You have seen the list. It goes around every few months with a graphic and a lot of exclamation points: Victoria's Secret, Whole Foods, Starbucks, McDonald's, all of them supposedly running on prison labor. In 2020 PolitiFact ran the claim down and rated it Mostly False.
Here is the part that should make you angrier, not less. The meme is wrong because it is too easy to debunk. The real machine is built so you can never make a clean list at all.
Start with the law, because for people convicted of a crime, forced labor is legal. The Thirteenth Amendment abolished slavery "except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have been duly convicted." Read that clause twice. It did not close the door. It wrote an exception into the Constitution, and that exception has never been repealed. A person convicted of a crime can be made to work, and made to work for almost nothing, and the founding document signs off.
So why is the meme wrong? Because Victoria's Secret never signed a contract with a prison. Years ago it signed with a company called Third Generation, and Third Generation signed with a South Carolina prison to sew lingerie. The brand keeps its hands clean and its name off the paperwork. That is not a loophole in the system. That is the system. Whole Foods sold goat cheese and tilapia tied to Colorado prison labor until protests pushed the company to announce, in September 2015, that it would clear the goods from its shelves by April 2016. Starbucks had coffee packaged by Washington inmates through a subcontractor, an arrangement the company says ended long ago. Every one of those companies says its deal is over, and the records back them up. The meme takes decade-old contracts that already ended and sells them to you as this morning's news.
Now the part that is happening right now. The federal government runs its own factory. It is called UNICOR, or Federal Prison Industries, and in fiscal year 2023 it booked about $471 million in total revenue while paying incarcerated workers between 23 cents and $1.15 an hour. The Department of Defense was its largest federal customer two years running: 56 percent of FPI's fiscal year 2023 sales activity, interagency sales included, after topping the customer list in fiscal year 2022 too. There is also a program with a bureaucratic name, PIECP, that lets private companies use prison labor directly. Forty-five programs hold that certification now, running at least 222 partnerships with private firms. Federal law says it has to pay them prevailing wages. Then that same law, 18 U.S.C. § 1761(c)(2), lets taxes, room and board, family support, and a crime-victim fund claw back up to 80 percent of the paycheck.
The single hardest receipt comes from Alabama. The Associated Press analyzed 24 years of the state's own monthly corrections reports to tally the money. It also parsed more than 83,000 pages of data from a public records request, and that data shows at least 500 private businesses leasing incarcerated workers between 2018 and mid-March 2024. Fast-food franchises and hotels among them. Alabama takes 40 percent off the top of every paycheck those workers earn. The garnished wages have, in AP's own words, "generated more than $250 million for the state since 2000." And, as AP reported, "Alabama collected more than $13 million in work release fees in fiscal year 2024."
Say the next part carefully, because this is where careless people get sued. Some of those prisoners worked at fast-food franchises, including McDonald's outlets. A franchise is a small business that licenses a logo. It is not the corporation. McDonald's corporate says it does not allow prison labor in its supply chain or at the restaurants it owns, and that franchisees operate independently. That distinction is real and it matters. It also does not make the 40 percent state cut go away.
The food supply is the other live thread. A sweeping two-year AP investigation, published January 29, 2024, traced farm goods out of prisons and into the national grocery system. Reporters followed cattle out of the Louisiana State Penitentiary at Angola to a nearby auction house, then some 600 more miles to a slaughterhouse in Texas whose beef feeds into the supply chains of Walmart, McDonald's, Cargill, and Burger King. Read that exactly as written. It feeds into their supply chains. That is a documented link, not a confession that any one of them runs on prison labor.
Two companies skipped the usual dance. Cargill told the AP it had bought goods directly from prison farms, called it a small fraction, and said it was working out what to do about it. That is not a denial. Walmart, asked years earlier, said its supplier standards "strictly prohibit involuntary prison labor" and that a review of its records "did not find" evidence of it, though it added that a small number of its suppliers "use voluntary labor as part of prison rehabilitation programs." AP reported that Hickman's Family Farms, an Arizona prison-labor contractor, "supplies many grocery stores, including Costco and Kroger," selling under names like Eggland's Best and Land O' Lakes. AP asked the companies it had identified for comment; "most did not respond."
Some of this is in court right now, and the honest word there is "alleges." A federal jury in the Western District of Washington awarded $17,287,063.05 in back pay to a class of immigration detainees at the GEO Group's Tacoma detention center, for paying them a dollar a day. After a bench trial the court added $5,950,340.00 in unjust enrichment owed to the state, and a federal appeals court upheld both awards. GEO listed its principal executive offices in Boca Raton, Florida. A separate forced-labor class action, brought by detainees at GEO's ICE detention center in Aurora, Colorado, went all the way to the Supreme Court on a question that had nothing to do with forced labor: whether GEO could appeal before trial. On February 25, 2026, the Court said no. The contractor doctrine GEO leaned on "provides a defense to liability, not an immunity from suit," so the company has to go to trial and argue about it afterward. GEO lost that fight and the forced-labor claims went back down to the district court. Nothing in the ruling said GEO did it. It said GEO has to wait its turn to argue. GEO's answer every time is the same: the dollar-a-day rate is set by the federal government, not by the company. Hold onto that defense, because it is true that a dollar a day is a lawful federal floor. The fight is over whether the work is voluntary and whether state law can demand more. No court has settled that yet.
Put a number on the whole thing and it runs past any single brand. The ACLU and the University of Chicago found that incarcerated workers "produce at least $2 billion in goods and $9 billion worth of prison maintenance services annually," and call the real figure likely much higher. Most of those workers keep the prisons themselves running, and most states pay them pennies an hour. Seven, Alabama and Florida among them, pay nothing for most prison work.
Here is why it lands on your kitchen table and not just theirs. A workforce that cannot quit, cannot unionize, and can be paid pennies is a floor under every wage above it. When a poultry line can call on labor that cannot walk off the job or organize for a raise, the worker down the road is bidding against that price whether he knows it or not. Frank Dwayne Ellington found the sharp end of it. He was serving a life sentence when he was killed on the line at a Koch Foods plant in Alabama in 2017. OSHA fined the company $19,500. Koch's argument was that he was not technically an employee.
So the next time that meme scrolls past and somebody in the replies calls it debunked, you will know the debunking is the trick. Boycotting a lingerie catalog over a contract that ended before some of you were born does nothing. The machine running today does not need a famous logo. It needs a subcontractor, a farm exemption Congress added by the Act of Oct. 14, 1940, ch. 872, 54 Stat. 1134, now 18 U.S.C. § 1761(b): "This chapter shall not apply to agricultural commodities or parts for the repair of farm machinery," and a public that argues about the meme instead of the mechanism. Follow the money and figure out exactly who did it, and it leads to a state treasurer's office in Montgomery and a slaughterhouse in Texas, not a catalog.
Come back for the rest
We do this every week. The easy story on top, the receipts underneath, every number traced back to the document it came from. Pull up a chair, pour something cold, and let us send you the real machine before the next meme sends you chasing the wrong one. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's small thefts and the one big one land in your inbox together.
Down here we don't say goodbye. We say: y'all come back, now.
The Receipts
Every claim above traces to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.
- Thirteenth Amendment, U.S. Constitution (Constitution Annotated, congress.gov; accessed August 23, 2026): the "except as a punishment for crime" penal-labor exception.
- PolitiFact fact-check (PolitiFact, June 22, 2020; accessed August 23, 2026): the viral brand list rated Mostly False; carries Walmart's statement that some suppliers "use voluntary labor."
- Statement on labor from correctional institutions (Victoria's Secret & Co.; accessed August 23, 2026): the company's confirmation that the Third Generation arrangement existed and ended.
- "Yes, prisoners used to sew lingerie for Victoria's Secret" (The Washington Post, via The Philadelphia Inquirer; byline Emily Yahr, June 19, 2015, citing a 1995 National Institute of Justice study; accessed September 7, 2026): Third Generation sewed at Leath Correctional Facility, Greenwood, South Carolina.
- Whole Foods to stop selling inmate-made products (CBS News, September 30, 2015; accessed August 23, 2026): the Colorado prison-labor products pulled after protest.
- Starbucks and Nintendo (Prison Legal News, March 15, 2002; accessed August 23, 2026): the original reporting on the Signature Packaging subcontract in Washington.
- UNICOR wage rates (Bureau of Prisons; accessed September 7, 2026): workers "typically earn between 23¢ to $1.15 per hour."
- FPI FY2023 financial statement audit (DOJ Office of the Inspector General, audit 26-006; accessed September 7, 2026): FY2023 total revenue $471,160,000; DOD took 56 percent of FY2023 sales activity, interagency sales included.
- Defense Contracting: DOD's Use of Federal Prison Industries (U.S. GAO, GAO-23-106240, August 2023; accessed September 7, 2026): "The Department of Defense (DOD) was FPI's largest federal customer for fiscal year 2022."
- PIECP overview (Bureau of Justice Assistance; accessed August 23, 2026): the certified program that lets private firms use prison labor directly, paying them prevailing wages.
- "Captive Labor" (ACLU & University of Chicago Law School Global Human Rights Clinic, 2022; accessed August 23, 2026): "at least $2 billion in goods and $9 billion worth of prison maintenance services annually."
- Alabama work-release investigation (Associated Press, via Alabama Public Radio, December 23, 2024; accessed September 7, 2026): the 500-plus businesses, the 40 percent cut, and the two quoted dollar figures.
- McDonald's corporate response (Las Vegas Sun, December 20, 2024; accessed August 23, 2026): the statement barring prison labor in its supply chain and corporate-owned restaurants, and that franchisees operate independently.
- Prisoners in the U.S. are part of a hidden workforce linked to hundreds of popular food brands (Associated Press, via CNBC, January 29, 2024; accessed September 7, 2026): the Angola trace, the Koch Foods death, Hickman's customers "including Costco and Kroger," and "most did not respond."
- Takeaways from the AP's investigation into how US prison labor supports many popular food brands (Associated Press, via The Seattle Times, January 29, 2024; accessed September 7, 2026): AP's own summary of the farm goods it traced into the national grocery system.
- Walmart, Tyson distribute food linked to prison labor (Arkansas Times, January 30, 2024; accessed September 7, 2026): Cargill's acknowledgment that it bought goods from prison farms.
- AG Ferguson: Jury finds GEO, for-profit operator of Tacoma ICE detention center, must pay detainee workers minimum wage (Washington State Office of the Attorney General, October 27, 2021; accessed September 7, 2026): the liability finding: GEO paid $1 a day though state law required $13.69/hour; a $57 million revenue projection; no damages figure.
- Ninth Circuit opinion affirming the GEO verdict (U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit, January 16, 2025; accessed September 7, 2026): jury back pay of $17,287,063.05 plus a bench-trial award of $5,950,340.00 in unjust enrichment.
- GEO Group 10-K, FY2020 (SEC EDGAR; accessed September 7, 2026): principal executive offices in Boca Raton, Florida, as of that filing.
- GEO Group, Inc. v. Menocal, slip opinion (U.S. Supreme Court, No. 24-758, 607 U.S. \_\_\_\_, decided February 25, 2026; Kagan, J.; accessed September 2, 2026): the Aurora detainees' forced-labor class action, and the holding that GEO cannot appeal its contractor defense until final judgment.
- 18 U.S.C. § 1761 (U.S. Code, Office of the Law Revision Counsel; accessed September 7, 2026): § 1761(b)'s farm exemption; § 1761(c)(2)'s 80-percent deduction cap.
- Act of Oct. 14, 1940, ch. 872, 54 Stat. 1134 (U.S. Statutes at Large; accessed September 7, 2026): the farm-machinery and agricultural-commodities exemption's origin, later folded into § 1761(b).