There is one sentence buried in the 1996 welfare law that has kept thirty years of church-and-state peace, and almost nobody has ever read it. Here it is, whole:

"No funds provided directly to institutions or organizations to provide services and administer programs under subsection (a)(1)(A) shall be expended for sectarian worship, instruction, or proselytization."

In plain English: we will pay you to feed people. We will not pay you to preach at them while they eat.

On August 25, the Justice Department's Office of Legal Counsel published a 39-page opinion saying that sentence is unconstitutional. Not outdated. Not unwise. Unconstitutional, along with the matching sentences in the addiction-treatment law and the child-care law.

And here is the part worth sitting with. The people who wrote that line were not the ACLU. They were Republicans, in 1996, who wanted faith-based charities in the anti-poverty business and knew exactly where they were putting the fence.

The Receipt

The opinion is called Constitutionality of Religious Restrictions on the Use of Federal Funds. It is signed by Assistant Attorney General T. Elliot Gaiser and Deputy Assistant Attorney General Joshua J. Craddock, and it is addressed to the Director of the Office for Civil Rights at Health and Human Services. HHS requested it on July 1, in a memorandum from the department's deputy general counsel to Craddock.

HHS asked two questions. Are these religious restrictions required by the Establishment Clause? If not, are they allowed under the Free Exercise Clause? OLC's answer, in its own words: "The answer to both questions is no."

The headline sits in the syllabus on page one: "Use-based religious restrictions on generally available federal funding programs are presumptively unconstitutional."

The conclusion in Part IV is flatter and sharper:

"The statutory religious restrictions are therefore unconstitutional under the First Amendment. Should HHS establish a policy not to enforce those unconstitutional statutory provisions and the Department's attendant regulations, it should report that decision to Congress within 30 days of establishing the policy."

Read that second sentence again, because it is the whole story in miniature. The lawyers have written the permission slip and told the agency where to file the paperwork after it stops enforcing the law.

Three statutes are named. Welfare services, at 42 U.S.C. § 604a(j). Substance-abuse treatment, at § 290kk-2 and § 300x-65(i). Child care, at § 9858k(a) and § 9858l(a)(4). The opinion also retires OLC's own 2019 opinion on religious restrictions in loans to historically Black colleges, saying it "no longer reflects the current state of the law."

What an OLC Opinion Is, and What It Is Not

This part matters more than the heat, so take it slow.

The Office of Legal Counsel is the shop that tells the executive branch what its own lawyers are allowed to think. When OLC says a statute is unconstitutional, that is binding inside the administration and nowhere else. It is not a ruling. No judge signed it. No case was argued. Nobody lost.

It also does not repeal anything. Those sentences are still in the United States Code, exactly as Congress wrote them. What changes is that the government's own attorneys have been instructed to stop treating them as law, and the agency has been handed the procedure for walking away.

So if you see a headline saying the ban is gone, that is not right. What is gone is the enforcer.

Why It Costs You

Look at which three programs got picked, because the selection is the argument.

The opinion spells out what the welfare restriction covers, on page 29:

"TANF-funded services, covered by the PRWORA restriction, include child-care assistance, pre-kindergarten, job-preparation classes and vocational training, work subsidies, family-formation projects, youth-mentoring programs, abstinence and sex-education programs, homeless shelters, and emergency food programs like soup kitchens and food banks."

The addiction restriction covers the grants that fund mental-health services, substance-use treatment and prevention, adult suicide prevention, and youth overdose prevention. The third covers child care for low-income families.

Now notice what those rooms have in common. A shelter bed at eleven at night. A detox chair on day two. A daycare you can afford on the wage you actually make. These are the three places in American life where a person has the least ability to stand up, say no thank you, and walk out into the parking lot.

That is not an accident of drafting. A captive audience is the cheapest audience there is.

And there is a second piece that has drawn almost no attention. One of the child-care provisions on the list, § 9858l(a)(4), is not a spending rule at all. It says that when a child-care provider gets 80 percent or more of its operating budget from government, it may not discriminate "because of the religion of such individual" in hiring the people who work directly with children, or in admissions. Strike that, and a daycare running almost entirely on public money can turn your kid away, or turn you down for the job, over what you believe. The opinion says the provision "burdens religious practice only." Read it from the doorway instead of the drafting table and it looks like the one sentence standing between your tax dollars and a religious test.

How the Machine Works

The route from a Supreme Court case about a playground to a soup kitchen in your county runs through four moves, and each one looks small.

Move one: the Court knocked out the old test. In 2022 the justices set aside the framework courts had used since 1971 to police government entanglement with religion, and replaced it with a historical inquiry into what the founding generation would have recognized as an establishment. This opinion is what that looks like once it reaches an agency.

Move two: erase the difference between who you are and what you do. The 2019 OLC opinion drew the same line the statutes draw, asking "whether the restriction is based upon an institution's religious status or whether it is based upon how the federal support would be used." The new opinion abandons it, leaning on the Supreme Court case that already had: Carson v. Makin had ruled that "any status-use distinction lacks a meaningful application not only in theory, but in practice as well."

Move three: declare the line undrawable. This is the clever one. The opinion argues that deciding what counts as "worship" or "instruction" or "proselytization" forces the government into theology, which is itself unconstitutional. Every faith answers those questions differently, so no neutral answer exists. Which means the government is not merely forbidden to draw the line where Congress drew it. It is forbidden to draw one anywhere.

Move four: cut it out clean. Part III.E holds the restrictions "severable from their statutory schemes," so the rest of the welfare law, the health law and the child-care law keep running. The fence comes out. The pasture stays.

The theory riding on top of all this is not hiding. It is the same claim laid out in the Seven Mountain Mandate and staffed out in Project 2025: government is a sphere to be occupied, not a neighbor to be lived beside. You can watch the identical logic running in the statehouses in four states, four Ten Commandments outcomes. What is new here is the mailing address. This one arrived at HHS.

The Strongest Argument on the Other Side

Let me give it to you at full strength, in the opinion's own best example:

"A secular food bank may post advertisements on its walls or announce messages before meals on countless topics, while a church soup kitchen cannot hold a communal prayer before serving a meal."

That is a good argument and it deserves a real answer. If a synagogue and a Rotary club both apply to run the same shelter, and the synagogue has to file extra paperwork proving it kept the mezuzah on a separate ledger, something genuinely unequal is happening. Trinity Lutheran and Carson are not nonsense. A state should not be allowed to hand out a benefit and then pull it back because the applicant is religious. Anybody who has watched a zoning board use "neutral standards" to keep a mosque out of a strip mall knows how that trick works.

Three things, cheerfully.

One: the example is not what the statute does. Nothing in § 604a(j) tells a church it cannot pray over a meal. It tells the church it cannot bill the federal government for the prayer. The HHS rule the opinion complains about asks that explicitly religious activity happen separately in time or location and that the difference be clear to the person standing in line. That is a bookkeeping rule and a notice rule. Whether the congregation prays is entirely up to the congregation, which is exactly the way twelve years of Catholic school taught me the arrangement was supposed to work.

Two: nobody is being excluded here, which is what makes this different from the cases it leans on. Maine excluded religious schools. Missouri excluded a church preschool. Charitable Choice did the opposite. It was written to bring faith-based providers in, and the opinion's own footnote quotes a 1997 law-review account of Senator John Ashcroft, one of its chief architects, arguing that "the focus should not be on whether sectarian organizations receive public funds, but on whether those funds are used for religious activities." The condition attaches to the dollar, not to the applicant. That is the building-versus-sermon line, and it was drawn by people who wanted religious charities funded.

Three: the third move gives the game away. If the government may never decide what worship is, then no line is available at any price, and "we will fund the shelter but not the altar call" becomes a sentence the United States is constitutionally barred from saying. That is not equal treatment. That is a blank check with a Bible verse in the memo line.

The Lever

Three real ones, all still on the books.

The right to a different provider survived. The opinion argues these programs are not coercive, and it leans on 42 U.S.C. § 604a(e) to prove it. If you object to the religious character of the organization serving you, the state has to find you "an alternative provider that is accessible to the individual" at no lesser value. The parallel provision for addiction programs, § 300x-65(e), carries that same alternative-provider right and adds something welfare programs do not have: subsection (e)(2), captioned "Notice," requires the state to "ensure that notice is provided... of the rights of such individuals under this section." None of that was struck. Print it. If you or somebody you love is in one of these programs, that is the paragraph to hand across the desk. In a county with one shelter and one detox bed, the word "accessible" is doing every bit of the work, and that is worth saying out loud to a state administrator.

The states kept their own veto. One subsection past the one DOJ wants gone, § 604a(k) says nothing in the section preempts a state constitution or statute restricting the spending of state funds in or by religious organizations. The child-care law carries the same savings clause at § 9858l(b). Most states run these programs as pass-throughs, which means your legislature and your governor are the second lock on this door.

Watch for the report. OLC told HHS that if it adopts a non-enforcement policy it must notify Congress within 30 days under 28 U.S.C. § 530D. That is a dated document with a name on it. When it lands, it is the receipt that the policy actually changed, and it is the thing to ask your representative's office about, because § 530D routes those reports to congressional leadership and to the chair and ranking member of both Judiciary Committees. As of this writing (checked September 21, 2026), we found no public record that HHS has adopted such a policy or that a report has gone to Congress: no HHS rule or notice in the Federal Register since August 25 that touches these restrictions, nothing in the press releases from HHS or SAMHSA, and no letter about this opinion on the Justice Department's own list of § 530D letters, last updated September 11.

The August 25, 2026 opinion is not a verdict. Congress wrote these sentences and Congress can write them again. A court has not touched them. And the opinion ends on a condition: "Should HHS establish a policy not to enforce those unconstitutional statutory provisions and the Department's attendant regulations, it should report that decision to Congress within 30 days of establishing the policy." The line held for thirty years because both parties agreed on where it went, and the only thing that has changed is that one department's lawyers stopped agreeing.

Come back for the rest

Keep an eye on this one with me. Subscribe to The Long Pour, the free newsletter where the week's small robberies and the one big one land in your inbox together.

Y'all come back, now.


The Receipts

Every load-bearing claim above, traced to a primary source you can open yourself.

  • Constitutionality of Religious Restrictions on the Use of Federal Funds (U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Legal Counsel, August 25, 2026; accessed August 31, 2026): the 39-page opinion: its holding, severability, the covered-program list (p. 29), and its Friedman-quoting Ashcroft footnote (p. 3).
  • Carson ex rel. O.C. v. Makin (Supreme Court of the United States, June 21, 2022, Opinion of the Court, slip op. at 17; accessed September 7, 2026): the status-use quotation the new opinion leans on.
  • Religious Restrictions on Capital Financing for Historically Black Colleges and Universities (U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Legal Counsel, August 15, 2019; accessed September 7, 2026): the 2019 opinion this one retires; the retiring words are the 2026 opinion's own, at its p. 2.
  • 28 U.S.C. § 530D (Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. Code; accessed August 31, 2026): the duty to report a non-enforcement policy to Congress within 30 days, routed to leadership and both Judiciary Committees.
  • 42 U.S.C. § 604a (Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. Code; subsections (j), (e) and (k); accessed August 31, 2026): the lede's quoted sentence, the right to an alternative provider of no lesser value, and the state-constitution savings clause.
  • 42 U.S.C. § 9858l (Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. Code; subsections (a)(4) and (b); accessed August 31, 2026): the bar on religion-based hiring and admissions at providers 80 percent or more government-funded, and the savings clause.
  • 42 U.S.C. § 9858k (Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. Code; accessed August 31, 2026): the child-care restriction, one of the three statutes the opinion names.
  • 42 U.S.C. § 290kk-2 (Office of the Law Revision Counsel, U.S. Code; the substance-abuse treatment restriction; accessed August 31, 2026): third statute; also § 300x-65, whose (e)(1) alternative-provider right and (e)(2) notice duty the Lever cites.
  • 45 C.F.R. § 87.3 (Electronic Code of Federal Regulations; accessed August 31, 2026): subsection (d), the rule that religious activity run "separately, in time or location" from the funded service.
  • Letters Submitted to Congress Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 530D (U.S. Department of Justice, Office of Information Policy, updated September 11, 2026; accessed September 21, 2026): no letter about this opinion on the list.
  • Federal Register search: HHS documents matching "religious" since August 25, 2026 (Office of the Federal Register; accessed September 21, 2026): no documents found.
  • HHS Press Room (U.S. Department of Health and Human Services; accessed September 21, 2026): no release announcing a non-enforcement policy since August 25.
  • SAMHSA Press Room (Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration; accessed September 21, 2026): no release announcing a non-enforcement policy since August 25.