Start with a number the IRS printed itself. A taxpayer is eligible for $2,200 in child tax credit, and $955 of that is refundable. After certain other credits, that taxpayer's income tax comes to $706. Take $706 away from $955 and $249 is left over, the part that comes back.

The Treasury Department and the IRS want that $249 to carry a new legal name. Under proposed regulations published August 20, 2026 at 91 FR 53812, the refunded portion of four refundable credits would count as a Federal public benefit under Congress's 1996 Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act. Noncitizen filers who are not qualified aliens under that law would be ineligible to receive it.

This is a proposal, not a final rule. The notice proposes that it apply to tax years that end on or after the day it is published as a final regulation. Written comments are due October 5, 2026, and a public hearing is scheduled for October 14. So here is what the notice reaches, what it leaves alone, and how to get your say into the record before the window shuts.

The Receipt: Four Credits and the Part That Comes Back

The notice is FR Doc. 2026-16985, REG-119882-25. The four credits it names are the child tax credit, the earned income credit, the American opportunity tax credit and the adoption tax credit.

Now read the line that sets the scope. The notice says the proposed regulations "would bar receipt only of the portion of the sum of those affected refundable tax credits that exceeds the income tax liability." That is the whole shape of it. The part of a credit that offsets tax is untouched. What the proposal reaches is the refunded portion, the amount left over once the tax is covered. A filer who claims more than one of the four adds them together first, and the refunded portion is whatever that sum runs past the tax.

That is where the $249 comes from. It is the notice's own child tax credit example, and the notice calls that $249 the Federal public benefit. Under the proposal, a taxpayer who is an alien and not a qualified alien could not receive it as a refund, have it credited against unpaid tax, or have it offset against certain non-tax debts. The notice also says those taxpayers could still get the nonrefunded portion if they otherwise qualify for the credits.

Why It Costs You: Treasury's Own Count

Treasury put numbers in the notice, and it put its own label on them. For tax year 2026, it estimates that 49 million individual returns will carry a claim for at least one of the four credits, and that 24 million of them will claim one that results in a Federal public benefit, meaning a refunded portion.

Then the harder number. The notice says Treasury and the IRS have no data on whether a taxpayer is a qualified alien. Working from Social Security Administration data, Citizenship and Immigration Services statistics and historical Homeland Security estimates of nonimmigrants, it offers "a rough estimate" that 200,000 to 700,000 of those 24 million taxpayers would likely be ineligible for tax year 2026, which is 0.8 to 2.8 percent. The notice says those figures assume static behavior. They do not account for anyone changing whether or how they claim.

It puts dollars on it the same way. Treasury estimates the average refunded portion, across all taxpayers whose claims include one, at $3,656 in 2026. Applying that average to its range of affected taxpayers, the notice arrives at "$0.7 billion to $2.6 billion of disallowed credits."

Two of the four credits change with the number of qualifying children. The child tax credit is figured per qualifying child. The earned income credit's maximum varies with the number of qualifying children, and the notice lists the 2025 maximums as $649 with no qualifying child, $4,328 with one, $7,152 with two and $8,046 with three or more. So how large a refunded portion runs on a given return depends in part on how many qualifying children the credits are figured on. Treasury's estimate counts taxpayers.

How the Machine Works: A 1996 Law and a Declaration on the Return

The law underneath is 8 U.S.C. § 1611. It bars aliens who are not qualified aliens from those benefits: such an alien "is not eligible for any Federal public benefit," except as the section provides. 8 U.S.C. § 1641 says who counts. Its subsection (b) covers lawful permanent residents, people granted asylum, admitted refugees, people paroled into the country for at least a year, people whose deportation is being withheld, people granted conditional entry under a provision in effect before April 1, 1980, Cuban and Haitian entrants, and people residing in the United States under a Compact of Free Association. Subsection (c) adds certain people who have been battered or subjected to extreme cruelty.

For most of that law's life, refundable credits sat outside it. The notice says that before 2018, Treasury and the IRS did not treat tax benefits, refundable credits among them, as Federal public benefits under the 1996 law, and that Treasury began to reconsider in 2018. In a November 19, 2025 memorandum opinion, the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel concluded that the refundable portions of five credits, the earned income, additional child, American opportunity, premium and Saver's Match credits, are "Federal public benefits" unavailable to non-qualified aliens. The notice says Treasury and the IRS incorporate that reasoning.

The proposal does not track the opinion exactly. It leaves out the premium tax credit, on the view that restrictions Congress later wrote into the health law and the 2025 tax law override the 1996 law for that credit. It says the Saver's Match will get its own proposed regulations. And it adds the adoption tax credit, which the Office of Legal Counsel had not addressed, as a similar benefit.

Then the mechanics on the return itself. On a joint return, one spouse who is a "U.S. citizen, U.S. national, or qualified alien" is enough to receive the joint refund. Each individual claiming a refunded credit, or one spouse on a joint return, would provide "a declaration under penalty of perjury" that they are eligible. The IRS says it intends to update forms and instructions, and the notice names Schedule 3-A, or another form the Treasury Secretary sets, filed along with the 1040.

Status gets checked on one day. The proposal fixes it on the date a taxpayer files the return that first claims the credit for that year. The notice walks through it. A noncitizen filer who is not a qualified alien on April 15, becomes one on December 1, and files an amended return on December 15 still could not receive the refunded portion, because the first claim came before the change. A filer who first claims the credit on that December 15 amended return could.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Treasury's case is that the 1996 law already bars non-qualified aliens from Federal public benefits, and that the proposal only says how that bar applies to credit dollars paid out past a filer's tax. It says the proposal is "expected to have limited economic effects." It notes that under the tax code, taxpayers are generally already required to have a valid Social Security number to be eligible for these credits. It leaves the part of a credit that offsets tax alone. It lets one qualifying spouse carry a joint return, and says it chose that over making couples divide the credits to reduce taxpayer burden and return errors. It weighed requiring everyone who claims any of the four credits to certify their status, and proposed the narrower version, where only claims with a refunded portion carry the declaration. On its own numbers, the taxpayers it expects to be ineligible are 0.8 to 2.8 percent of those who get a refunded portion.

That is a real argument, made in writing, and it deserves to be read that way. The answer is in the same notice. Treasury says it lacks the data to count the people this reaches, which is why its range is a rough estimate, and it says it cannot precisely estimate the dollars either. Every claim with a refunded portion would carry the declaration, citizens' claims included. By Treasury's own estimates, that is a declaration under penalty of perjury on an estimated 24 million returns to reach somewhere between 200,000 and 700,000 taxpayers.

What You Can Actually Do

Comment by October 5, 2026. The notice's own words: "Written or electronic comments must be received by October 5, 2026." It also says "Commenters are strongly encouraged to submit public comments electronically." The Federal Register page for the rule links to the comment page on Regulations.gov, and the notice tells commenters to "indicate IRS and REG-119882-25." The notice's paper address is "CC:PA:01:PR (REG-119882-25), Room 5503, Internal Revenue Service, P.O. Box 7604, Ben Franklin Station, Washington, DC 20044." Treasury asks for comments on all aspects of the proposal, and specifically on its rule for when eligibility is determined.

Know that your comment is public. The notice says electronic comments "cannot be edited or withdrawn" once submitted, and that Treasury and the IRS will publish comments for public availability. Write only what you are comfortable seeing posted.

Watch the hearing date, because it can disappear. The hearing is set for October 14, 2026, at 10 a.m. Eastern at the IRS building at 1111 Constitution Avenue NW in Washington, and the notice says participants may attend by telephone instead. Anyone who wants to speak must send an outline of topics, with the time for each, by October 5. The notice is plain about the rest: "If no outlines are received October 5, 2026, the public hearing will be cancelled." Requests to attend must arrive by 5 p.m. Eastern on October 9. The email addresses and the exact subject lines to use are in the notice's Comments and Public Hearing section on the Federal Register page; copy them from there.

Read the examples yourself. The notice runs 16 pages, 53812 through 53827, and each of the four proposed sections carries worked examples with the dollars laid out line by line. The $249 is in the child tax credit section.

The So-What

This is an immigration eligibility rule that would ride on a tax return. It would come with a declaration under penalty of perjury, a status fixed on the day a credit is first claimed, and a new legal name for money the credit formula already produced. Right now it is a proposal. The notice says comments submitted on time will be considered before it is adopted as final, and the time runs out October 5.

Come Back for the Rest

We read the notice all the way through so you can hold this piece up against it, line by line. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and subscribe to The Long Pour so the next document we open lands in your inbox.

The Receipts

Every figure in this piece comes from the Federal Register notice; the statute and opinion quotations come from the documents linked below.