A judge looks at a person charged with a crime and finds they are too sick to understand the case against them or help with their own defense. The case stops. The judge commits that person to a state hospital. And then, according to a federal lawsuit filed September 16, the person stays in a county jail cell and waits.

Florida's statute gives the jail that job for up to 15 days. The complaint in Disability Rights Florida v. Williams says the Florida Department of Children and Families' own sworn numbers put the average wait at about four months.

So we are going to ask the two questions this show always asks. Who is waiting. And who is paying for the wait.

The Receipt

Start with the law, because you can open it yourself. Section 916.107 of the Florida Statutes says that when a client has been "adjudicated incompetent to proceed," a jail "may be used as an emergency facility for up to 15 days" after the state receives a completed copy of the court's commitment order.

The lawsuit reads that window as a deadline. The complaint says Florida law gives the department, DCF, 15 days, counted from the day it receives the court's commitment paperwork, to move these defendants out of the jail and into a state hospital, and that every criminal proceeding stays paused until the person is stabilized and treated enough to take part in their own case. It says DCF misses that deadline by an average of more than 100 days.

Disability Rights Florida is the plaintiff. The Southern Poverty Law Center's announcement says the SPLC, Disability Rights Florida, the Florida Justice Institute and the firm Terris, Pravlik & Millian filed it. The defendant is Kathryn Williams, sued in her official capacity as DCF's interim secretary, and the suit asks for declaratory and injunctive relief.

Then the complaint tells you what DCF told the courts. It says that in July 2025, answering petitions in criminal courts that asked for immediate transfers, DCF submitted affidavits attesting that 881 people were on its waitlist, that 772 of them had waited longer than 15 days, and that the average wait was about four months: 117 days for men and 125 days for women.

Read those numbers as what they are. They are DCF's sworn figures as the complaint reports them. This desk has not opened the affidavits.

Disability Rights Florida ran its own count, too. The complaint says the group and its lawyers interviewed at least 129 clients and constituents in 25 counties and could measure the wait for 108 of them, from the day a court found them incompetent to the day DCF admitted them. The average was at least 124 days. The complaint calls that a conservative projection, because 39 of those people had no exact transfer date. The longest wait it found was 246 days.

Why It Costs You

Here is the part that should stop you cold. Nobody on this list has been convicted of the charge that put them there.

"These individuals with mental health disabilities have not been convicted and are presumed innocent," Kelly Knapp, a senior staff attorney at the SPLC, said in the announcement. Their cases are on hold. No trial, no plea, no way forward. They wait.

The complaint says that on any given day at least 150 people found incompetent are waiting in county jails inside the Southern District of Florida alone. It says jails, with few mental health options of their own, often end up holding people in this condition in solitary confinement until DCF finally takes them, locked in a cell "around the size of a king-size bed, for at least 23 hours a day." And it says Disability Rights Florida identified three people who died in county jails after DCF let their transfers run past the 15 days. This piece does not name them.

The wait also does not end where it looks like it ends. The complaint argues that the longer a person goes untreated, the longer restoration takes once they finally reach a hospital, which keeps that bed full longer and pushes the next person in line further back. By the time some people get through all of it, the complaint says, "they often serve more time, at greater cost to their overall health and the public purse" than if they had been sentenced on day one.

"The state cannot leave people in legal limbo while their mental health deteriorates," Dante P. Trevisani, litigation director at the Florida Justice Institute, said in the same announcement.

That is who pays first. People the law presumes innocent, paying in months.

The County Picks Up the Tab

Then there is the second bill, and it lands on your county.

A county jail is where these people wait. The complaint says DCF makes county jails do double duty, as lockup and as mental health treatment facility, for people who should be in DCF custody, "without any increase in state resources." It goes further, and says DCF has spared itself the cost of meeting its legal obligations while "placing a huge financial burden on each of the county jails throughout the State of Florida."

That is the plaintiff's charge, and the complaint does not put a dollar figure on it. But a jail bill is a public bill, and the complaint names who is holding it: the counties.

How the Machine Works

None of this is new, and the complaint's history section is where that becomes plain. It says lawyers for people found incompetent have been litigating these delays for nearly 50 years.

Here is how it runs, as the complaint tells it:

  • In 1981, when state law let a jail serve as an emergency facility for 45 days, a federal district court held that the state had 72 hours to get people out of jails and into treatment facilities.
  • In 1993, the Legislature set the jail window at 15 days. By 1995, the state was running about 40 days past it.
  • By 2006, the waitlist had grown to around 300 people, and at least 240 of them had been waiting past the 15 days. State courts in multiple jurisdictions sanctioned DCF or threatened to.
  • Then DCF's secretary resigned, the Legislature put more money into forensic treatment beds and diversion programs, and for the next decade, the complaint says, DCF kept the wait under 15 days.

Sit with that last one. By the complaint's own history, after more money came, the wait came down.

Then it climbed back up. The complaint says DCF added only around 360 forensic beds from 2006 to 2025. The waitlist reached 639 people by 2022. In 2024 it jumped 36 percent by July, from 354 to 482, with state hospital beds 98 percent full. By the July 2025 affidavits, 881.

Now follow the money. The complaint says that for fiscal year 2025-2026 the Legislature gave DCF another $78 million to expand state hospital bed capacity, and kept $58 million of that locked in reserve until DCF delivered certain metrics. One of those was a Behavioral Health Gap Analysis. The Legislature released the money after it got that analysis, the complaint says.

What did the analysis find? According to the complaint, state facilities would need at least 1,602 more forensic beds within five years just to hold a 98 percent occupancy rate, one the complaint, quoting the analysis, calls "unsustainable." To run at 85 percent, which the complaint calls the industry standard, they would need 2,034 more forensic beds by 2029.

And then, the complaint says, DCF's 2026-2027 Legislative Budget Request asked for no money to add forensic beds at state hospitals. It asked for 85 community residential treatment beds instead, for people who can be diverted to settings less restrictive than a state hospital.

A projected gap of about 2,000 beds, in an analysis DCF itself handed the Legislature. A budget request for none of them. Both documents are described here the way the complaint describes them; this desk has not opened either one.

The Strongest Version of the Other Side

Let me give DCF's side as fairly as the record in hand allows, and tell you exactly what that record is.

This desk had not obtained a response from DCF as this piece was drafted. So what follows is the state's position as the plaintiff describes it, and you should weigh it that way. The complaint says DCF has repeatedly argued that it does not have the resources to build hospital beds and staff them at the level demand requires. The complaint's label for that argument is "the excuse." It is not a neutral word, and it is not DCF's.

The resource argument is not nothing. Beds take buildings and people to staff them. The gap analysis, as the complaint describes it, projected the forensic waitlist growing 6 percent a year while Florida's population would grow 1.5 percent. The statute itself also allows for some care before a transfer: it says that while a person waits in jail for admission, the local community mental health provider, among others, may evaluate and treat them there. And asking for community beds is a real policy choice, one the complaint itself describes as serving people who can be diverted out of the state hospital track.

Here is the complaint's answer. It says that even if the resource problem is real, DCF has repeatedly failed to fully put in place treatment alternatives the state already authorizes, and that no shortage of resources lets DCF give up its constitutional duty to provide the treatment courts have ordered. That is a legal argument. Whether it holds is for the court to decide, and nothing in this piece is a ruling or legal advice.

What you can judge without a law degree is the budget request. By the complaint's account, DCF handed the Legislature the size of the gap and then asked for no new state hospital forensic beds.

What You Can Actually Do

Read the complaint. It is 44 pages, posted by the SPLC. The history is paragraphs 36 through 44. The budget is paragraphs 46 through 48.

Read the 15 days yourself. Section 916.107 is short. The jail language is in subsection (1)(a).

Follow the case. It is Disability Rights Florida, Inc. v. Williams, Case No. 1:26-cv-26377, in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Florida, Miami Division. Watch for DCF's response. That is where the state's side goes on the record in its own words.

Ask your state legislators one question. Does the next budget fund the forensic beds the gap analysis described, and if it does not, what is the plan for the people waiting in county jails in the meantime?

If someone you love is on this waitlist, their defense lawyer is the person to ask. This piece can tell you what a lawsuit says. It cannot tell you what to do in a particular case.

The So-What

The statute says 15 days. DCF's sworn average, as the complaint reports it, is about four months. In between sit people who have not been convicted, counties the complaint says are paying to hold them, and a budget request with no new state hospital forensic beds in it.

The complaint says Florida got the wait under 15 days once, after the Legislature put more money in. Whether a court orders the state to fix it this time is what this case asks. Who pays until then is not a mystery.

Come back for the rest

Every number in this piece is tied to the document it came from, so you can check the work. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's receipts land in your inbox together.


The Receipts

Every claim above traces to a document you can open yourself, with the access date on each line.