The Agriculture Department published a rule on Tuesday, and it did the counting for you. By the department's own estimate, "approximately 16.9 percent of participating SNAP households (17.6 percent of SNAP participants) would no longer receive SNAP benefits." The rule puts a number on it: that "represents 3.2 million households containing 6.3 million individuals in FY 2029," the first year the department expects the rule to hit full force.
That is not an advocacy group's projection. That is USDA, in writing, on docket FNA-2026-0661, and the comment window on it closes Dec. 10. As of today, that is 29 days.
So we are going to ask the two questions this show always asks. Who decided these families should go. And who keeps the money.
The Receipt
Here is the change, in the rule's own words. Right now SNAP regulations count TANF benefits as both cash and "non-cash or in-kind benefits or services from TANF-funded programs." A household getting either can be categorically eligible for SNAP. The proposal "would limit categorical eligibility to only households that receive TANF assistance, as defined at 45 CFR 260.31." In plain terms: TANF assistance, which the rule calls mostly cash plus some supportive services such as child care for unemployed parents, would still count. The other TANF services would not.
The department estimates the cut to federal SNAP benefit spending at "approximately $44.649 billion over the five-year period FY 2027-FY 2031." The Federal Register's record dates publication to Nov. 10 and lists comments closing Dec. 10.
Why It Costs You
Start with who these people are. The rule says that in FY 2024, about 5.4 million people lived in SNAP households with resources above the program's limit, and about 2.0 million lived in households with incomes above the federal limits. The bigger group is the savings group, not the paycheck group. And "resources," per the rule, means liquid or near-liquid assets, with exclusions that include a home, retirement and pensions.
Under the regular rules, a household without an elderly or disabled member needs gross income at or below 130 percent of the poverty guidelines. Under the state option this rule targets, the rule says, states can raise that to as much as 200 percent. That band is the family above the poverty line and nowhere near comfortable.
Then follow it to the lunch table. The rule says the change "impacts other nutrition assistance programs where SNAP participation confers eligibility in lieu of an income assessment," and it names "the National School Lunch Program and School Breakfast Program." The department puts the number of children who would lose automatic eligibility for free school meals at about 1.78 million. To be fair to the department's numbers, it also says about 97 percent of those children would still qualify on income and could sign up another way. The rule estimates school districts would process 197,000 more applications. And by its count, 93,000 children would drop from free to reduced-price meals and 28,000 would end up paying full price. (We have covered the school lunch line before.)
It keeps going. About 42,000 children could lose Summer EBT starting in summer 2029, the department estimates, and WIC would lose 5,500 women, infants and children. The rule's own civil rights analysis says the change has the potential to hit households headed by Asian, Hispanic or multiracial people, families with kids, and households with an elderly member. It also notes that "some small retailers may experience reductions in sales." The corner store feels this too.
How the Machine Works
Categorical eligibility is old and boring on purpose. The rule quotes the 1988 Senate report behind it: leaning on other programs' eligibility decisions "can greatly reduce the paperwork burden on both applicants and eligibility workers." If a family already passed one program's means test, the state did not make it run the same test twice.
The version this rule goes after is called broad-based categorical eligibility. It lets a state use a TANF-funded service to open SNAP to households above the federal limits. Per the rule, the number of states using it "grew from 18 to 43" between fiscal 2008 and 2011. As of December 2025, the rule counts 46 states using it, 37 with gross income limits above SNAP's, and 41 with no resource limit at all.
Here is what most coverage misses. The rule calls this a "loophole." The same rule says USDA itself encouraged states to lean on benefits worth next to nothing, such as "an informational pamphlet or an 800-number," to confer that eligibility. The loophole has a federal return address.
And this is round two. USDA "previously proposed changes to categorical eligibility on July 24, 2019." That proposal was withdrawn on June 10, 2021, and the rule records why: the department found it "did not sufficiently justify the impact on SNAP households or the costs to State agencies." This time the department's own estimate of the impact on households is 6.3 million people off SNAP in FY 2029.
Now follow the money. The rule estimates states would see a net reduction in SNAP spending of about $5.243 billion over five years, citing Section 10105 of P.L. 119-21, while their administrative costs rise about $928.5 million. What the rule calls the effect on household burden is estimated at about $71.7 million. Under the rule, "States and households would need to contact financial institutions, Departments of Motor Vehicles, or other entities to obtain documentation of household resources." And in the same document, the department writes that the rule "does not impose substantial or direct compliance costs on State and local governments." Hold those two sentences next to each other and read them again.
Who keeps the money? Washington keeps $44.649 billion in benefits it no longer pays, by its own estimate. States come out ahead on net, by its own estimate. Every dollar of that federal figure is a grocery benefit that stops.
The Strongest Version of the Other Side
The department rests its case on the law, and it is not a silly one. It says the households it would cut "exceed the Federal statutory limits for SNAP," and that the rule targets benefits "to needy households that have qualified for TANF assistance." Congress wrote income and resource limits. A rule that lets states route around them with a pamphlet is, in the department's telling, an agency ignoring the statute.
It brings examples. In a state with no resource limit, the rule says, a household holding $1 million or more in available resources and no regular income could qualify, and the department says it is "aware of instances where millionaires have received SNAP benefits." It cites a GAO finding, as the rule describes it, of payment errors for 17.2 percent of these households over the federal income limits in fiscal 2010, against 6.7 percent of other SNAP households. And it says over 840,000 households of one or two people got the minimum benefit in 2024 only through this option, nearly $214 million. The minimum benefit was $23 in FY 2025.
Take that seriously, then put it on the scale. The millionaire is an anecdote in a footnote. The 6.3 million is the department's own estimate. A $23 benefit going to someone over a limit is a real policy question, and the answer the rule chose is to remove 6.3 million people and push 1.78 million children off automatic free lunch. The rule does ask for input, on its own terms: it "invites comments on whether there are alternative approaches to limit categorical eligibility with TANF that achieve the same policy goals." That is an invitation to cut a different way, not to stop cutting. You can still tell them the goal is wrong. That is our advice, not their invitation.
What You Can Actually Do
File a comment on or before Dec. 10. The rule gives three routes.
Online. Go to regulations.gov, search docket FNA-2026-0661, and follow the instructions there. The docket system's own record closes comments at 11:59 p.m. Eastern on Dec. 10, by our conversion of its timestamp, and does not accept late comments.
Email. Send it to sm.fn.snappdbrules@usda.gov. Per the rule, put the docket ID, FNA-2026-0661, and the rule's title, "Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program: Reforming Categorical Eligibility," in the subject line.
Mail. Address it exactly as the rule does: "SNAP Program Development Division, Food and Nutrition Administration, 5601 Sunnyside Ave, Beltsville, MD 20705." The rule says comments "must be received on or before" the deadline, so mail is the slowest road. If you mail, mail this week.
Before you write, know this: the rule says "the substance of the comments and the identity of the individuals or entities submitting the comments will be subject to public disclosure." Your name goes on the public record. Leave out your case number, your Social Security number and anything about your kids you would not post on a church bulletin board.
What to say: tell them something they do not already know. If your family gets SNAP and has savings you built to get out of the hole, say how much the resource test would cost you. If you work in a school front office, the rule says districts would process 197,000 more meal applications; tell them who does that work. If you run a store that takes EBT, the rule already concedes sales may drop; tell them by how much. And the department's regulatory impact analysis is on the docket too, listed in the Federal Register record as FNA-2026-0661-0002. Answer its numbers with yours. Specific beats loud.
The So-What
The department wrote the number down itself. Six point three million people. It is not hiding them. The only open question is whether anybody says their names back to it in the next 29 days.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The official framing on top, the receipts underneath, every figure traced back to the document it came from so you can go open it yourself and check my work. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the receipts before the next quiet robbery clears the courthouse. Subscribe to The Long Pour. The free newsletter where the week's little robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Each claim above links to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program: Reforming Categorical Eligibility (USDA Food and Nutrition Administration, proposed rule, RIN 0584-AF10, docket FNA-2026-0661, FR Doc. 2026-22936, Nov. 10, 2026; accessed November 11, 2026): the rule's change, estimates, case, history and comment instructions.
- Federal Register document 2026-22936 (Federal Register API record, published Nov. 10, 2026; accessed November 11, 2026): publication date, Dec. 10 comment close, docket ID and the RIA's docket number.
- Regulations.gov document FNA-2026-0661-0001 (Regulations.gov API v4 record, docket FNA-2026-0661; accessed November 11, 2026): the comment end timestamp and that late comments are not accepted.