DHS's position as the OIG summarizes it, ICE's oversight and Baker.
- Executive Order Number 23-03 (Office of the Governor, State of Florida, January 6, 2023; accessed September 15, 2026): the order the report names as the facility's state authority.
- 8 U.S. Code § 1357, Powers of immigration officers and employees (Office of the Law Revision Counsel, subsection (g); accessed September 15, 2026): the agreements known as 287(g).
- Letter to the Secretary of Homeland Security and the Acting ICE Director (Sen. Jon Ossoff and Sen. Richard J. Durbin, March 25, 2026; accessed September 15, 2026): the March 2026 inquiry the report cites on the enclosures.
- DHS OIG Hotline (DHS Office of Inspector General; accessed September 15, 2026): where the report directs reports of fraud, waste, abuse or misconduct.